12.1 C
Byron Shire
May 30, 2024

Climate deniers take legal action against bloggers

Latest News

Byron biz digs in for BayFM

The Byron business community gathered at Fishheads for their new menu launch and a fundraiser for Bay FM last week, with $1,360 being raised for the independent radio station.

Other News

Housing: too important to leave to private market

It saddens me every time I get to the back of The Echo and see all the real estate...

Who is responsible?

Teenage (stabbing) crime. Here I go again! Why are these kids allowed out of the house before their parents...

The joy of new talent

Discovering new talent is one of the joys of any comedy festival. Every year the Byron Comedy Festival cherry-picks the brightest and boldest of emerging new talent to present at their annual event. This year they are presenting two of Melbourne International Comedy Festival’s most loved newcomers and stars of their roadshow, Lewis Garnham and Scout Boxall.

Kinship Festival – Unity Celebration

In Murwillumbah 6,000 people celebrated the annual Kinship Festival on Saturday, 25 May with the theme of Yabulgu – Together as one, Unity for our children’s future.

Dutton doubles down on nuclear

Despite clear evidence that the Coalition's nuclear power policy is untenable, Peter Dutton and friends are sticking with this industrial-level distraction, forcing us all to talk about it instead of focusing on real solutions to Australia's energy needs.

Lone Goat Gallery celebrates diversity with ‘Recognise’

About to open at Lone Goat Gallery, Recognise is an exhibition featuring works by local artists Carla Davey, Mathew Daymond, Lydian Dunbar, Shirley Gibson, Nathaniel Harvey, Rebecca King, Willie Mutton, Quinlyn Seikot, Zion Levy Stewart, Gill Williams and Lucas Wright.

Crikey journalist Amber Jamieson reports the US Heartland Institute is threatening legal action against bloggers who published leaked documents the instite now cannot confirm it produced.

Controversial US think tank the Heartland Institute has sent legal letters to bloggers and writers who reported on the release of leaked Heartland Institute documents last week.

The Heartland documents revealed the key donors for the institute, plans for a K–12 curriculum based on a climate science denier agenda and how much well–known climate science denialists are paid to push the anti–climate change agenda for Heartland.

Heartland questioned the authenticity of some of the documents and threatened legal action last week. It proved over the weekend that it was going through with it, with a number of environment writers receiving legal letters.

‘We realize this will be portrayed by some as a heavy–handed threat to free speech,’ announced Heartland president Joseph L Bast in a press release. ‘But the First Amendment doesn’t protect internet fraud, and there is no right to defamatory speech.’

Heartland’s communications spokesperson Jim Lakely told Crikey that so far five media organisations have been sent legal letters: Brendan de Melle from DeSmog Blog, Brad Johnson from ThinkProgress, Arianna Huffington from The Huffington Post, John H. Harris from Politico and Greg Laden, a blogger at ScienceBlogs. However at least one other climate blog received a legal notice notice.

Heartland has republished the letter it emailed to climate news website DeSmogBlog. The legal letter, written by Heartland’s general counsel Maureen Martin states:

‘On or about February 14, 2012, your web site posted a document entitled ‘Confidential Memo: 2012 Heartland Climate Strategy’ (the ‘Fake Memo’), which is fabricated and false.

‘On or about the same date, your web site posted certain other documents purporting to be those of The Heartland Institute (‘Heartland’). Heartland has not authenticated these documents (the ‘Alleged Heartland Documents’).

‘Your site thereafter has reported repeatedly on all of these documents.’

It notes that Heartland is still investigating whether the leaked Heartland documents – excluding what they allege to be a fake climate strategy memo – ‘are authentic or have been altered or fabricated’, although they have been released publicly for five days already:

‘Though third parties purport to have authenticated them, no one – other than Heartland – has the ability to do so. Several of the documents say on their face that they are confidential documents and all of them were taken from Heartland by improper and fraudulent means. Publication of any and all confidential or altered documents is improper and unlawful.’

DeSmogBlog, which first published the leaked Heartlands document dump last week, is refusing to remove any of the documents or articles in question and said it will keep them in place as a matter of public interest.

‘After due consideration, we could see no basis in fact or law for Heartland’s demand that we remove these documents,’ wrote DeSmogBlog founding editor and well–known environment journalist Richard Littlemore.

Crikey spoke to the Vancouver–based Littlemore yesterday. The legal letter is full of ‘logical inconsistencies at the very least’, Littlemore told Crikey.

‘What they are saying is that we’re accusing you of theft but we can’t be sure that the stuff you have is stolen,’ said Littlemore.

‘If the stuff is legitimate, then you can accuse someone of having stolen it. But if you can’t even satisfy yourself that the material is yours, then you’re certainly not in a very good position to tell anyone that they’ve stolen it.’

DeSmogBlog were sent the leaked documents in full after an individual pretended to work at Heartland and convinced the Institute to email them the allegedly confidential documents in full.

‘If any of this turns out to be demonstrably incorrect then we will take that very seriously,’ Littlemore told Crikey. ‘But in the meantime we look forward to reading and writing about the material.’

Greg Laden, a climate blogger at ScienceBlogs who received the legal letter threat, agrees that the legal letter wasn’t clear. Laden thought at first that the legal letter ‘looked like something some crazy denialist made up and sent me’ since the letter he received via email didn’t include his name in full (it’s Gregory), the title was wrong (he’s a doctor) and the address was wrong (he doesn’t live at the address or know anyone who does).

‘As far as I can tell, looking at it no one I know who is a lawyer would retain staff who are as incompetent as those who wrote this letter,’ said Laden.

How can Heartland seek action against a document it says is a fake? ‘They can’t take down a document they have nothing to do with,’ said Laden. ‘If it’s made up and has nothing to do with Heartland, it would be difficult for them to argue that I should take it down off my website.’

But he sees the legal letter as a threat from Heartland against those who write about climate change and climate science. ‘It’s obvious to me Heartland is interested in making people who argue against their point of view quiet,’ said Larden. ‘They want people to shut up.’

Crikey understands The New York Times will reveal the identity of Heartland’s ‘Anonymous Donor’, an individual who has donated $13.7 million to the Heartland Institute since 2007 and at times has provided 60% of the institute’s funding.

Crikey asked Heartland to clarify how long it will take for all of the leaked documents to be authenticated, but we didn’t hear back before deadline.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Only 7 per cent of sexual assaults reported in NSW result in guilty outcome

The latest study from the NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOCSAR), shows that only 7 per cent of sexual assaults reported to NSW Police end up in a guilty verdict in court.

Ballina adopts Corporate Emissions Reduction Plan

After an hour's debate, Ballina Shire Council voted to adopt its own Corporate Emissions Reduction Plan at its last meeting.

Households warned against smoke alarm complacency

Firefighters, NRL stars and other top athletes are urging households across the state to make sure they have working smoke alarms fitted in their homes, as Fire and Rescue NSW (FRNSW) launches its annual Winter Fire Safety Campaign.

Surf like a woman

Local surfing legend Pauline Menczer has told her remarkable story in a new book, 'Surf Like a Woman', which tells the story of how she overcame sexism, homophobia and rheumatoid arthritis to become World Surfing Champion.