6.5 C
Byron Shire
July 23, 2024

PNG deep-sea mine could threaten local fisheries

Latest News

Tweed council catching up on DA backlog

Tweed Shire Council staff say they’re catching up on and reducing the number of outstanding development applications [DAs] lodged locally.

Other News

Valley of Craftsmen at Mullum Farmers Market

Victoria Cosford It’s a pest and a weed, introduced from East Asia and found along most of the east coast,...

Regional ratios rollout NSW begins in Lismore

The NSW Nurses and Midwives’ Association (NSWNMA) has welcomed the announcement of nurse-to-patient ratios at two regional NSW hospitals but has expressed concern over the pace of the phased rollout.

Byron’s foreshore future – a closer look

Plans for Byron Bay’s foreshore are on exhibition until July 31 – Council staff propose options and a ten-year vision for the much-used space, including the removal, or partial removal of the carpark around the pool and Fishheads restaurant. 

Support Tweed’s rough sleepers in Tweed Heads and join the Community Sleepout

Vinnies and Fred’s Place are asking for the residents of the Tweed Shire to come together for a night and experience what it is like to be homeless.

Young readers well catered for with contemporary books and rising stars

This year’s festival features some of the buzziest young authors, including Bri Lee, author of Eggshell Skull with a new novel called The Work. Lee will appear alongside zeitgeisty author Jessie Tu with The Honeyeater.

Missing Gage

Our Gage is still a missing person, after the car was found crashed into a tree on Koonyum Range...


Paula Park, Scidev.net

A debate has erupted over the scientific validity of the environmental impact statement (EIS) of the world’s first deep-sea mine, located off the coast of Papua New Guinea (PNG).

The furore may push the PNG government to convene a further roundtable meeting for experts, before the mine becomes operational next year.

The original impact assessment, which prompted the government to give a green light to the mine in 2009, was ‘completely unacceptable by scientific standards’ and based on ‘second-rate science’, according to a review published by the Deep Sea Mining Campaign pressure group last week (5 November).

It says the EIS — which paved the way for a Canadian company Nautilus being granted a 20-year mining lease in 2011 — failed to adequately assess the risk of metals contaminating fisheries and people.

The PNG government and Nautilus Minerals Inc, the Toronto-based company set to run the Solwara 1 deep-sea mine, claim to be taking the new review seriously, while Coffey Natural Systems, the consultancy firm responsible for the EIS, maintains its assessment was scientifically valid.

Nautilus plans to mine sediments from underwater hydrothermal vents that deposit metals such as copper, gold and silver in heavy concentrations on the region’s sea floor.

The Solwara 1 mine will excavate and pump sediment to a floating platform, where the ore will be extracted and the waste rock returned to the sea floor via pipes.

The 2008 assessment or EIS stated that the project would be ‘socially acceptable, environmentally responsible, technologically achievable and economically viable’.

But the review of that EIS, written by John Luick, a physical oceanographer at the South Australian Research and Development Institute (SARDI), finds it contained ‘serious omissions and flaws’. In particular, these relate to data provided on the speed and direction of currents at different depths, and on the upwelling of material from the seabed.

Because of the omissions, it is impossible to assess adequately the potential contamination to humans and fisheries, the review states.

Furthermore, the EIS understated the risk of metals entering the water through emissions on the seabed, leakage during the pumping process, or spills on the surface, Luick said.

‘They didn’t do a proper analysis,’ he told SciDev.Net.

A spokesman for Nautilus said the company was taking the review seriously and would issue a statement soon.

Gunther Joku, special projects director for PNG’s Department of Environment and Conservation, said he would like to hold a forum, so that the Deep Sea Mining Campaign, Nautilus and any other interested groups can present their views publicly.

This forum would enable scientists to explain what the project is about, and ensure that experts from all interested groups have a space to convene, Joku told SciDev.Net.

‘We [would] also explain what the government does in terms of applying laws to the project,’ he added.

But Coffey Natural Systems stands by its results, and says the PNG environment department even commissioned a second consultancy firm, Cardno, to peer review the EIS before granting Nautilus its environmental permit.

Yet, findings of that review have not been made public, and the scientific community appears divided on the issue.

Chalapan Kaluwin, a professor of environmental science at the University of Papua New Guinea, says, ‘the EIS should have provided a solid basis for the PNG government to decide whether to approve this project, and if so, under what conditions’.

‘The findings of this new report suggest these important decisions were made on the basis of junk science,’ he said.

However, John Wiltshire, associate chair of the University of Hawaii’s ocean and resources engineering department, said he was not concerned by the EIS’s level of analysis.

‘My sense is that Nautilus has done a reasonable amount of work,’ he told SciDev.Net. ‘I don’t think they would have come to a different conclusion if they had done more analysis.’

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

King tide flooding in Ballina

King tides in Ballina are expected to cause minor flooding of some local roads this week.

Teenage girl missing from Coffs Harbour

Police are asking the public for help finding a teenage girl reported missing from the Coffs Harbour area over the weekend.

Ballina motel siege: captives freed after 6 hrs

A man is to face court today after allegedly holding a woman and a small child against their will in a Ballina unit on Friday.

Editorial – Water politics is undrinkable 

Until now, the most significant difference between Mayor Michael Lyon (independent, former Green) and Greens challenger Cr Sarah Ndiaye has been on the Wallum fiasco.