17.5 C
Byron Shire
May 10, 2021

A Hazzard to public health

Latest News

Join Clarkes Beach paddle out this weekend to stop massive oil and gas field project

Hundreds of local surfers and water-lovers will paddle out at Clarke’s Beach over the weekend to protest against a massive oil and gas field proposed for the NSW coast.

Other News

Upside down river

Tim Harrington, Lennox Head Letter contributor Richard White (letters 21/4/21) quite correctly identifies the Richmond River as an ‘upside down river’...

Come and try basketball in Byron

The next generation of female basketball players, with coordinator Karen Irwin, turned up to a ‘come and try day’...

Cartoon of the week – 5 May, 2021

Letters to the editor We love to receive letters, but not every letter will be published; the publication of letters...

Respect for Country

Léandra Martiniello, Whian Whian It is the night of the full moon, I have just watched it rise. On the...

Is hydrogen part of a sustainable energy future?

There’s a lot to like about hydrogen. For starters, it’s abundant. Hydrogen can store excess renewable power. When liquified, it’s more energy intense than fossil alternatives. In a fuel cell, it can generate electricity. When it’s burned, the only by-product is water.

Byron Bay wins season opener against Mullum Giants

  Ross Kendall The local league derby is always  and the Byron Bay Red Devils have won the first game of...

State minister hears from the not-so-silent 87 per cent

Story Melissa Hargraves Photos Jimmy Malecki

The anticipated start to yesterday’s public meeting on coal-seam gas mining was held up by chants of ‘NO CSG’, which filled the Lismore City Hall as frustrated citizens released their unheard concerns.

Because of the overwhelming number of people in attendance, safety issues also delayed the start as the crowd were directed away from emergency exists and onto the stage.

Lismore MP Thomas George organised the meeting with NSW planning and infrastructure minister Brad Hazzard MP and various departmental bureaucrats to answer questions from the 800-plus audience to ‘address concerns surrounding coal-seam gas (CSG) mining and the recent release of the NSW government’s Strategic Regional Land Use Policy (SRLUP)’.

The chants continued as Mr Hazzard attempted to introduce his panel of five ‘experts’, who were in fact all members of government departments or government-funded qangos.

The minister told the audience that ‘the disrespect that is currently being shown by not listening is not helping as this panel are here to help you with your concerns,’ and ‘I would have thought that in Australia we would respect each other’s views’.

The audience jeered loudly at the irony of his comments, given the majority of northern rivers residents feel as if it is they who are not being listened to or respected.

Stakeholders, not shareholders

During an attempt by regional planning and infrastructure bureaucrat Greg Yeates to explain his role, Ian Gaillard of Lock the Gate Northern Rivers, with the aid of a chanting audience, secured a microphone to allow local Indigenous man Mr Kevin Boota to confront the panel on their United Nations obligations and the Native Title Act, which ‘allows the government eighty-five percent mandate of all our land, water, minerals and everything in it’.

The meeting then turned into an attempted question-and-answer process.

Ian Gaillard addressed the panel. ‘This is about stakeholders, not shareholders. Mr Hazzard, there will be people walking up to you and giving you (CSG-free) declarations from their roads. I call on you to accept them all and take note because we are not going to allow this to happen in the catchment of our rivers and tributaries. One thing that you blokes don’t seem to get right is that the environment comes before economy.’

While he was receiving the road declarations, a local resident informed those on the stage that ‘we are mothers, grandmothers and workers and we have our backs to the wall and that is why, Mr George, you have never seen anything like this response before’.

Mr Hazzard told the audience that his government took over from a previous government which had ‘no process or policy structure’ surrounding CSG mining and that they have since engaged in ‘lengthy and comprehensive policy development initiatives to bring together all stakeholders and ensure transparency’.

No provision for refusal

Dan Keary, strategic regional policy director for the Department of Planning and Infrastructure, elaborated on the SRLUP and said that if companies want to mine for CSG on strategic agricultural land ‘they will need to go through the gateway process, which is independent and must be addressed through a DA process’.

Deputy mayor of Lismore, Cr Simon Clough, questioned why the gateway process ‘has no provision for refusal’.

Helen Wagener, a farmer who has a gas well being drilled next door (800m from her house) told the panel that it ‘leaked for near on 12 months’. She then went on to ask the panel and police to empathise with the community, as ‘this hasn’t been easy’.

Mrs Wagener also asked Mr Hazzard and the panel if they had read or were aware of the recent Southern Cross University studies, which detected increased levels of methane surrounding gas fields.

‘I hope that you do not ostracise [the scientists] because of their boldness and for telling the truth.’

Mr Hazzard asked Rob O’Neill, water policy and planning director at the Office of Water, if he could ‘identify any risks surrounding water contamination’.

‘We do have extensive monitoring networks and we do try to establish baseline conditions,’ he replied.

Dr Isaac Santos from SCU, who conducted the recent research that has been rejected by Metgasco, asked the panel to tell the audience how many monitoring wells there were.

Minister Hazzard’s response was ‘the short answer is that we don’t know how many.’

Local research scientist Dr Effie Ablett said that it is too late for assessment after the chemicals have been used as they work at undetectable levels.

‘It takes one molecule of these toxic chemicals that can change a pre-cancerous cell to a cancer cell. The leakage from these wells could cause the largest health threat that we have seen in Australia… research has shown that they leak methane; they will be leaking other chemicals as well.’

Members of the audience also questioned why a representative from the health department was not on the panel.

Climate change was mentioned numerous times as many scientists around the world are continuing to make urgent warnings of the need to shift our energy sources from fossil fuels to renewables.

Adam Guise of CSG Free Northern Rivers informed the panel that ‘methane is twenty to a hundred times more potent than carbon dioxide. How can your government credibly pretend to be taking action on climate change when you are funding and promoting a toxic, dirty industry, which is fossil fuel. Every dollar that is put into fossil fuels is taken away from renewables.’

Chemical pollution

Dr Marion Lloyd-Smith, who has made a study of chemical pollutants, questioned the panel over the testing of chemicals used in CSG mining activities. ‘If you are so comfortable with all the chemicals being used, why is one and a half million dollars of public money going to be spent over the next few years to assess these chemicals?’

Brad Mullard, executive director of mineral resources responded, ‘There are literally thousands of chemicals that can be potentially used. The federal government is undertaking a process of assessing; they can only assess about one hundred. But,’ he added, ‘most of the chemicals are in common use.’

Boudicca Cerese of Lock the Gate Northern Rivers asked Mr Hazzard why the NSW government lifted the moratorium on fracking ‘when the chemicals have not been assessed for their use ‘This is not just about disclosing the chemicals; if you use household chemicals you do not pour borax on your children’s cereal?’

Mr Hazzard had to leave at 12 noon to attend further meetings. He was approached just before entering his car about the comment he made recently to Lismore mayor Jenny Dowell regarding the inevitability of CSG mining in the northern rivers, to which he responded he was ‘misinterpreted’.

More alarming to the audience was the comment by Rob O’Neill, the director of water policy and planning at the Office of Water, who told the audience that ‘surface water is not necessarily connected to the deep ground water’.

It appears the 18 months that the NSW government has spent on establishing procedures for CSG mining has not satisfied the well-informed communities of the northern rivers.

Baseline data, compliance, monitoring and CSG mining exemptions from the SRLUP are all areas of concerns that were not allayed in Mr George’s organised public meeting.

Opponents speak out

Prior to the meeting, the crowd was addressed by a number of speakers who oppose CSG mining in the northern rivers.

Dr Wayne Somerville spoke of the psychological impacts of the threat of CSG mining and also stressed that ‘we cannot wait twenty to thirty years to find out the implications of this industry like we have with asbestos and tobacco; we need to know now’.

Dr Somerville continued, ‘the mining industry can always find people who believe this industry is safe; I can also find people who believe that asbestos and tobacco are safe too’.

Dr Marion Lloyd Smith, whom many in attendance have heard talk of the many unassessed chemicals used in the CSG mining industry, also spoke before the forum.

‘Today, you will probably hear the NSW government say that “you don’t need to worry because soon enough there will be an assessment of these chemicals”. The federal government has given one and a half million of public funds to our national regulator to finally assess the chemicals.

‘What I would like to say and what you won’t hear today is that you will not get any information until 2014; meanwhile the industry continues. Additionally, the regulator has been told that they only look at water impacts. They are not allowed to look at impacts on soil or air, or talk to residents like those at Tara who have already suffered so badly.’

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Best coverage I’ve read so far of this impassioned meeting. Quotes were accurate and informative, because even though present, i found it difficult to hear and even more so to see from my angle. Great job echonetdaily.

  2. Thanks for this detailed, informative article on the Lismore CSG public meeting. The stand that the Northern Rivers community is taking against CSG is heartening for us out in the North West where the biggest CSG field in NSW is being proposed in the unique Pilliga Forest. Thank you to all for all your continued efforts and for questioning this industry and the various levels of Government that stand to profit from it, as boldly and clearly as you are.

  3. Go the Northern rivers we know our subject and will not lie down till the LNP MP’s Page, Proverst and Thomas understand that no means no

  4. Thomas George looks a bit stressed these days. Maybe it is time the poor old fella resigned and let someone with some intellect and courage take over his seat, as long as it is not his sleazy son.

  5. I’m very proud of the way the community conducted themselves at this meeting. There were many questions from local scientists and researchers that went unanswered.

    Despite assurances from the Minister and his ‘expert’ panel that the test wells are being monitored, when asked by Dr Issacs how many wells were being monitored the answer was ‘we don’t know’.

    It is not acceptable to our community or environment to let this industry proceed given the lack of environmental safeguards in relation to public health, water, agricultural land and the environment.

    Hopefully the Government will start to listen to the people and the science as opposed to the short term cash and ex-politician lobbyists that currently have the ears of the NSW Government.

  6. Thank you to the heroes who so eloquently exposed the lies of the NSW government politicians and their bureaucratic cronies, and stood up for our health, water, land, and communities. And thank you, Echo, for the excellent coverage of the event.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Man dead after boat capsizes near Yamba

Police say a man has died and a second has been taken to hospital after a boat capsized south of Yamba this morning.

Jonson Street bus shelter gone and an era ended

Byron Shire Council says that the wooden bus shelter on Jonson Street outside the Byron Visitors Centre is being removed today with all bus services operating from the new bus interchange on Butler Street in Byron Bay

Upside down river

Tim Harrington, Lennox Head Letter contributor Richard White (letters 21/4/21) quite correctly identifies the Richmond River as an ‘upside down river’ and nowhere is this more...

Ballina Dragons’ great results at Urunga

The Ballina Dragon Boat Racing Club is a group of paddling people from all walks of life who enjoy being out on the water having fun and keeping fit.