26 C
Byron Shire
March 8, 2021

What’s the point of another ABC inquiry?

Latest News

Seapeace: the late Tony Maxwell’s wetland legacy

Many curious minds have pondered the purpose of the rice paddy-like waterbodies that scallop the contour lines out into the Ewingsdale coastal plain that can be viewed from St Helena Road.

Other News

Soli becalmed in NSW Pro surf series

Local surfer Soli Bailey has finished in second place at the Mad Mex Maroubra Pro World Surf League Qualifying Series event held at Sydney’s Maroubra beach last weekend.

Rapey Liberal culture is their undoing

Former Liberal staffer Brittany Higgins’ steel-eyed testimony around rape allegations saw spiders crawl from under rocks and spread in all directions last week. 

Be proud of Ballina, help clean up our beaches

This Sunday, 7 March, Ballina Coastcare is inviting everyone who cares about Ballina's environment to Step Up To Clean Up, and join a special event for Clean Up Australia Day.

Fossil investments

Brian Mollet, Mullumbimby It is with considerable incredulity that I read in last week’s Echo that Byron Shire has a lazy...

Byron Wildlife Hospital’s DA up for public comment

A development application for the mobile Byron Bay Wildlife Hospital is now before the public.

Editorial – #ChooseToChallenge the patriarchy

It is easy to think we have almost achieved equality for men and women in a country like Australia – just as long as you don’t think too hard about it.


ABC's Ultimo radio and TV studios, Sydney.
ABC’s Ultimo radio and TV studios, Sydney. Photo Wikipedia

Fiona Martin, The Conversation

Prime minister Tony Abbott may be a fan of institutional inquiries and a critic of supposed ABC bias, but he has nothing to gain by responding to calls for yet another review of the ABC.

First, there’s no clear need for a review. Claims of ABC bias are always tenuous, especially given the extensive accountability framework developed over six years by former editorial policies director Paul Chadwick – after the 2003 inquiry into allegations by former communications minister Richard Alston of biased coverage of the Iraq war.

Bias is a less persuasive rationale after yesterday’s announcement about “editorial audits” on information programming. ABC chairman James Spigelman told the National Press Club that the ABC has already begun to commission industry experts to do up to four impartiality checks annually on coverage of contentious political issues such as asylum seeking.

That leaves crowding out in digital markets as a point of contention. However, this is also a weak rationale in the Australian context.

As creative industries pioneer Stuart Cunningham has argued in his latest book, public service media like the ABC can have a sponsoring – rather than chilling – effect on innovation, at least where its competitors are not already in position to do research and development and where it isn’t the dominant market player.

Two examples illustrate this. The ABC’s online streaming service, iView, is a model for video-on-demand services that has yet to be matched locally for usability and functionality. The ABC has also set an accessibility benchmark with its television audio description trials for blind Australians.

Spigelman acknowledged yesterday that the ABC does compete to some extent in service delivery. Yet it was designed to do this after the 1982 Dix Inquiry, which found the national broadcaster was: ‘… slow-moving, overgrown, complacent, and uncertain of the direction in which it is heading’.

Dix triggered the then-Australian Broadcasting Commission’s transformation into a public enterprise, with innovation added to its charter. This laid the groundwork for its digital expansion.

However, despite the claims made by News Corp columnist Andrew Bolt that the ABC stole fact-checking website PolitiFact’s thunder, its online news presence seems to have had little impact on the scope of competition.

Clearly it was not a deterrent to the UK’s The Guardian or Daily Mail setting up online Australian editions.

Predictably, News Corp has led the push for an inquiry for ideological and commercial reasons. That, historically, has simply been its modus operandi.

Back in the 1930s, the then-CEO of the Herald & Weekly Times, Sir Keith Murdoch, argued the ABC shouldn’t be broadcasting radio in competition with private operators, or delivering independent news. Now his son Rupert tweets his unhappiness about state-funded and leftist media: ‘BBC massive taxpayer funded mouthpiece for tiny circulation leftist Guardian. Meanwhile print media about to be gagged to protect toffs’ [— Rupert Murdoch (@rupertmurdoch) October 6, 2013].

Yet the BBC, News Corp’s bête noire, has come up with a market value test that makes its developmental agenda more open to competitive scrutiny. This is something Rupert should applaud.

Public value testing

In 2005, the BBC introduced a two-step public value testing process that would help it justify the rationale for any new digital operations. Since then, its market impact assessment model has been widely adopted across Europe as a way of increasing the transparency and rigour of product and service development.

But these so-called ex-ante tests have also generated long, costly and ultimately ritualistic verification processes.

In Norway, national broadcaster NRK’s 2011 bid to develop a web-based travel planner with three public sector partners took 18 months, four levels of review and royal intervention to resolve in its favour. The project folded shortly after approval.

Inquiries like this make blunt policy instruments and may undermine the process of innovation they were mean to serve.

Fiona Martin is senior lecturer in convergent and online media at University of Sydney.
This article first appeared in
The Conversation.



Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Caravan park to pay $2.3mil plus to consumers

The NSW Court of Appeal has upheld the Supreme Court’s decision arising from the sale of the movable dwellings located on waterfront sites along the Tweed River.

Government modelling fails to reflect women’s interrupted careers

New research to be released this week analyses two decades of Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) Survey to estimate the actual labour force experience of women over their life and accounts for working when super is not paid.

Ballina cleans up!

Clean Up Australia Day was a great success in Ballina, with the beach clean up event organised by Ballina Coastcare yesterday attracting twenty volunteers.

Lismore future councillor information sessions

With the delayed Local Government elections being held in September, several councils, including Lismore City Council, are holding information sessions for community members who are thinking about running for Council.