20.2 C
Byron Shire
July 27, 2021

Pirate ship under attack

Latest News

With avocados, farmer fresh is best

There are many different avocado varieties, but walk around the supermarket and you might get the impression there is...

Other News

A disappointing limbo? Byron candidates on delayed council elections

Mr Dey, incumbent Mr Lyon and four other mayoral candidates were already busy campaigning for the top spot when NSW Local Government Minister Shelly Hancock delayed the election for a second time.

Vax zombies

Paul Stephen, Yamba Will Ash denounces The Echo for being pro-vax (9 July). The Echo is just being pro-science, and supporting...

Artificial reefs for coastal erosion control

The building of seawalls has been the subject of a controversial court case brought against BSC in recent years. What are the other options?

Community pantry opens in Mullum

Locals can now get quality grocery items for considerably less than the cost of buying them at the supermarket, after the Mullumbimby Neighbourhood Centre opened a new community pantry.

Our water future – Rous County Council

Hugh Nicholson, The Channon A spokesperson for Our Future Northern Rivers (OFNR), explains clearly why the OFNR position on water...

Local Labor

Asren Pugh, Labor candidate for Mayor Labor has a very long and proud history as part of the Byron Shire community...

Operator of the Brunswick Buccaneers boat hire business, Ilan Schnitzler, is not happy with North Coast Holiday Parks’ moves to evict him. Photo Eve Jeffery

For 30 years, Brunswick Buccaneers has been an icon of Brunswick Heads, but now the tourist attraction is under threat from NSW government bureaucrats.

An eviction notice was served ‘without warning’ last Easter by Colin Woodbry from North Coast Holiday Parks (NCHP) to operator Ilan Schnitzler, who has for the last 15 years hired boats, kayaks, canoes and paddle boards from his pirate ship on the river opposite the pub.

Additionally, Echonetdaily has learned that NSW Crown Lands area manager Nessbit Hurcum has hand-balled responsibility of the surrounding parks and waterways to the secretive NCHP and is ‘reluctant to go against the recommendations’ of its Trust manager and former Byron Shire Council staff employee, Jim Bolger.

In a startling reply to Echonetdaily enquiries, Mr Bolger refuses to explain his decision to evict Mr Schnitzler and, like NCHP’s financial records, his actions remain cloaked in secrecy.

Mr Bolger said ‘the Trust will not take part in discussing licence or legal issues through the media’.

It’s the latest public relation blunder and take-over bid by the state government-owned and privately-run corporation: three Brunswick Heads caravan parks and foreshore land that were previously managed by Council were controversially taken away in 2006.

An Echonetdaily investigation later revealed that after that take-over, Council are now much worse off financially for it.

Additionally, residents criticised NCHP over the caravan parks’ subsequent encroachment on footpaths, roads and foreshores.

So far, the only state MP to be critical of the lack of transparency with the cost shifting and loss of amenity to locals is NSW MLC Jan Barham, who is also a former Byron Shire mayor.

And like other residents of Brunswick Heads, Mr Schnitzler is putting up a fight.

Eviction reasons vague

Mr Schnitzler says the consent authority of the waterway is Crown Lands, despite being ‘vaguely threatened’ by NCHP about having customers ‘illegally’ use the steps from Banner Park as an embarkation point.

‘I received a letter by NCHP last Easter saying my lease had been terminated because of unpaid rent,’ Mr Schnitzler told The Echo.

‘I was given just four days to leave, and an extension of two weeks if I paid the $300 that was owing. There was no warning. They claimed I did not pay them rent, but I never received those letters. It was a very unprofessional letter.’

He says his tenure with Council to operate on Simpsons Creek rolled over to NCHP after it took control.

This also includes access to Banner Park, where his boat is moored.

But after engaging a solicitor to defend the eviction, Mr Schnitzler says he was advised that Crown Lands have jurisdiction on the creek, ‘as the boat is moored below the mean high water mark and that is where the Banner Park boundary ends’.

However Crown Lands have hand-balled responsibility instead to NCHP.

Mr Schnitzler’s legal representative, Claire Lovejoy, told Echonetdaily that ‘it appears from [Crown Lands area manager] Nessbit Hurcum’s last email that the only reason they are not giving Mr Schnitzler a permit to stay in the Crown Lands creek is because NCHP won’t give him a permit for customers to access the stairs.

‘So while he is moored in Crown Lands jurisdiction, NCHP are involved because customers enter through Banner Park,’ Ms Lovejoy said.

‘I have been verbally advised by Marine Parks, and Ilan has said RMS (Roads and Maritime Services) have said they will also provide their permits once he gets ‘tenure’ to stay.

‘That can only come through Crown Lands, who say they will only provide it if NCHP allow the customers to access the stairs,’ she said.

While Mr Schnitzler says he received no return calls or emails after asking Crown Lands to intervene, Ms Lovejoy says she received an email from Mr Hurcum advising her client that he was ‘reluctant to go against the recommendations’ of the NCHP reserve trust manager and offer a separate tenure.

Instead, Mr Hurcum suggested that as plans of management for the reserves are now on display for comment, ‘it may be an appropriate avenue for you to raise this matter through comment, for discussion and adoption, given the iconic nature of your client’s enterprise’.

MP ‘surprised’ 

The eviction plans by bureaucrats at NCHP and the hand-balling of responsibility by Crown Lands were also kept a secret from NSW minister for north coast, Don Page (Nationals).

It raises the question as to what accountability the NCHP corporation has to the government and suggests Mr Bolger and his bureaucrats are undermining the authority of the politicans, and therefore the public, whom they are supposed to serve.

While Mr Page didn’t answer Echonetdaily’s question as to whether he was happy with Jim Bolger’s performance as NCHP manager, he did say, ‘I do receive briefings from time to time on Crown land issues in Brunswick Heads but I’ve not been briefed on the Brunswick Buccaneers situation’.

As for the lack of transparency by NCHP, Mr Page said he was ‘surprised to hear’ that NCHP is refusing to explain its actions.

‘I believe and the government believes in transparency, so an explanation should be made.’ He added that he will follow up the case this week.

Meanwhile, Mr Schnitzler’s operation remains in limbo as he has no current permit to stay in the creek.

It comes as plans of management for Brunswick Heads caravan parks and foreshores by NCHP were put on public display.

So far, the plans have been slammed by residents for what they say is ‘pursuing maximum profits without regard for social or environmental impacts’.

Additionally, a plan by NCHP to remove an 80-year-old forest redgum (Eucalyptus Tereticornis) in Banner Park recently angered locals who successfully fought to retain it ten years ago after it was also then deemed dangerous.

Byron Shire Council staff instead have recommended the fate of the tree will be left up to councillors at its February 14 meeting.

Both NCHP’s Colin Woodbry and Crown Lands area manager Nessbit Hurcum were contacted but did not reply by the time of going to press.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. You’ve got to be kidding.
    Ilan’s business has been an iconic part of Brunswick Heads for decades.
    Another example of petty bureaucracy with nothing better to do than make people’s lives miserable.
    The NCHP has once again demonstrated it’s lack of interest in Brunswick Heads’ locals opinions.
    I wonder who’s making money out of all this subterfuge?

  2. I remember running it for a while in 1990! It is a part of Brunswick surely these bureaucratic dunderheads can see that!! At least he’s got a good solicitor on board in Claire lovejoy

  3. Sounds like the hot weather is making the bureaucrats grumpy. It’s too bad that they always pick on the little bloke who’s scratching a living and lending some friendly atmosphere to the place.
    Feed ’em to the sharks at Byron Bay!

  4. North Coast Holiday Parks is not ‘privately run’. It is owned and operated by Crown Lands NSW and that corporation bestows power to its agents operating its assets.

    In case anyone needs to be disabused of the notion that council have a say in this, it is important to point out that the ‘Crown’ is a perpetual corporation based in the motherland and the lands under its control are only the concern of council if that council is a nominated trustee or custodian.

    NCHP is extending its remit to manage income generating assets (holiday parks) on Crown reserves to managing all economic activity on those reserves.

    Crown Lands has its own sovereign reserve trust distinct from council

  5. Duncan, even the ‘crown’ is a political body that should be responsive to the communities desires. And the fact that the crown delegates authority in no way gives that authority the right to carry on activities that the local community seriously dislikes – quite apart from any issues that might arise such as corruption or plain bloody mindedness.
    Consultation and negotiation are part of any modern society – the unfettered right of the crown vanished with the Magna Carta.

  6. Brunswick would certainly be a lesser place without the Brunswick Buccaneer. We have to protect this one. Perhaps get rid of the caravan park?

  7. stick staunch llan a lot of ;locals will get down and get behind you organise a peacefull protest and involve national media they are not only threatening a local icon and business but they are also going to destroy this fella’s income and living standards

  8. NO way No way… We need to have a Save the Buccaneer rally and quick! While tourists are still around! Everyone could dress as pirates and we would get a lot of national media exposure and save the iconic vessel!
    I am sure it couldn’t be too hard to organise!!!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Ink Gin still a winner

S Haslam Has it already been six years since I first saw a demonstration of the curious colour-changing properties of the innovative Ink Gin at...

Magnificent sporting prowess and flag pride after 2021 NAIDOC

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people also shone in the sporting arena during NAIDOC 2021. 

Independent councillor calls for online voting

A manageable and easy-to-navigate system was necessary, Cr Allsop said, one that allowed 'equal presence for all candidates'.

Byron Farmers Markets temporarily moved to make way for COVID clinic

The Byron Farmers Market is to be held opposite Elements resort on Bayshore Drive this week, while health authorities use the Cavanbah Centre for a drive-through COVID testing service.