26.1 C
Byron Shire
February 25, 2021

Is there asylum seeker blood on my hands?

Latest News

‘Hollywood’ drug squads over the top

I guess we have to thank Hollywood for the enduring myth that a black-clad squad of elite 'blokes', preferably with cool helicopters, from the capital are needed to crack down on really serious crime in hick parts of the country like Mullumbimby.

Other News

Ready for Byron’s latest massive development on Jonson St?

The changing face of Byron as Gold Coast and Sydney developers move in to recreate the look and feel of the town with intense development proposals.

Interview with Michael Balson, creator of Ocean to Sky

Local filmmaker helps tell the story of Edmund Hillary’s last adventure, in the film, Ocean to Sky

Update: Main Arm raids… The police are in Mullum!

After several reports today from readers that there is a 'massive drug operation' and a 'gun and drug unit from Parramatta!', an intrepid Echonetdaily drudge wandered over to Barry Lomath Oval next to the skate park and netball courts in Mullum.

Byron police assault trial could attract human rights law analysis

Northern Rivers policeman accused of youth assault to continue facing trial.

Last minute water park unsuccessful as Jack Evans Boat Harbour PoM approved

A last minute attempt by Councillor Warren Polglase (conservative) to introduce a water park as part of the Jack Evans Boat Harbour Plan of Management (PoM)at last nights Tweed Shire Council saw yet another ‘workshop’ set up for councillors to discuss the implications.

TGA obstructs prescription psilocybin, MDMA

Imagine that some crazy professors convince a bunch of participants at a five-day mindfulness retreat to agree to take part in an experiment where half of them are given magic mushrooms, and half of them a placebo.

Protesters carry placards at a 'Welcome Refugees' rally in Sydney recently after a vessel carrying an estimated 120 asylum-seekers sank in rough seas of of Indonesia, claiming 22 lives, including children. AFP photo/William West
Protesters carry placards at a ‘Welcome Refugees’ rally in Sydney recently after a vessel carrying an estimated 120 asylum-seekers sank in rough seas of of Indonesia, claiming 22 lives, including children. AFP photo/William West

Lauren Smith*, through Crikey.com

Why did ordinary men participate in the killing process during the Holocaust? This essay question in a university subject put me on the path that I am on today. I have travelled the world analysing the behaviour of people involved in war.

People react differently to war. A range of emotions take over: anger, pain, grief, loss, sadness, frustration and denial.

But in every person I have seen fear. Then I have heard blame: someone else is responsible for these killings.

Usually, the people I am talking to do not feel responsible, including the perpetrators.

People on all sides believe they are ‘the goodies’ and that their actions were justified: the perpetrators, the victims, the bystanders.

And I was the same when confronted with being involved in the war on refugees.

Believing I was doing a ‘good’ job helping support people escaping war, I took work with the protection visa section of the Department of Immigration.

I was providing administrative support to people determining who was a ‘genuine’ refugee and who was not.

Our team was determining which ‘boat people’ could stay in the safety of Australia and who would be returned.

Shortly after joining this section I realised that the Australian government and some of my colleagues were seriously endangering innocent people by returning them to unsafe countries.

Throughout all of this I convinced myself that it was not my fault, I wanted to do good things but couldn’t.

I blamed everyone else, I blamed the government, I blamed the officers. I blamed the Australian public for electing the government.

In May 2013, I went to Christmas Island, an experience that began to unravel my comforting alibis. I began to understand my participation in these callous and life threatening processes.

I was there to organise screening interviews for Sri Lankan clients. Many of these clients were poor fisherman, coming to Australia as they would die of starvation if they stayed in Sri Lanka.

As they were viewed as ‘economic refugees’, the government saw an opportunity to send a strong message: they were not wanted in Australia.

A secret process was created: enhanced screening. This denied these asylum seekers access to legal representation and proper protection during interviews.

The aim was simply to send them back as quickly as possible. Sri Lanka is one of few countries to which Australia has the right to forcibly return asylum seekers.

This opportunity was seized, ignoring much evidence that, for these asylum seekers, a return to Sri Lanka could imperil their lives.

In the north of Sri Lanka, there is still mass corruption and discrimination. This is affecting people’s livelihoods and starving desperate fisherman.

These ‘economic refugees’ are still imperilled by war’s prejudicial aftermath. I saw starving mothers holding newborn babies come off these boats.

No matter what anyone says, there must be very serious reasons why they had risked their lives and the lives of their children to come to Australia.

Their starvation was directly linked to the political climate of their country.

However, Australia refuses to recognise this as a valid reason to claim refuge. So we returned these people, very possibly to die.

For a while I continued to delude myself that this wasn’t my fault. I didn’t make these decisions, the protection visa officers did.

These people, these Sri Lankans, chose to take this journey. They understood the risk. And if they didn’t understand, the ‘people smuggler’ did. The people smugglers were surely to blame.

However, the day I returned from Christmas Island I was told 28 life jackets had washed up on the shores of Cocos Island, an Australian island.

Some 28 Iranian refugees had been killed in Australian waters.

I was devastated to learn this, but I begun to put together the pieces of the puzzle. For a week while I was on Christmas Island, I had been waiting for that boat to arrive on shore, so we could assess their claims for asylum.

Hearing the news they had died sent me into a state of shock. I realised it was not the dangerous journey or the people smugglers that had killed these people, it was we Australians.

We knew for a week they were close to our shores, we were constantly monitoring them, and we let them die.

We knew they were in trouble, and we chose not to save them. Furthermore, this was published in the newspaper, and Australian citizens just ignored the fact that our government believed it had the right to choose who lives or dies.

As I grappled with the seriousness of the situation, I had to ask myself some tough questions.

Could I justify continuing to work for this department? I finally realised that although my intentions were good, my involvement had implicated me in these deaths.

Ultimately, I chose to leave the department rather than to continue to implement policies that: sent people back to their homelands risking their death; allowed people to drown in Australian and Indonesian waters; and detained people indefinitely in harsh conditions, with limited access to water, food and medical treatment.

Unequivocally, we Australians are causing severe mental and physical harm to fellow human beings.

In the American justice system, if you witness a crime and do nothing to try and stop it, you are guilty by association.

However, Australians do not have this obligation. This perplexes me, as the legal system should be a reflection of our morals and values.

Protecting the vulnerable in society should not be choice but a moral obligation.

In the end, if you do not help save someone’s life, you are, in some measure, responsible for their death.

Amid all the proud flag-waving this Australia Day weekend, I was unable to raise my flag. I did not feel comfortable celebrating the current pain Australia is causing other human beings and I know I was not alone.

Many Australians cannot frankly face the implications of our governments’ policies that deny others’ human rights and terrorise vulnerable people seeking our help.

But we pretend we are not involved, that we do not know what is happening or we deny responsibility.

Every Sunday, Catholics like Tony Abbot attend church to remember Jesus’ life and his struggle to spread peace and stop unnecessary suffering.

On Anzac Day we remember all those who have died at war and we say ‘lest we forget’.

However, we appear to have forgotten what it means, that we should not forget the past: that people have died in many wars to help bring peace.

We can remember our past and learn from it, we can remember our journeys and celebrate our achievements.

And, living in the present, we can forgive past mistakes and commit to not repeat them.

When we see a problem we should try to resolve it quickly so it does not escalate into a crisis and harm us or others.

A civilisation is judged by how it treats the most vulnerable. I fear Australia has been found guilty of crimes against humanity, and no one seems able to talk about it, to reflect on what is being done.

If someone is in trouble it is our responsibility to help them out.

We should not let people drown at sea; we should bring them safely to our shores.

Once here, they should not be left to languish in interminable limbo, but helped to get on with their lives and to contribute meaningfully to Australia, like so many migrants who have come before them.

*Lauren Smith worked as an administration officer for the Department of Immigration. She now works in refugee support services, and is the co-founder of non-profit group Learning & Ideas for Tibet. She is calling for signatures on a Change.org petition to protest government policy.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Lauren and others miss the point.
    Australia is extremely generous when it comes to settling refugees. According to some analysis we are among the highest on a per capita basis. In addition Australia resettles millions of immigrants in our country. we always have.The average annual settlment is north of 200,000 per year.
    Refugees and immigrants are screened for suitability and refugees are accepted via UN sponsored processors.
    The wicked event in 2008 was when the Labor and Greens combined for a Kumbaya moment (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kumbaya) to dismantle John Howards successful Border Protection Policy.
    Rabbitting on about compassion, opening our borders to all and the visual Group Hugs between Bob Brown, Gillard, Wong, Christine Milne et al set Australia on a disastrous open border policy.
    The ensuing border chaos, loss of a reported more than 1,000 lives at sea, 50,000 uninvited and unselected economic tourists (sponsored by the business model of the people smugglers)…..all at a reported cost of $15-20 Billion Australian taxpayers Dollars. This is the equivalent of 1,500,000 dole or pension payments for one year…..go figure the equivalent in schools, child care, medical research, international aid.
    This warm inner glow policy was the pinnacle of Labor/Green stupidity.
    The electorate judged the policy on 7th September last year.
    One of the most basic responsibilities of ANY country is to regulate who and how foreigners come into the country. Australia has been doing it generously, compassionately, effectively and fairly under John Howard’s border policy.
    We are still waiting for the apology from labor and greens for the border debacle of the Rudd/Gillard/Rudd adventure. Instead we get bleating nonsense from people like Lauren and Getup.
    give me a break…………..

  2. A truly great, moving story. Congratulations, Lauren Smith for telling it. We need more Australians like you.
    We MUST push for questioning and reflective time NOW in Australia. It is already too late on many fronts as so much of our present Government views are reinforcing the uglier aspects of Australian power hungry, macho characteristics. The results are already plainly, visually, painfully apparent. It’s daily news. Let’s sign Lauren’s change.org petition to the government. Rethink, Reshape, Recharge Australia, so we can be truly proud of our nation into the future!

  3. Thank you Lauren for your well written story. Shame on Australia for our treatment of people who are suffering. May we all gather courage to speak and find ways to be heard.
    Mati Jo beams

  4. Geoff [you don’t seem to have] the heart or the brains to see the truth! We are all boat people, unfortunately lead by a gutless male called Tony Abbott !who in the last five months has destroyed anything positive about being Australian
    Check out abbotts 89 atrocities via Sally McManus

  5. These people coming by boat are going about it all the wrong way. The people are paying huge money (in there dollar) to travel here and how can you call them poor? one would think you would by a loaf of bread and feed ya kids… Australia has a system that they can apply and if all the boxes are ticked they will be resettled safely here in Australia. Well done Aussie Government!! you have my vote.

  6. Geoff, John and especially Toe Knee Abbot give me no reason to feel proud to be an Australian. Thank goodness for people like Lauren.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Local fisherfolk caught in the parking fine net

FIsherfolk have been caught in the net of parking fines designed to stop travellers parking up for the night on the Tweed Coast Road and they are seeking help to access their beaches at night without fines.

Family Court scrapped

Despite overwhelming opposition from Australia’s family law specialists and advocates, the federal Liberal-Nationals government and cross benchers scrapped the Family Law Court and subsumed it into the circuit courts last week.

Cavanbah centre gets a taste of 3×3 basketball

The Byron Beez basketball team in collaboration with the U League hosted a 3x3 tournament at the Cavanbah centre at the end of January that attracted 30 teams.

Northern Rivers policeman accused of youth assault acquitted

Magistrate Michael Dakin has ordered a common assault charge against a former Byron-based policeman be dropped after an altercation involving a naked youth in Byron Bay three years ago.