28.1 C
Byron Shire
December 9, 2021

Green levy plan for Tweed knocked down

Latest News

Byron Shire Council elections still being counted

There are 25,414 registered voters in the Byron Shire local government area (LGA) who are responsible for electing a...

Other News

Voting options on paid parking

Council paid parking in Byron Bay, and National Parks NSW paid parking, has ruined the amenity we once had,...

Editorial – Council restart and the most unsafe house in the nation 

Expectations of government have been undermined – so where to from here and how to rebuild a nation based on good politics.

Issue dividing the community

This bitter division in the Northern Rivers community regarding trains on our tracks or the rail trail could’ve been...

Jo Jo Smith back in town for one show only

It will be a night to remember with Jo Jo Smith back in town for a performance at the Mullumbimby Ex-Services Club this Saturday, 11 December.

Legal aid funding inadequate, say Law Council of Australia

The nation’s top law advocacy group is calling on the government for adequately resourced Legal Aid Offices, owing to unmet demand for the service.

True non-partisan leadership of Ballina Shire Council over

A reign of non-partisan leadership in the Ballina Shire may well be over, with conservative independent Sharon Cadwallader leading the mayoral vote tally by lunchtime Tuesday.

Tweed River bank erosion is the initial focus of the proposed environmental levy. Photo Frank Smith www.geograph.org.uk)
Tweed River bank erosion was the initial focus of the now halted environmental levy. Photo Frank Smith www.geograph.org.uk)

Luis Feliu

Tweed ratepayers have been spared a proposed environmental levy that would have added an average of around $13 a year to their rates bill.

Tweed shire councillors last night decided to defer consideration of the one-per cent, 10-year levy which pro-development Cr Warren Polglase had proposed in order to leverage state funding for six major environmental projects.

The levy plan now has to wait to be considered till after a shire-wide environmental sustainability strategy is completed, an assessment of other funding sources for such projects, and an assessment of the community’s ‘capacity to pay’ for it.

Debate on the issue at the meeting at Banora Point Community Centre, the first one to be held outside council’s Murwillumbah headquarters in five years, dragged on for almost an hour as up to 25 locals, many from the local residents group, watched on.

Last month’s decision by councillors to consider the levy in the 2014-15 budget deliberations only included funding for Tweed River bank management (such as rock revetment to prevent further erosion),

But that was rescinded on a motion by Crs Polglase, Gary Bagnall and Carolyn Byrne with a 5-2 vote (Crs Bagnall, Byrne against).

Cr Polglase said the reason for the rescission motion and change of mind on his original proposal, which only included the Tweed River project, came about after lobbying by environmental groups, and he now had a ‘better idea’ to expand the programs for funding by the levy.

But his replacement motion (which included biodiversity and bushland management, vertebrate pest management, sustainable agricultural program, sustainability programs, integrated water cycle management, and riverbank management) was narrowly defeated 3-4 (Crs Polglase, Byrne and Youngblutt for).

Cr Polglase had argued that a ‘broader view’ of what projects should be funded was needed and the community would be also be given more opportunity for their input.

His stance drew praise from an unusual quarter, with the Greens Cr Milne commending him for ‘introducing the levy plan in the first place and not just picking one project’.

Financial stress

Deputy mayor Michael Armstrong, a staunch opponent of the levy, said an informal briefing to councillors recently had provided ‘disturbing facts’ about the capacity to pay of many Tweed ratepayers, especially pensioners, with 40 per cent of locals already under financial pressure.

‘Are we hurting the people of the Tweed by rushing this? Let’s have a thorough assessment of whether people who live here can afford it,’ Cr Armstrong said.

‘We also need a proper review of the projects and be guided by the (environment) strategy.

‘What’s the point of slugging ratepayers with a one per cent increase if funding can be sought from other sources?’ Cr Armstrong said.

But Cr Polglase said it would take too long to wait for the strategy and assessments to be completed, at least over two years, which would hold funding for environmental projects back.

He said the levy was only a $2.55 a week, or around $12-to-$13 a year, ‘and I’m sure many people in the community can afford it’.

He said some councillors had always talked about protecting the environment and now should ‘show leadership and direction’ in finding ways of getting funding for environmental projects.

‘We’ve had a workshop, now let’s get the feedback,’ Cr Polglase said.

Cr Youngblutt said many ‘renters’ would not have to pay the levy and only ratepayers had to, drawing flak from Cr Milne who said the remarks were ‘derogatory to the public’.

But Cr Youngblutt said ‘It is ratepayers. And the ones I’ve spoken to are happy to go ahead with this for the environment’.

Cr Byrne said environmental costs had to be managed and could only be done if funding was available.

She said it was ‘a small levy to be able to leverage other funding’ and ‘another bucket of money’ available only for the environment’.

‘If we defer this, it will take another two to four years before we get started,’ she said, adding that such a delay ‘equates to $2 million in lost funding’ which could fund ‘lots of projects’.

‘I know rocks on the riverbank is not a pretty sight although they soften over time,’ she said, referring to the riverbank erosion project in the original decision for the levy funding.

Cr Milne said the shire had 3,000 hectares of bushland which was ‘extremely onerous’ to manage and ‘as much as I’d love to get the levy done this year, it may not be used for the best environmental outcomes’.

She said the riverbank project was not supported by the Tweed River Advisory Committee and councillors should ‘pull back’ from the levy plan till the environmental strategy was done.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Just another booooollllshhhheeeeeeeeet tax scam. If council wants to spend $$$$ on environmental stuff it should be funded no differently to all other council responsibilities ergo thru their current method of revenue collection. For example council chose to spend a lot of money on a art gallery that loses hundreds of thousands of dollars and counting. Instead they could have chosen to spend the art gallery money on the environment. They could close the art gallery and transfer the covered losses by directing it to the environment. The art gallery is merely one possibility among many.

  2. The erosion of our river and creek banks is quite shocking, and I am surprised that not too much has been done about it already. How about the council considering guidelines for properties that own creek and river frontage lands. A 10m buffer zone along the creek fronts to allow riparian zones to re-establish. Where cows and horses are fenced out. Also to steer current budget spending to revegetate the riparian zones.
    Please help us save our creeks and rivers


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Alcohol-free zones to continue in Ballina Shire

Four areas of public land in the Ballina Shire are to stay alcohol-free zones for at least another three years.

Work is starting on Tweed Rail Trail

The Tweed Council section of the Northern Rivers Rail Trail is a 24km section that stretches from the Murwillumbah Railway Station to Crabbes Creek and work is starting on the construction.

Jo Jo Smith back in town for one show only

It will be a night to remember with Jo Jo Smith back in town for a performance at the Mullumbimby Ex-Services Club this Saturday, 11 December.

NORPA announces stellar 2022 season

This morning in a special online event, NORPA revealed some of the adventurous, world-class shows that will transport audiences to different worlds in 2022.