12.1 C
Byron Shire
May 18, 2024

Do we have to rely on bankers to protect the planet?

Latest News

Brunswick 30 has been delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour

Following successful sea trials at Yamba the Brunswick 30 was delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour on Wednesday, May 15. 

Other News

Saffin welcomes Neighbourhood Centre Week

NSW Labor Member for Lismore Janelle Saffin has welcomed today’s start to Neighbourhood Centre Week across the country.

First baby born at new Tweed Valley Hospital

The new Tweed Valley Hospital opened on May 14 at Kingscliff and it saw its first baby born that day at 8.53pm.

Brunswick 30 has been delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour

Following successful sea trials at Yamba the Brunswick 30 was delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour on Wednesday, May 15. 

Commemorating ten years since V Day at Bentley

It's ten years today since a wave of relief spread through Camp Liberty at Bentley, when those gathered discovered that the riot police would not be coming, and gas company Metgasco was being referred to ICAC by the NSW government.

Cartoon of the week – 15 May, 2024

The Echo loves your letters and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most to our readers and the people of the NSW north coast. So don’t be a passive reader, send us your epistles.

Motorcyclist flown to hospital from New Italy

At about 3pm yesterday, Tuesday 14 May, the Westpac Rescue Helicopter was tasked by NSW Ambulance to the Pacific Highway, New Italy following reports of a motorcyclist suffering serious leg injuries after collision with a barrier.

Photo: The Banker by Jason de Caires Taylor through reneweconomy.com.au
Image: The Banker, by Jason de Caires Taylor, through reneweconomy.com.au

Giles Parkinson, reneweconomy.com.au

Just before Christmas, leading Citigroup analyst Elaine Prior took Australia’s coal freight giant Aurizon to task over the lack of board engagement on the science of climate change.

The board, which is considering taking the lead role in a $6 billion investment in an upgrade of the Abott Point coal port and a new rail line to the massive coal mines in the Galilee Basin, did not have climate change on the radar.

In fact, Prior observed, there was no strategic assessment of climate at senior management and board level, and it barely rated a mention in the sustainability report. Little wonder, then, that there had been no apparent investigation as to whether the massive investment may end up as a stranded asset.

Prior’s assessment gained no headlines, had no visible impact on the Aurizon share price, and may not have even been noticed by the Aurizon board.

But in the light of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority’s approval to dump three million tonnes of sediment from the Abbott Point expansion project into the marine park, and the determination of the Abbott federal government and the Newman state government to develop the Galilee Basin deposits, partly owned by the likes of Gina Rinehart, Clive Palmer and others, the only thing that could stop the projects is the lack of finance and support in the investment community.

Financial markets have not always taken the environment into account.

If, as green groups have assessed, the Galilee Basin resources are one of a number of global “carbon bombs”, then it seems the only people likely to save the planet are bankers.

Given their track record in sub-prime and other disasters, it may not be a comforting thought.

But, at least, banks and financial analysts are starting to take on board issues that many corporates, and Australian state and federal governments, refuse to countenance, or may even consider to be ‘unAustralian’. The science of climate change is chief among them.

Little wonder that green NGOs are now taking their arguments directly to banks and the investment community, reasoning that, unlike politicians, banks and investors should at least have a longer-term perspective, and more skin in the game in the form of potential lost capital.

Coal concerns

Prior, a former top-rating analyst of oil and gas and still one of the country’s best regarded analysts, is not alone in raising concerns about coal.

HSBC economists last month wrote that the issue of stranded asset valuations for coal has become ‘increasingly topical for equity investors and management’ over the past 18 months.

‘It is fair to say that the long-run future of coal is now “in play” in commodity and equity research markets,’ the HSBC economists wrote.

Not that the miners accept this, because they have a massive ‘blind spot’ over short-term profits.

But the fact that there is a debate in investment circles is a change in itself over the past 18 months.

‘We believe that mining companies need to be able to demonstrate to investors how their portfolio would prosper in a low-carbon scenario, and how this is being factored into long-term capex,’ HSBC writes.

That is particularly true of infrastructure investors such as Aurizon.

Deutsche Bank and Goldman Sachs have raised questions about the future of thermal coal, and even the IEA has said the current low coal prices ‘raise concerns about the economic feasibility of projects in the Galilee Basin,’ and several pieces of specific analysis have queried the financial standing of some of the key players in the Galilee Basin

Analysts says there are several reasons Aurizon’s $3 billion investment (its 51 per cent share) into rail and port infrastructure might not be a good long-term investment.

The first is China’s moves to combat its shocking air pollution. There is increasing talk that China will implement the cap on coal consumption that has been freely discussed among its main policy bodies.

The second is that the world may take decisive action on climate change, and actually try to do what it said it would – seek to limit global warming to 2C.

No future market

That would require, according to International Energy Agency, the imposition of a strict ‘carbon budget’ and the world leaving two-thirds of its fossil fuels in the ground.

There would simply be no long-term market for Galilee Basin coal under that scenario.

The third is the most intriguing, because it is based around simple economics rather than government policy.

It is generally assumed that India will continue to import huge amounts of coal, no matter what, to fire its electricity.

But Prior notes that falling costs in renewables, particularly solar, means that coal may not be able to compete over the medium to long term.

These may not be crucial for miners, who are keen to dig up as much of the wealth that currently lies in the ground.

But for companies such as Aurizon, the infrastructure would require a 20-year payback period, and may not even be constructed for another five years.

Has Aurizon considered any of these options? Apparently not.

Prior put some questions to Aurizon and the company told her that it sees strong 20-year fundamentals for coal, and it does not believe a 2°C global warming scenario represents a material risk.

Prior has a different view: ‘We see a risk that if the project starts five to ten years into the future, and the world does take action on climate change or other dynamics drive a shift away from coal, driving weaker coal prices, a major long-term investment in the Galilee Basin might leave Aurizon’s shareholders with a “stranded” asset.’

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Thatcher started it by stating that there is no such thing as society. Gordon Gecko immortalised it in popular culture “greed is good” and of course the Christian fundamentalists legitimated it. An interesting side bar to history is the fact that our Barry Jones was invited by Thatcher to speak in London on the “awareness of Greenhouse issues “in 1998.

    Years later nothing much has changed on the Howard/Abbott agenda -there is a cabal of right thinking politicians who deny that Global Warming is a concern for “our society”. Global Warming is a “con” to the dysfunctional Tea Party members in the US and those in Australia who follow the same agenda, almost exclusively LNP types who slavishly follow their agenda.

    What has this to do with banks and their actions/responsibilities?
    Global Warming is a matter of scientific fact –now acknowledged and accepted by the vast majority of scientists (whose job it is to know about such things) and most thinking people.

    However the whole discussion has been turned into an ideological political fracas -indeed it descends into farce. The famous shock jock punditry of such people as Alan Jones, Ray Hadley, Greg Smith, and god forbid that we should mention Andrew Bolt (pun intended) –some of our local entertainers who express “expert” opinion are all of one voice. These opinion makers and vast panoply of sceptical blogs (funded surreptitiously by fossil burning big corporations) make up the nay sayers. Surely we must also highlight the infamous Lord Monckton a favourite of MP Dennis Jensen along with other members of the current Government -all look only to their immediate political future. Such an illustrious group all on the side of the government –how could we possibly ignore their wisdom?

    And banks (of course there will be exceptions) are mostly marketing short term profit “thinkers”. Keynesian vs. Hayekian economic theory is at the heart of the considerations that we must make.

    Finally, consider this brief summary, quote: “The far right view global warming not as scientifically proven phenomena, endorsed by every national scientific academy in the Western world, but as a political assault on capitalism…… they defend the free market at any cost”. End of quote.
    Where is the societal contract in that type of thinking


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Editorial – Just another unjust moment in history

Justice has been served and it’s a shit sandwich: whistleblower David McBride is now the first person to be sentenced to jail in Australia for reporting war crimes.

What do young people want and what do they think needs to change?

The ‘Your Voice, Our Future’ survey has been launched and is asking young people to put forward their views on what is important to them. 

Conciliation meeting over Broadwater floodplain development terminated

Richmond Valley Council refused a development application for a 60-lot residential development on flood-prone land on Rileys Hill Road, Broadwater, close to the Richmond River in October 2023. 

Pickleball takes Alstonville by storm as new courts open

Alstonville now boasts tournament-standard pickleball courts that opened to an enthusiastic crowd and players last Saturday despite the rain.