21.3 C
Byron Shire
February 26, 2021

Minor parties again eyeing preference deals

Latest News

‘Hollywood’ drug squads over the top

I guess we have to thank Hollywood for the enduring myth that a black-clad squad of elite 'blokes', preferably with cool helicopters, from the capital are needed to crack down on really serious crime in hick parts of the country like Mullumbimby.

Other News

TGA obstructs prescription psilocybin, MDMA

Imagine that some crazy professors convince a bunch of participants at a five-day mindfulness retreat to agree to take part in an experiment where half of them are given magic mushrooms, and half of them a placebo.

Local fisherfolk caught in the parking fine net

FIsherfolk have been caught in the net of parking fines designed to stop travellers parking up for the night on the Tweed Coast Road and they are seeking help to access their beaches at night without fines.

Will the Lennox Park pavilion survive?

Ballina Shire Council will today debate the future of the Lennox Park pavilion/dressing shed, which is slated for removal as part of the Lennox Village Vision concept plan.

Police confirm Main Arm drug operation

NSW Police have finally confirmed what pretty much every one in Main Arm already knows – they are conducting drug operations in the north of the Shire.

Call to protect oceans from plastic and pollution

A new sign has been installed at Main Beach, Byron Bay, calling for increased awareness and collective action on the issue of marine debris and pollution. 

Facebook fails

Adrian Gattenhof, Mullumbimby American spoilt brat Zuckerberg may have done adults around the world a great favour with his screamy...

Greens Senator Robert Ludlam. Photo Greens MPs/Flickr
Greens Senator Scott Ludlam. Photo Greens MPs/Flickr

Charles Richardson, through crikey.com

Western Australia goes back to the polls in just under a month’s time, on April 5, to re-do its half-Senate election.

So of course everyone wants to talk about preferences. In last week’s papers you can read (in the Fairfax press) about the prospect of Labor shafting the Greens, and (in News Corp) about Glen Druery threatening that his preference harvesting could cost the Coalition a seat.

To understand either point, it’s necessary to get something straight about the basics of the Western Australian Senate vote.

Every person and their dog are likely to stand (nominations close on Thursday), but almost without exception the serious and semi-serious candidates will fall into five groups: the Coalition, Labor, the Greens, a variety of broadly left-wing minor parties (Sex Party, HEMP, WikiLeaks, etc), and a larger number of broadly right-wing groups (Palmer United, Liberal Democrats, Christians, Shooters, Family First, etc.)

Last year, when they ran the election the first time, the Coalition had fractionally over three quotas and the right-wing minors just over one quota.

Labor had a bit less than two quotas, the Greens about two-thirds of a quota and the left-wing minors the remaining one-third.

So although the original count and the recount gave different results, in terms of the Left/Right balance they were the same: four to the Right (three Coalition and either a Palmer or a Sports Party: that’s ‘or’, not ‘and’ as the News Corp story has it) and two to the Left (either two Labor, or one Labor and one Green).

It’s generally assumed that for the re-election there’ll be a swing away from the government, so the overall Left should be favoured to pick up a seat at the expense of the overall Right.

Unless the pattern of voting changes radically from last year, that would mean the second Labor candidate and the Greens’ Scott Ludlam would both get up, while on the Right there would be a close contest between the third Liberal and whoever came out at the head of the pack of right-wing minor parties.

So what Druery is saying is basically correct: if the right-wing minors preference one another tightly, the Liberals certainly ‘might struggle’ to again get a third candidate elected. (It’s also possible that the Nationals, who run a separate ticket but whom I’ve included in the Coalition total, would be in the mix.)

But there’s a bit more to Druery’s ambitions than that.

His preference strategy also involves trying to convince minor parties that they have a common interest that transcends ideology, so that left- and right-wing minor parties should preference one another ahead of their respective major parties.

And here’s where the Labor v Greens dynamic comes in.

‘Transferring a seat from the Greens to a minor party can only make Labor’s position worse.’

Unless there’s some large and unexpected shift, there’s no chance of the left-wing minor parties getting near a quota between them. The Left’s seats should be shared between Labor and the Greens: either one each (as in last year’s recount), two-nil (as in the original count) or two-one (if the left picks up ground in aggregate).

So if Labor chooses to distance itself from the Greens by directing preferences to, say, the Sex Party, that should have no effect.

It’s not impossible that a left-wing minor party could sneak ahead of the Greens if there was a large Labor surplus, but it’s much more likely that Ludlam would still get up, provided those preferences go to the Greens ahead of any of the parties on the Right.

That proviso hasn’t always held up. Most famously, in Victoria in 2004, the ALP directed preferences to Family First ahead of the Greens, electing Steve Fielding.

Despite that experience, there are evidently many on the Labor Right (or even, if Fairfax is to be believed, on the Left) who would happily do the same again.

In terms of Senate numbers, that makes no sense. Transferring a seat from the Greens to a minor party can only make Labor’s position worse (because Labor can’t get a majority without the Greens, whatever happens). But lack of sense is not necessarily a fatal obstacle.

It’s the same lesson that was learned from the Queensland Liberal Party’s warfare over One Nation preferences 15 years ago. Participants in the debate claimed to be arguing about what made better tactical sense for the party, but in reality they were arguing about whether or not they felt themselves to be philosophical kin to One Nation.

Similarly, Labor’s tacticians will have ingenious rationales for preferencing the Right, but what they really boil down to is that they hate the Greens and want to express that hatred. (Or, more cynically, that they’re convinced the electorate hates the Greens and want to show that they feel the same.) They don’t really have a preference strategy, they have preference symbolism.

Even assuming Labor’s votes still end up with the Greens, the risk of the anti-Green agitation is that some of the left-wing minor parties will be more inclined to listen to Glen Druery’s siren song and divert their preferences from the Greens to the likes of Palmer, the Christians or the Sports Party.

And if that happens, the Right’s chances of again walking away with four senators would be much improved.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Local fisherfolk caught in the parking fine net

FIsherfolk have been caught in the net of parking fines designed to stop travellers parking up for the night on the Tweed Coast Road and they are seeking help to access their beaches at night without fines.

Family Court scrapped

Despite overwhelming opposition from Australia’s family law specialists and advocates, the federal Liberal-Nationals government and cross benchers scrapped the Family Law Court and subsumed it into the circuit courts last week.

Cavanbah centre gets a taste of 3×3 basketball

The Byron Beez basketball team in collaboration with the U League hosted a 3x3 tournament at the Cavanbah centre at the end of January that attracted 30 teams.

Northern Rivers policeman accused of youth assault acquitted

Magistrate Michael Dakin has ordered a common assault charge against a former Byron-based policeman be dropped after an altercation involving a naked youth in Byron Bay three years ago.