16 C
Byron Shire
October 18, 2021

With land ownership comes responsibility

Latest News

Privately owned, but still ‘sacred site’ – Nimbin church burns to the ground

Last night at around 9pm, St Patrick's Catholic Church in Nimbin burned to the ground.

Other News

Bio-energy vs biodiversity

I thank The Echo for so clearly informing the readers of the ongoing concerns of Byron Bird Buddies and...

Can we inoculate against the racism virus?

Like many others, I watched with interest the recently screened ABC documentary, The School that Tried to End Racism.

Border bubble to Queensland reopens for local shires

Local Government Areas (LGAs) that have recently come out of lockdown, including Lismore, Kyogle and Richmond Valley Council (RVC) have now been brought back into the border bubble zone with the Queensland border.

NSW govt’s Health Order lacks clarity

Confused and anxious when it comes to ambiguous and complex COVID-19 laws? You are not alone.

COVID-19 hospital horror – opening up and the dangers ahead

A hospital is not a health farm. For a start, the food has a terrible reputation. Seriously though, when life is on the brink, a hospital is the destination.

Tweed Mayor tries for 180 short term holiday letting limit

At the Tweed Shire Council (TSC) meeting (October 7) a late Mayoral Minute by Tweed Shire Mayor Chris Cherry...

Recently, I and other members of the Byron Residents Group, sat on a Byron Bay street and canvassed the thoughts and opinions of the passing local community members over a three-hour period on the issue of the West Bryon housing development.

We spoke to many people, and of these 68 went the next step to sign a petition opposing the development proposal for West Byron. Only two people in that time supported the proposal, one on the grounds of low-cost housing and the other just supported it and did not want to say why.

I personally spoke to around 20 long-term residents, some of whom I have known for 30 or more years, and every one of them did not approve of this development yet they feel disempowered to stop it.

Our council has rejected this development three times. Our community appears to be opposed to it. Who is not listening? The developers have taken the rejected proposal to the state government because they don’t like the Council’s and the community’s wishes.

Some of these developers are people I grew up with and I know them to be caring members of our community who have done and continue to do some wonderful work in the community.

But to me the proposed West Byron development in its present format defies logic and in fact could be described as an act of bastardry against the community.

To build a major village complex on what is an acid sulfate soil flood plain (75 per cent of the area), which acts as part of the head waters to the Belongil Estuary, has the potential to be nothing short of environmental vandalism.

Acid sulfate soil when disturbed/or is dried out generates sulfuric acid and leaches heavy metals into the water system that flows into the Belongil and on into the Cape Byron Marine Reserve. It has the potential to destroy the fish nursery and affect the whole wetland.

Why would you do that to your neighbours?

In peak hours, traffic and parking congestion in the Bay are as bad as metropolitan areas. From the Pacific Highway to the Main Beach along Ewingsdale Road commonly takes more than 30 minutes. From Suffolk Park to the main beach can take just as long when at its worst.

On any public holiday we are almost at traffic grid lock. Parking? What parking?

The West Byron rezoning will increase the Bay’s population by 25 per cent and does absolutely nothing about solving the already existing traffic chaos.

Contributions to the proposed bypass are all smoke and mirrors, they won’t improve anything when the destination of most of the traffic is the town, the Cape and the beach. When we get there, the same inadequate parking spaces will await us. Just add 25 per cent more cars circling, circling our choked streets.

The potential decimation of a core koala colony and the breaking of a critical migration corridor for the koala from Broken Head through to  Tyagarah, do these iconic creatures deserve to be considered and protected by us?

Or do they get ignored by the developers proposing to remove their habitat trees and surround them with urban housing?

I ask myself how could I be responsible for that happening in my town and my community?

Low cost affordable housing? I don’t think so. The land will be sold at market rates. We are not talking about commission housing here, we are talking about the potential for speculators building units and  rentals. It takes a government action to develop low cost accommodation not speculators.

Jobs, what jobs? The developers employ large contractors from out of the area to develop these sites at cut throat rates. South Queensland and their sub-contractors are only an hour up the road. I doubt that locals will get a look in.

Maybe the developers will trade down, from what we are led to believe is a  proposed 1,100 houses, to 500 or some such figure, but the outcome on the environment and the Belongil estuary will be largely the same.

I say to our ‘local’ developers that: With land ownership comes custodial responsibility. With community membership comes a responsibility to care for and respect community values.

I urge you to take a step back and consider what could be done with this land with vision, courage and a sense of community involvement.

The Byron Residents Group is not anti-development. We are pro-community, which includes our ecology and environment in all its forms and we are prepared to talk to our ‘local’ developers who control parcel(s) of land that accounts for a reported 700 of the proposed 1100 houses on this development.

There is an alternative way of doing things that could make our ‘local’ developers beacons of our community and proud custodians of this piece of land.

Any residents who need to find out more on this issue can contact the Byron Residents Group via www.westbyron.org

Donald Maughan, Byron Bay


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. I also have lived here for 50 years Don and what you write comes from the heart .Low cost housing is a dream that won’t happen unless it is supplied by the government at fixed price rental.Dont forget that all this area was once a swamp covered by water,drains got dug to make it available for grazing.The reason Island Quarry got its name was because it was an island amongst the swamp and the basalt was going to be used to build a breakwater from The Cape to Julian Rocks.
    West Byron is not the place for 1100 homes .What jobs are available for the possible 2800 people living in these homes.Build a large aged care facility on the existing Belongil Fields site,this will bring jobs and be low impact as less vehicle movements will be created.Get Ewingsdale connected to the West Byron sewerage plant and subdivide the existing housing lots to provide more housing.

  2. Is it possible to share publicly who the local developers are (the people – not the company)? I genuinely don’t know who locally is involved and am interested to know.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

XR plans two weeks of ‘Reclaim our Future’ protests

Extinction Rebellion Lismore is part of the Northern Rivers push to highlight the issue of climate change and a march and candlelit vigil last night was the start to a fortnight of ‘Reclaim Our Future’ protests.

Phone scam – Just.Hang.Up.

Crime Stoppers says that almost 90 per cent of Australians have received at least one nuisance or unwanted call every week

Anti-DV umbrellas launched in Ballina

Rotary have partnered with NSW Police to design and distribute 150 umbrellas with a very clear message: 'Say NO to domestic violence'.


The truth doesn’t mind being questioned. A lie does. Margot Hays, Bangalow