Bentley farmers abandon meeting with ‘deaf’ bureaucrats

Sick of not being listened to, Bentley farmers stood up en masse and handed NSW Land and Water Commissioner Jock Laurie letters outlining their concerns before abandoning Tuesday's meeting.

Sick of not being listened to, Bentley farmers stood up en masse and handed NSW Land and Water commissioner Jock Laurie (standing, centre) letters outlining their concerns before abandoning Tuesday’s meeting. Photo Leone Wilkinson.

Simeon Michaels

The enormous shit-storm that Nationals Party member Peter Graham ignited after signing his property over to gas mining in Bentley near Lismore continues to escalate.

Just two days after the meeting, NSW mining minister Anthony Roberts has shut down the Metgasco operation, saying the industry had not consulted effectively with local residents. Read the full story here.

Almost all of Mr Graham’s 40 immediate neighbours stormed out in disgust from a meeting with government departments on Tuesday (May 13) after they tried to convince the landowners that gas mining was safe.

It appeared the bureaucrats, who represented the Office of Coal Seam Gas (CSG) and NSW Land and Water, were unable to provide satisfactory answers by the residents. In fact, the residents appeared better informed and educated than the government reps themselves.

Held at the Goonellabah Sports and Aquatic Centre, the invitation-only event was promoted as a workshop for concerned residents, focussing on ‘providing a better understanding around groundwater and well-integrity issues, fracture stimulation, and will provide an overview of existing benchmark northern rivers catchment water data.’

And the invitation said that without any media attention, it will ‘help ensure that local landholders and local members of the Casino community have a chance to hear information about the proposed Rosella E01 (PEL16) gas well at Bentley’.

It is unclear however why a media presence would hinder a ‘chance to hear information’.

Talked to rather than listened to

The meeting began with NSW Land and Water commissioner, Jock Laurie, describing his job as, ‘going to rural areas, listening to their concerns and taking them back to the government’.

But the audience soon became angered as it became clear that they were going to be talked at, rather than listened to. Mutters of ‘We know that already’ soon turned to direct questioning of the presenters, who seemed unprepared for the farmers’ high level of education.

Cracks appear

The cracks began to appear after Rachel Connell, director of the Office of CSG, admitted of approving Metgasco’s Bentley operation as ‘conventional gas exploration’, despite its own assessment that it was a tight sands project that carried greater environmental risks.

‘We are not responsible for how the company chooses to promote itself,’ she said. And temperatures rose further when she was grilled as to why her office continued to approve Metgasco operations despite the company having  been responsible for well blow-outs and contaminated-water spills. ‘We acknowledge that’s an issue,’ she replied.

The red rag to the bull, however, was Ms Connell’s assurance that while limited consultation was required for exploration, Metgasco would be required to conduct full consultation prior to obtaining approval for extraction. Vocal responses from the audience followed: ‘You’ve approved this company to spend millions of dollars to look for gas … and now you’re telling us you might not let them get it.’

‘Who’s the regulator here. Are you the regulator?’ asked Keerrong cattle farmer Joshua Wellman.

As the meeting boiled over, Green Mountain premium beef producer David Scarrabelotti, stood up to say it was now time for the government to listen to the community.

A group statement declared, ‘We have done the research, we know the facts, we have seen Metgasco in action and we are resolute … we declare our absolute determination to stop them.’

Twenty minutes into the workshop it was all over, and only a few residents stayed on to rake over the ashes with the shaken delegation.

‘We insist that this clear message from our community is taken, by you, back to your minister and the premier of NSW,’ concluded the letters handed to Mr Laurie.

Govt propaganda

Later landholder Charles Wilkinson told Gasfield Free Northern Rivers of the meeting, ‘We don’t need to listen to any more of their propaganda. We are all clear in our understanding of the risks and threats associated with industrialisation of our area and are a very well informed community, familiar with the plethora of evidence documenting the risks and failures of the gas industry. Yet once again, the government has failed to recognise and address community concerns and call for a stop to gas exploration in the northern rivers.’

The landholders also requested that their message be relayed to Sydney and to ensure that copies were being sent to the premier, the police minister, the minister for resources and energy and the minister for transport.


Who is Jock Laurie?

NSW Land and Water commissioner Jock Laurie has also shown political ambitions; last year reported that he stood down as National Farmers’ Federation president – and then lost – as the Nationals candidate for the NSW state seat of the Northern Tablelands.

Recent stories tagged Bentley Blockade:

7 responses to “Bentley farmers abandon meeting with ‘deaf’ bureaucrats”

  1. Ken says:

    Wow, restores my faith in traditional farmers !
    Yes these people are far better informed than the government agencies, because they actually care.
    The days of government dictating to citizens are numbered as was soundly demonstrated in the public meeting in the Lismore town hall, where Brad Hazzard was shown the door. Now lets see if we can rescue this country from this corrupt government.

  2. Carol Gilmore says:

    Sincere gratitude to our farmers who will not let our land, water and air be destroyed by greedy mining companies who have no interest in the future. ‘The enormous shit storm’ created by Peter Graham only served to consolidate the community into a movement the size of which has never been seen before in this country. If our politicians won’t protect us then we will – now and forever! Long live Bentley and its proponents!

  3. Rose Fox, Byron Bay says:

    Congratulations to the farmers, land-owners, protectors, protesters and everyone who helped to win this fantastic victory for the land and people of the Northern Rivers, a victory also for common sense. For once the people have spoken and the government has listened!

  4. Lavender says:

    Congratulations to the farmers and all involved working to make government and others realise the great dangers of CSG mining. Bouquets too to all community members involved to back this action – the Bentley protectors, negotiators and advocates, advisors, Mayor Jenny Dowell and countless others. What we have to remember is that the Metgascos of this world have deep pockets, plentiful spin and ears in the corridors of power, so the rest of us have to stay tuned and vocal to protect the earth, water, land, farmers’ livliehood and communities’ well-being. The voice of the people will be heard!

  5. john says:

    It seems that Jock Laurie and the Office of CSG have quite a lot of homework to do. The days of waffle and soothing “tuts tuts” don’t cut it anymore.
    These are our livlihoods, our farms and our kids futures that these people are dealing with.
    We will live in the gasfields that they want to develop. They won’t be there.
    Interlopers need to get ethical, listen to the communities that they want turned into an unlivable industrial wasteland. Wonder if they’ve visited Tara in Queensland, talked to the people there. Asked the Tara people about their kids and the land that they can’t sell for a pittance. Have any Office of CSG folk talked to the NAB bank and asked if insurance cover can be got on a place with CSG wells on it? Outrage that there is even the gall to try this on.

  6. Patti Jacobs says:

    It’s been a monumental, 4 year, hard fought battle just to be finally HEARD by this government. It has taken 4 years of protest, 2 months of camping & blockading, 10,000 plus people marching, taking polls, talking, shouting, emailing, organising, having meetings, lobbying, writing & phoning…at long long last, by their dogged determination & unity the people of the Northern Rivers NSW have reached the ears of the politicians & the government! And only JUST in time to save a massive $8-14 million confrontation between the citizens of this area & 700-1000 imported riot squad police!!!! And believe me, the police are just as relieved as we are!! Let’s just pray that as time goes on the ICAC reveals all &, in the words of the Rev, Jim Nightingale, “We can dance on the grave of CSG in all of NSW!!!!”

  7. Leigh says:

    Can someone please email this link to the OCSG and Anthony Roberts. This is the perfect example of no one listening (iPads difficult to send link). They really need to see this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsor Brunswick Picture House.