21.9 C
Byron Shire
April 10, 2021

Who’s Swindelling whom over West Byron

Latest News

A win for the roughy

The battle for the 'roughy had been a tough road for conservationists and hopefully this win will be the last fight.

Other News

ANZAC Day with a difference in Lismore

The Northern Rivers peace group ‘Remembering and Healing’ (RaH), now in its twelfth year, is organising two public events for ANZAC Day to remember the suffering war brings on all sides, and to make a strong commitment to peace and non-violence.

Kyogle unveils writers fest program

Billed as 'a small-town festival with big ideas', Kyogle Writers Festival is shaping up to be a great celebration of writing. 

Irresistible pastries you can’t go past

Story & photo Lisa Machin  Scratch Patisserie is a household name in the Northern Rivers, and it’s a rare individual...

$50,000 in grants for sixteen Tweed sports clubs

Tweed sporting organisations have received a welcome boost with the announcement of the Local Sport Grants Program by the NSW Government.

Big swinging dicks

Keith Duncan, Pimlico After the tumultuous events of the past weeks regarding alleged sexual assaults within the Liberal Party and...

Byron Council explores community land trust option for affordable housing

Could the creation of a Community Land Trust in the Byron Shire provide desperately needed, genuinely affordable housing for locals on low incomes?

Ms Swindell, the ‘reputation manager’ for the West Byron developers, claims they have followed department of planning process ‘to the letter’. It is surprising that Ms Swindell says that ‘to our knowledge’the Preliminary Acid Sulfate Soil Study was put on exhibition in 2011 since the Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) stated that:

‘no acid sulphate soil study has been included in the appendices to justify the conclusions reached in the planning report. Until a study is prepared or presented, consistent with OEH standards, the potential impacts cannot be reviewed.’

After later receiving a Preliminary ASS report, the EPA wrote ‘the extent of sampling is considered insufficient, compared with the requirement of the Assessment Guidelines in the Acid Sulfate Soils Manual 1998’. Those guidelines also state, in regard to rezoning, that ‘an Acid Sulfate Soils Study should be prepared when any intensification of land use on acid sulfate soils is proposed.’ The proponents’ inadequate report is hardly ‘to the letter’. No rezoning should be considered when even a preliminary study does not meet Department guidelines.

The developers’ original koala report by the respected Biolink consultants was, according to Ms Swindell,  peer reviewed and then discounted. Who peer reviewed it and why was that review not part of the available documentation?  The Biolink report was consistent with the Office of Environment and Heritage who, in their submission in 2012, described the area as Core Koala Habitat. The OEH was critical of the Environmental Assessment report prepared by the West Byron Landpartners, commenting that:

‘The [report] prepared by Landpartners … states that the koala population recorded on the site is most probably migratory rather than resident. This statement appears misleading and may lack scientific credibility given the historical and current use of the site by a number of koala individuals.’

The West Urban Release Area State Significant Site Study Guidelines say that, with regard to traffic and transport, the proposal must ‘include a traffic study in accordance with the RTA Guide to Traffic Generating Developments’. The West Byron developers’  traffic study does not conform to those guidelines – hardly following the process ‘to the letter’.

I am not, as Ms Swindell suggest, trying to ‘drum up community concern’ but rather the Byron Residents’ Group is responding to the  will of the 2500 plus people who have signed our petitions so far. We have done genuine community consultation on a scale with which the developers cannot compare. We hear how Byron locals are astonished by the effrontery of a handful of developers who have dismissed Council’s recommendations and taken their irresponsible, oversized and unwanted proposal to the state government to decide.

Cate Coorey, president, Byron Residents’ Group


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. How do you get justice for the environment when you are battling governments that are tainted with the likes of Obeid ,Tripodi and McDonald.I I am sure there is still a fair few ministers with skeletons in the closet .

  2. If these Swindellers haven’t met the required level of community consultation I suggest they be reported to the ICAC as Metgasco has been reported. Occasionally society needs a good ICAC enema and detox. We are indeed fortunate in the northern rivers to have such diligent and well informed gate keepers against the Orcs of Mordor. LOCK THE GATE!! MAN THE BARRICADES.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Maybe Canberra needs a bit of distraction biff

Mick breathed in but his Cronulla Sharks football jersey struggled to contain his well-insulated six-pack and he held up his hand as he approached Bazza in the front bar of the Top Pub.

Council crews working hard to repair potholes

Tweed Shire Council road maintenance crews are out across the Tweed's road network repairing potholes and other damage caused by the recent prolonged rainfall and previous flood events.

Poor Pauline

Bob Vinnicombe, Sefton A lot of hypocrisy from Labor and The Greens about respect for women. Look at the treatment they dished out to Pauline...

New film celebrates getting back outside

'Free From Lockdown: Back Out in Nature' is a new short film in which a group of disabled and non-disabled performers from the Northern Rivers celebrate being in nature after COVID lockdown.