20.4 C
Byron Shire
April 20, 2024

Govt fearmongering over Aussies fighting in Iraq

Latest News

Infrastructure for east end of Mullum

Mullumbimby was founded 135 years ago. In the 1960s sewerage was introduced, as was I suppose drainage infrastructure. Are...

Other News

Woodburn: ute hits, kills pedestrian

A 30-year-old woman walking in Woodburn died on Sunday morning when a teenager driving a ute crashed into her, police said.

Who is our next GG?

Sam Mostyn has been announced by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese as Australia's next governor-general. So what sort of woman is she, and why has her appointment sent the right wing media into a tizz?

A festival in laneways

Mullumbimby, a town known for its abundance of artists and creatives with a passion for what drives them, is set to host the much-anticipated Laneways Festival 2024 on May 4 and 5.

Antisemitic racism

It takes the death of an Aussie, Zomi Frankcom, to remind Prime Minister Albanese that murdering aid workers is...

All those macas and the Festival of Love

This season’s organic nuts have not been harvested so it is a harvest festival where festivalgoers can pick five kilos free as part of their festival entrance fee which is payable in the new paper money being launched at the Off-Grid Macadamia Festival of Love, to be held at Macas Camping Ground where The Elders of Gaia will be discussing how to get back the many freedoms recently lost and get sanity into local, national and global management.

Wage peace not war

Northern Rivers Peace group, Remembering and Healing is inviting all community members to a peace gathering on the eve of ANZAC Day.

Demonstrators chant pro-al-Qaida-inspired Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant slogans as they wave al-Qaida flags in front of the provincial government headquarters in Mosul, Iraq, on Monday (June 16, 2014). Photo AP
Demonstrators chant pro-al-Qaida-inspired Islamic State slogans as they wave al-Qaida flags in front of the provincial government headquarters in Mosul, Iraq, in June. Photo AP

Dr Scott Burchill* (through Crikey)

In Overblown, distinguished American political scientist John Mueller exposed how politicians and the terrorism industry grossly exaggerated the threat of terrorism after 9/11.

Using detailed historical comparisons going back to World War II, Mueller explained how Western governments have consistently exploited and exacerbated public fears in order to boost military spending and grant themselves draconian surveillance powers.

Mueller’s conclusions were devastating. The responses of the West to 9/11 and subsequent attacks were ‘wasteful’, ‘counterproductive’ and a ‘wild, absurd overreaction’.

Canberra’s response to revelations that Australian citizens have gone to fight for the Islamic State (IS) in Syria and Iraq follows the same pattern of state fear-mongering.

Firstly, there is threat inflation based on a small number of religious fanatics who want to fight for a caliphate incorporating northeastern Syria and Sunni tribal lands in Iraq.

Why these people would wish to return home and fight for an entirely different, unidentified cause, is not explained.

Cheerleaders for greater state surveillance ignore the religious and political motivations of these zealots, preferring to portray them as freelancers who, because of their training, indoctrination and militancy, will ineluctably, if inexplicably, pursue jihad upon returning to Australia.

Here is think-tanker Anthony Bergin in The Age:

‘Our security agencies have made a clear case to government that we face a serious threat to national security when radicalised Australians return from training and fighting in Syria and Iraq. Some could act on their jihadi beliefs and commit a mass attack on Australian soil.’

What ‘clear case’? At this point it is nothing more than an unsubstantiated assertion. No evidence for this claim has been produced by ASIO or its uncritical stenographers in the media, who have already forgotten similar assurances about Saddam Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction from the very same agencies.

‘We must require our government and its security agencies to clearly explain how our security is directly threatened by these 150 Australians and why we must relinquish our civil liberties to defeat them.’

They seem uninterested in the nature of this particular Sunni uprising and why Iraq has become a magnet for foreigners wishing to fight Shiites, Kurds and Christians there.

Attorney-General George Brandis talks about jihadists from earlier, unrelated conflicts such as Afghanistan, who returned home to plan or carry out violence.

However, the dynamics of the rise of IS in Iraq today, and their appeal to foreigners, are very different from the Western world’s war against the Taliban, which began in 2001.

According to terrorism academic Greg Barton, this ‘is about as big a threat as we’ve ever faced,’ and because terrorists like to use social media, the metadata of all Australian citizens needs to be monitored and retained without warrant to confront this new and immanent danger.

To suggest this is an overreaction does not adequately capture the hysteria behind the decision.

Secondly, the deliberate conflation of disparate conflicts in Syria, Iraq and Gaza into a monolithic anti-Western terrorist threat leads to some dangerous, if risible, defences of state surveillance.

This is also a replay of 2001, when China’s attacks on the Uyghurs, Russia’s war against Chechnya, and Israel’s conflict with Hamas was opportunistically prosecuted under the War on Terror banner.

To those who wish to keep fighting a war with militant Islam for 100 years, all jihadists are much the same: There are no significant differences between Hamas, Hezbollah, IS, Ahrar al-Sham, Jemaah Islamiyah or al-Qaeda, they are all irredeemably evil and irrationally anti-Western, whether they are fighting colonialism in Palestine, moral pollution in Bali or for a caliphate in the Levant, their variegated motivations are ignored so a ‘one size fits all’ policy response can be adopted to protect us from them.

The intellectual dishonesty and laziness of this attitude suggests we have learnt very little over the last decade.

Instead of heeding the warnings of John Mueller or understanding our own role in the disintegration of Iraq and the rise of IS from Patrick Cockburn and William Dalrymple, Canberra seems determined to repeat mistakes of the recent past.

We cannot expect more than contrived moral panics from tabloid hacks and surveillance apologists in the Murdoch empire and terrorism industry.

But we must require our government and its security agencies to clearly explain how our security is directly threatened by these 150 Australians and why we must relinquish our civil liberties to defeat them.

The WMD intelligence debacle of 2003, which led directly to our destruction of Iraqi society with appalling consequences that we are still dealing with today, demands nothing less.

* Dr Burchill is a senior lecturer in international relations at Deakin University.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Wonderful to hear the voice of reason. Let us not snuff out that precious candle.
    For those wanting a deeper understanding of the “anti-terrorist” industry, I refer you to Richard Flanagan’s book The Unknown Terrorist. Written in 2006, its message is still powerful and fresh. It is a brilliant account of the making of a terror suspect and the operation of our anti-terror laws. EP Thomson Whigs and Hunters brings a fine historical perspective to the ruling class response to popular outrage against unjust laws, in this case passed 300 years ago to justify the seizure of the commons to make up for the losses incurred when the South Seas Bubble – an investment scam of those times – went bust. Like now, the law makers invented a new category of “crime”, with 300 new laws, punishable by death, in order to keep the people in line.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Save Wallum now

The Save Wallum campaign has been ongoing and a strong presence of concerned conservationists are on site at Brunswick Heads. How the state planning...

Can Council’s overturn their decisions?

NSW Labor planning minister, Paul Scully, when asked about the Wallum estate by local MP Tamara Smith (Greens)  in parliament on March 20, said,...

The bridges of Ballina Council

Ballina Shire Council has started preliminary investigation works at Fishery Creek Bridge, on River Street, and Canal Bridge, on Tamarind Drive, as part of their plan to duplicate both bridges.

Tweed Council wants your ideas on future sports facilities

Tweed Council is looking for feedback from residents about future plans for sport and recreation in the area.