21.3 C
Byron Shire
December 2, 2021

Moylan’s sentence a Pyrrhic victory for miners

Latest News

A disappointed dog

It’s taken a whole week for my dog to read to page 21 in last week’s Echo. She’s been...

Other News

Fatal crash – Alstonville

A man has died following a crash in Alsonville yesterday.

Gladys just doesn’t get it? Bullshit.

The rules are lost to the dark art of time, but when I was younger, we used to play a card game called ‘Bullshit’...

Candidates against the train

Bruce Clarke, Mark Swivel and Asren Pugh have officially stated they do not believe it’s worth trying to get...

Ballina Council agrees to consider tighter holiday let policy

The Ballina Shire Council has voted unanimously to investigate options for restricting short-term rental accommodation.

Give them a doggie inch…

Your article on dogs (17 November) is a sad reminder of the adage… give them an inch and they...

COVID update – Aquarius, Lismore sewage fragments and the South African variant

The Northern NSW Local Health District says there have been no new cases of COVID-19 reported in the 24 hours to 8pm 28 November, but, they are urging residents in the Lismore area to be alert for COVID-19 symptoms.

Jonathan Moylan

Paddy Manning, Crikey business editor

Non-violent protest against coal is not going away, and the miners cannot win, no matter how much money they spend pushing doubt and reaction or how many newspapers are on their side.

In fact, every victory they notch up, defeating the mining and carbon taxes, securing vast new coal mine approvals,- only ups the ante and ensures a stronger retaliation down the track.

What else do they imagine? People will give up? Let our safe climate, on which all life depends, get wrecked, just so we can put off a switch to renewables a while longer? Save a few pennies sticking to a dirty old form of electricity generation while shelling out billions on climate damage?

People won’t give up. The stakes are too high, and they’re rising, and if the coal industry can’t see Jonathan Moylan’s hoax for what it is, a sign of things to come, that is their problem entirely.

Market integrity is fundamental, no question. Jonathan Moylan was guilty of market manipulation at the beginning of last year when, while sitting in a protest camp in the Leard State Forest, which will be largely destroyed by the Maules Creek mine, Moylan sent out a fake ANZ press release from his laptop, in which the bank purportedly withdrew a $1.2 billion loan to Whitehaven Coal.

The release was picked up by media and caused Whitehaven shares to plummet.

For 20 minutes or so Moylan wiped a few hundred million dollars off the market capitalisation of Whitehaven Coal, but after a trading halt and clarification the stock rebounded, and the maximum possible losses suffered that day were under half a million dollars.

As it turned out, anyone who got out at the intra-day low of $3.21, off 8 per cent, avoided a subsequent halving of Whitehaven’s share price.

Moylan deserved the sentence he got, a suspended sentence, with a two-year good behaviour bond and a $1,000 surety.

Do the crime, do the time: former Greens leader Bob Brown was jailed and, as he pointed out in this passionate piece, so have the leaders of many civil disobedience movements in history.

As judge Lord Leonard Hoffmann ruled in a UK case when sentencing anti-Iraq war protesters: ‘They vouch the sincerity of their beliefs by accepting the penalties imposed by the law’.

Judge David Davies didn’t comment in the Moylan case, but for mine the financial consequences of Moylan’s hoax were trivial compared with Richard Macphillamy’s ‘rumourtrage’ against Macquarie Bank, surreptitiously spreading false rumours of a run on the bank’s cash management trust after the failure of Lehman Brothers, which helped send Macquarie shares as low as $15 and could have sunk the bank given the panic in the market at the height of the GFC.

Macphillamy was given an 18-month ban after the Australian Securities and Investments Commission decided Macphillamy’s actions were ‘rash, ill-judged and wholly inappropriate’.

Moylan faced a maximum of 10 years’ jail because sentences were toughened up in 2010 in the wake of ASIC’s Project Mint investigations into rumourtrage.

The chorus from the big end of town to throw the book at Moylan was out of whack with our corporate regulator’s slack record of enforcement on white-collar crime generally, contrast for example the maximum sentence available against Moylan with the ASIC’s failure to appeal a light $50,000 sentence for insider trader former Gunns chairman John Gay as my colleague Bernard Keane pointed out.

Davies accepted Moylan was genuinely contrite and that his hoax had more impact than he intended, particularly on Whitehaven shareholders; Moylan was mainly targeting ANZ for financing the project.

Most importantly, perhaps, the judge said Moylan’s action was not motivated by a desire for personal gain, unlike other examples of white-collar crime, the provisions in the act were designed to prevent.

The Moylan camp believe ASIC wanted to go as hard as possible, but the Director of Public Prosecutions recognised this was a different type of offence, both from the kind of white-collar offences the act sought to prevent, and from anything Moylan had done before. So, ultimately, did Davies.

To the credit of all sides, the Leard camp has stayed non-violent and, despite dozens of arrests since, it will stay non-violent.

Outside the NSW Supreme Court last Friday was a crowd of young people cheering for Moylan. The ‘Stand with Jono’ Twitter handle has 811 followers. My bet is plenty of them are inspired by what Moylan did and they would be prepared to do exactly the same thing. Moylan himself predicted more protest.

The coal industry likes to pretend it is beset by powerful NGOs and rich foundations, and the Abbott government is right now setting about silencing them. A furore broke out a few years back when a draft strategy to frustrate new coal projects somehow leaked to The Australian Financial Review.

That strategy did not contemplate market manipulation, and no established green group could last a second if it was caught spreading false information.

Lying as a means to an end would be a very short-term strategy indeed. Moylan’s prank involved lying, and any journalist listening to the verbatim transcripts available to the court and read out in Davies’ judgment would have blanched, how easy would it have been to be fooled while under the pump.

But the coal industry spreads mountains of misinformation every day.

Put aside funding for climate sceptics and industry stooges in politics. Or astro-turfing campaigns like #australiansforcoal, replete with ‘suggested tweets’, which backfired within minutes.

Or Peabody’s laughable campaign pretending that ‘advanced’ coal using clean technology ‘available now’ (but, strangely, not yet installed anywhere) is the solution to energy poverty in the developing world, as though Peabody cares for the poor.

The biggest lie (it’s not market manipulation, but it does artificially prop up share prices, so what is it?) is that life as we know it will continue if we burn all the fossil fuel reserves held by our big mining companies.

It can’t. Last year the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change backed work by Carbon Tracker that showed three-quarters of those reserves cannot be burned if we want a better-than-even chance of limiting warming to two degrees.

This carbon bubble is going to burst, perhaps it has started already, and the market write-downs must follow. There are particular implications for Australia. Carbon Tracker estimated our coal reserves are ‘already more than double their market share of the precautionary global carbon budget for coal’, that is, we’re counting on burning twice as much coal as we should.

The coal industry knows how powerful the divestment campaign is and supporters like Sinclair Davidson, of RMIT and the Institute of Public Affairs, say environment groups mounting the argument should be prosecuted for secondary boycott provisions and/or exactly the same law that Moylan himself broke.

For an attack on freedom of speech, it is pretty hard to beat. And if the law is unjust, they will be lining up to break it.

Moylan’s prank worked, and to paraphrase Bill Kelty, the battle over Maules Creek is merely a prelude: the federal and state governments’ determined push to develop the vast, uneconomic thermal coal resources of the Galilee Basin, kicked along today by environment minister Greg Hunt’s breathtaking approval of Adani’s Carmichael coal mine, which could become Australia’s biggest, will be the ‘full symphony’.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Moylan wasn’t ‘contrite’ after the trial. He was aggressively still challenging the system, threatening more disruptive action. A year in the jail would have smartened him up. Maybe next time………

  2. Jonno Moylan has many supporters with internet sites dedicated to his case. In addition he has thousands fellow supporters that will continue the fight against CSG and coal mining companies that are destroying our Country and our Planet.

    We need as many Australians (and other caring people around the World) as possible join us and help save the environment.

  3. The only thing Moylan did wrong was get caught. What on earth are you on about ? Whats with the sucking up to being owned and controlled by the state ? This type of gutless, moralistic preachy pandering merely enforces the slave brainwashing the majority don’t know they have. Mary Elizabeth Croft has a highly influential book about this. She has given it away free to read or download I advise you read it before picking up the pen again


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Realistic, local agendas!

On Saturday 4 December we need to vote for people who focus on issues that can be controlled by Council. Candidates claiming they can,...

Coal shame for Queensland and Australian

Local Whitsundays resident Paul Jukes took action this morning against the continued development of the Adani Carmichael Coal Mine.

Wilsons River flood peak and flooding not expected for Tweed, Rouse, Brunswick River catchments

The prediction provided by the Bureau of Meteorology expects that locals around the Wilsons River at Lismore will see the river peak this afternoon at 4.20m. However, ‘Flooding is no longer expected in the Tweed, Rouse, Brunswick River catchments.

Vote for community

From 2007 to 2020, I lived in Byron Bay. I worked as a community-based coastal and marine researcher and writer. I wrote about this...