18.9 C
Byron Shire
September 24, 2021

Abbott will live to regret his ‘lifestyle choice’

Latest News

Fundraising for koala signs for Bangalow

As the koala mating season has started, Bangalow Koalas has set up fundraising to create incorporate more koala road signs. Bangalow...

Other News

Tackling cane toads on the Tweed

Tweed Shire Council has put in place a plan to deal with the cane toad population in the area. Along with the not-for-profit organisation Watergum, Tweed Shire has launched a project for collecting toads that will begin in October.

A matter of choice

I have chosen to receive a vaccination. Others have chosen not to. Unless we are living in some totalitarian state, that...

COVID-19 update NSW, September 22

As Byron Bay and Tweed Shire enter on their first day of a snap lockdown, NSW recorded from 8 pm last night 1035 announced Premier Berejiklian.

A new COVID-19 case flies into the Far North Coast

The Northern NSW Local Health District has confirmed that there is a new case of COVID-19 in Northern NSW today, and they will be included in NSW Health’s official reporting tomorrow.

ScoMo does it again

ScoMo recently travelled from the ACT to Sydney, not something to be recommended at the moment. What is an essential...

Why are there so many vaccinated people in hospital?

It may be confronting to hear there are more vaccinated people than unvaccinated people in hospital – but it’s actually a good thing.

Mungo MacCallum

Tony Abbott’s brain snap describing the indigenous outstation movement was not only crass, unthinking and deeply offensive; it was just plain wrong, and wrong on a whole series of different levels.

The full quote revealed the width of its ignorance: “What we can’t do is endlessly subsidise lifestyle choices if these lifestyle choices are not conducive to the kind of full participation in Australian society that everyone should have,” he told ABC radio in Kalgoorlie.

First and most obviously, the outstation movement is not a lifestyle choice in any accepted sense of the phrase. It has little to do with a leisurely move to sell up a vastly expensively inner city property and career to settle in a comfortable seaside resort, to sit by the pool with a chilled bottle of chardonnay and a few Vogue magazines beside the table.

The move to the outstations was driven not by self-indulgence but by necessity, at times by desperation; the urban ghettoes of the cities had become sinkholes of degradation and misery, for those who have been forced off their traditional lands and for those who had immigrated to them in the vain hope of employment, and more importantly for their children, whose future was being blighted by alcoholism, drugs and violence.

A return to the bush was their only recourse; it offered not a comfortable and relaxed retirement, but rescue. They were looking to regain the remnants of their culture, their country and their old ways— a lifestyle, if you like, but one steeped in many generations of tradition.

And they were not demanding endlessly subsidies, but the bare necessities – those that would expected by right by all Australians. They asked for shelter, water, some source of power and transport, communications and a modicum of welfare – in precisely the way the government is prepared to provide for remote and isolated communities throughout the land.

These communities can be increasingly unviable; economic rationalists rail at what they see at the futility of propping up farms which can no longer become profitable, mining towns which have left their use by date, settlements passed by the major production routes, and many other communities which cannot, by any stretch of the imagination, be able to involve themselves in the full participation of Australian society. But the people cling to their land and governments are generally willing to help them survive, and indeed make a virtue of doing so.

An entire political party, the Nationals, is devoted – or at least was – to funding a lifestyle choice to live in rural and regional environments, however remote, inconvenient and expensive they may have becom

So those in need receive subsidised education and health care, transport and communications as a matter of course, not to mention drought and flood relief, and many other forms of assistance – the diesel fuel rebate and the super phosphate bounty to name but two. An entire political party, the Nationals, is devoted – or at least was – to funding a lifestyle choice to live in rural and regional environments, however remote, inconvenient and expensive they may have become.

But governments go much further than that; the cities are also pampered when it suits. What is middle and upper class welfare but tax-payer funded lifestyle choice? Superannuation tax concessions for the rich, rebates for private hospital care, handouts for the wealthy schools of wealthy parents – all go into the pot. Abbott’s now deferred paid parental leave bonanza is one of the few which has been seriously challenged.

And at times there is not even a pretence of justification to give greedy votes what they believe to be their due in offering to fund their lifestyle choices, especially during election times. The politicians scour the country for the opportunity to raid the pork barrel; electorates are showered with benefits. Parks and gardens, sporting facilities, performance venues, upgraded bus stops – there are no limits.

Many years ago Gough Whitlam’s staff used to joke that when they flew into a new electorate, they would look out the window: if they saw a river they would promise a dam, if they didn’t they would promise a College of Advanced Education. Only the lifestyle choices have changed.

Obviously this is particularly rife in marginal electorates, which live from triennium to triennium of the certain beneficence of taxpayers funds, but the grateful winners are not denied either: in 2013 Tony Abbott’s opulent constituency of Warringah received a handsome grant to tart up Brookvale Oval. Some of these projects can be called worthy, but many are clearly simply electoral bribes, based on what the politicians see as enhancing their own self interest in getting re-elected – funding their lifestyles, in fact.

For Abbott to single out the most needy and deprived of them, the wretched of the outstation movement, is not only unfair; it is just irrational. Funding taxpayers’ lifestyles is precisely what governments do.

So why did Abbott, who prides himself on his empathy with Aboriginal Australians, say something so silly? The cynical will say that it was a deliberate ploy: Abbott was determined to shore up his support both among the hard-line conservatives in the party room who insist that he must abandon any remaining attempt to play Mr Nice Guy, and more importantly to the populists in the electorate who have always regarded his commitment to Aborigines as a distraction, and one that he could far better spent on benefits conferred on themselves.

Well, perhaps. But there is an old and well-tested adage in politics that if you have to choose between a conspiracy theory or a stuff up, nine tomes a out often it will be the stuff up. The simplest answer is almost certainly the right one: Tony Abbott, in spite of all his protestations of reform, of consultation, of listening to the people, has reverted to the habit of a lifetime and shot his mouth off and refused to recant or apologise; he will bluff it out and to hell with the consequences, even if it means that all his plans for reconciliation and his memorial as the Prime Minister of Aboriginal Affairs who delivered the long awaited constitutional recognition for of Indigenous Australia has to be ditched.

Perhaps, in the excitement of the last few weeks, he has been just a bit punch drunk. Yes, the same old Tony Abbott.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Tony Abbott isn’t as stupid as he looks. Apart from the squattocracy’s (Liberal/National party) traditional, instinctual approach of kicking those least able to resist,the poor and those kept from higher education by exorbitant university fees. There are plenty who agree that this new era of racism is on the nose, and I believe that this is Tony’s desperate ploy to slow his inevitable death spiral. By appealing to those who see the pit- falls of creating a class of ‘more equal’ citizens.

    We’d all be sitting around in the country if we could. However the reality is most of us have to work for a living. Real Australians can’t just go bush and expect the services, that are available in the city ( to those who can afford them ! ) To be provided gratis and on demand.
    Aboriginal life expectation has been doubled, since civilisation arrived and this should be appreciated along with all the other indispensable aides to ‘traditional culture ‘ like Toyotas, TVs, laptops, telescopic sights and tinnies.
    All Australians are equal and aboriginal people are no special case.

    I not only claim equality, I demand it. If you or anyone else thinks otherwise that is racism !
    My ancestors were French/ Irish/ Scots and were subject to “bullying, put downs, cultural and social genocide, murder, rape and pillage; when your children have been ripped from you and placed in hostile homes as servants; when everything you believe and believed in has been torn from you –” and then exiled to the ends of the Earth, you begin to understand the experience of colonial Australians.
    The last two hundred years have been an horrendous era for millions worldwide and Aboriginals are nothing special. What happened here was British Imperialism, the same as in Africa ,India,America,China and the Middle East etc. it was terrible but it was two hundred years ago.
    The future is the only time that matters and it’s about time to realise we are all in the same boat and all equal.

  2. Get over yourself, Mungo. You and your ilk are getting so bloody boring with all this personal pettiness against Abbott. The guy’s certainly made a few mistakes but weighed against his main achievements, they pale into insignificance, especially amongst those of us for whom the greatest nightmare would be a return to the chaos of the Rudd/Gillard fiasco.

    Why don’t you join the outraged chorus over his harmless and friendly remark about St.Paddy’s Day? Oh, I see, you’re saving that for next week? I look forward to reading that.

    Gotta larf!

    • Mungo is a fully tenured cog in the Echo hierarchy. Unfortunately, that means no matter how disconnected with reality he continues to get, many long suffering Echo readers will still have to make that extra effort of flipping past his page of Whitlam Dreaming propaganda.

  3. The truth is he is tokenistic towards all non anglo groups which when coupled with his tendency to tell the room what it wants to hear leads to the superficial utterances which have been the one consistent trait of his time in public office.

  4. Abbott is Howard’s apprentice and Howard was calculatingly cold.
    Peta and his minders would ensure that every word is scripted for maximum vote gain.
    Pauline is history but her fans are still there waiting for the next Messiah.

  5. Warren Mundine said he would ask the Prime Minister “for the third time, to lift his game” in regard to appallingly ignorant and offensive Aboriginal Life Style comments. It is painfully obvious Abbott does not have this ability.

    In his avalanche of inappropriate outbursts, he, today (Thursday) spewed a Nazi tirade against Bill Shorten, Leader of the Opposition. Mark Dreyfus, Shadow Attorney General who is Jewish took understandable offence – and Speaker Bronwyn Bishop displayed blatant Anti-Semitism by unfathomably removing him from the House.

    How long can Australia tolerate such an inadequate person usurping the role of Prime Minister ? His continuing embarrassment to the high Office; the people of this Country; and indeed the increasing number of Leaders & others overseas who are beginning to ridicule his woefulness must surely call for rectifying action sooner rather than later.

    It gets worse and worse day by day !


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Nuclear Submarines – just a foot in the door

In the next few months we will hear a lot about how superior nuclear-powered submarines are. Vice Admiral Mike Noonan is even claiming superior stealth characteristics – which is simply not true. Yes, they tend to be faster. This is great if you want to go thousands of kilometres in a matter of days. But they are also much more expensive.

Compost back on Lismore’s gardening menu

Lismore City Council says that their BIOCycle Compost is again on sale from the Lismore Recycling & Recovery Centre and Nimbin Transfer Station, after a two-year break.

Tony’s reflections as king of the Macadamia Castle

Looking back on 14 years at the Macadamia Castle, Tony Gilding says the important things to him were the conservation of the animals and the development of staff.

Getting annoyed with NSW Farmers naming ‘rights’

The Annoying Vegan has become more annoyed today with what they see as the NSW Farmers getting on their high horse about the use of the words ‘meat’ and ‘milk’.