23.3 C
Byron Shire
February 24, 2024

Spare Boston bomber from death penalty: Bali duo’s lawyer

Latest News

Lighthouse Road

The section from the bus stop on Lighthouse Road to the divide of the road to Byron Bay, is...

Other News

Editorial – Prosecuting publishers

WikiLeaks founder and Australian citizen, Julian Assange, will soon face possibly his final court hearing in the UK High Court of Justice over whether he should be extradited to the US to face spying charges. 

Tallowood Estate open space deal on hold

Byron Shire Councillors have deferred a decision on whether to accept an offer on a large parcel of forested ridgeline land above the Tallowood Ridge Estate near Mullumbimby.

4,000 failed

I attended the flood forum held at the Ballina RSL last Monday and was aghast to hear some of...

1,000 people attend BJJ tournament

Over 1,000 people flocked to Byron Bay on the weekend to either compete or spectate at one of Australia’s...

Government amends Biosecurity (Fire Ants) Emergency Order

As the spread of fire ants into the north of the state becomes more apparent, the NSW Government has made amendments to the Biosecurity (Fire Ants) Emergency Order in an attempt to stem fire ant migration.

River to the sea

Here we go again. Another example of the antisemitic slur ‘from the river to the sea’ from Mary McMorrow...

Boston bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev has been sentenced to death. Photo FBI
Boston bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev has been sentenced to death. Photo FBI

The Boston Marathon bomber should not be put to death and Australia must vocally oppose the sentence brought down against Dzhokhar Tsarnaev for his role in killing four people and the wounding of hundreds of others in 2013, Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran’s lawyer Veronica Haccou said yesterday.

Ms Haccou said execution must never be tolerated, no matter how terrible the crime. Just hours before her clients’ executions last month she vowed to fight the death penalty, no matter what the circumstances, because of its barbaric and inhumane nature.

‘Whatever the justification for the death penalty, it is nothing but premeditated, state-sanctioned murder,’ Ms Haccou said.

‘What are we teaching the younger generation by executing people? Killing people is wrong… It is so wrong that we kill people to prove our point? That is not justice, it is vengeance. We as society do not benefit in participating, or being complicit, in such acts of violence,’ she said.

Ms Haccou, who detailed her harrowing ordeal as a mother, herself, forced to see traumatised mothers peeled off their children, said execution was something no condemned person, or family of such a person, should ever be forced to go through no matter what the circumstances.

She said it was always a situation of people with power abusing such power as no one had the right to take the life of another. And in the case of her clients, there had been so many inconsistencies by the Indonesian judicial system that it bordered on the bizarre.

‘Such behaviour by the president, who even admitted to failing to read my clients’ cases before rejecting clemency, is frankly beyond belief, when he knew he was sending them to their deaths. He had said previously that he “shouldn’t be expected to read everything”. Well, when it is about human lives, that should be the least he could do.

‘The inconsistencies were quite perplexing. None of it made any sense. Towards the end, President Widodo kept saying it was no longer his decision but a matter of law, despite his power to grant clemency. Yet, while choosing to reject my clients’ clemency applications, he granted pardons to three murderers.’

Ms Haccou said such contradiction was not the purview solely of Indonesia and was a potential in all death penalty cases, where cruel and inhumane suffering was meted out to the young and innocent as well as those found guilty of a criminal offence.

Australian lawyers Julian McMahon (L) and Veronica Haccou (R) listening to an appeals hearing for Australian drug smugglers on death row Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran at the Jakarta State Administrative Court on April 6, 2015. AFP Photo / Romeo Gaca
Australian lawyers Julian McMahon (L) and Veronica Haccou (R) listening to an appeals hearing for Australian drug smugglers on death row Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran at the Jakarta State Administrative Court on April 6, 2015. AFP Photo / Romeo Gaca

Ms Haccou, barrister Julian McMahon and Consul-General Majell Hind had been up for 24 hours before Mr Chan and Mr Sukumaran were executed, trying to do whatever they could to help the men, their families and seven others slated to die alongside them.

‘To witness these mothers, families and two young boys visiting their loved ones for what, in most cases, was the last time, was difficult to bear,’ Ms Haccou said.

‘Seeing the two little boys of Mary Jane (Veloso) was particularly hard. Every single female guard in the prison had tears in her eyes. Many of the others were visibly distressed and apologised for what they were forced to do,’ she said.

Ms Haccou said she was so proud of her reformed clients who were overheard bolstering the courage of those being led to death with them, through song, before all were shot dead. It had proved the men were genuine in their concern for others because, at the end, no ulterior motive (as suggested by some skeptics in regards to their charitable work) could have been operating when choosing to relieve the suffering of those dying alongside them.

‘I only hope they heard of Mary Jane’s last minute reprieve. They were such thoughtful boys to the very end and held no malice towards the Indonesian people, who they had come to love and help through the use of their own money and resources. Their loss was such a waste to these people as well.’

Ms Haccou said reform was always possible, even in the case of the Boston bomber, and mistakes, politics and retribution often played too much of a role in the death penalty being imposed.

‘It feels to me like justice is just a game. Indonesia kept claiming the right to its sovereignty, yet continues to work hard to save its own citizens on death row abroad, including those on drugs offences. In February, the attorney-general was quoting an SMS Morgan poll saying most Australians were in favour of the executions, anyway. He said, ‘It is one of the things that pushes us to feel we are not making a mistake’.

These were good strong men who deserved to live and had something to contribute to society. They have asked me to continue this fight against the death penalty and I will. Nothing ever condones the use of the death penalty. Nothing is ever achieved by such actions.’

Ms Haccou said she intended to speak out on the subject whenever she was given the opportunity and said the Australian Government must remain consistent with opposition to the penalty in all situations without exception.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Not likely. I’m speaking from an Australian citizens point of view. How can anyone think that Dzhokhar’s actions could be considered an innocent mistake, one that he should be forgiven for making. Bizarre is how I rate the aspirations of the lawyer making the suggestion.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

4,000 failed

I attended the flood forum held at the Ballina RSL last Monday and was aghast to hear some of the facts presented. 4,000 people...

Knitting Nannas get behind Save Wallum campaign

With porcelain tea cups, lace-covered tables and plenty of knitting the Knitting Nannas Against Greed (KNAG) headed to the basecamp of the Save Wallum...

NPWS wants to remove beach nudity option

For 26 years, Tyagarah Beach has been an oasis for the region’s naturist community – a space where bodies of all shapes and sizes could roam free without threat of fines or reprimands.

‘Key workers’ removed from Ballina Council’s housing project as Mayor seeks full market rents

Essential workers were the losers at the recent Ballina Council meeting when councillors actively removed the category for ‘key workers’ from their development of rental housing on land it owns in Wollongbar.