19.3 C
Byron Shire
April 20, 2024

Mungo: As cops bribe crooks, Tony moralises and Bill folds

Latest News

Save Wallum now

The Save Wallum campaign has been ongoing and a strong presence of concerned conservationists are on site at Brunswick...

Other News

WATER Northern Rivers says Rous County Council is wrong

WATER Northern Rivers Alliance says despite decades of objection, Rous County Council have just commissioned yet another heritage and biodiversity study in the Rocky Creek valley, between Dunoon and The Channon, in the heart of the Northern Rivers.

Teenager arrested following an alleged stabbing

A teenager remains in police custody following an alleged stabbing at a church in Sydney’s south-west overnight.

Northern Rivers rugby league underway for 2024

Senior rugby league got off to a good start for the 2024 season with Byron Bay, Ballina and Mullumbimby teams picking up competition points.

Tweed Council wants your ideas on future sports facilities

Tweed Council is looking for feedback from residents about future plans for sport and recreation in the area.

Wallum urban development back in court

The company behind the Wallum housing development in Brunswick Heads is once again taking Byron Council to court, this time for allegedly holding up its planned earthworks at the site in an unlawful manner.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Shopping Centres Scare Me

I feel trapped. There isn’t a single time I attend where I don’t check my proximity to the exits, or imagine what I’d do if there was a fire, or worse, a shooter. The sense of being enclosed is unnatural, I can’t tell what time of day it is, I lose my sense of direction. It’s designed to be disorienting. It feels otherworldly. And never in a good way. They are designed to make you stay longer. They are by design, disorienting.

Mungo MacCallum

Our prime minister deals in absolutes. Coal is good for humanity – not some coal or some parts of humanity. No suggestion that coal can have its disadvantages, adverse consequences, to sully its benefits. There are no qualifications: coal is good for humanity. The sky is blue, the grass is green, beauty is truth, truth beauty; that is all ye know on earth and all ye need to know.

And it’s a similar story with border protection: the most moral thing you can do is to stop the boats. No matter that this eternal verity does not even appear in Tony Abbott’s own catechism: there is no mention of Thou Shalt Stop the Boats among the Ten Commandments, nor does the Sermon on the Mount contain the message Blessed are the boat-stoppers, for they are the most moral of us all.

Abbott’s repeated insistence that everything that has been done to stop the boats has been lawful may or may not be true: he refuses to adduce any evidence to support it. But even if it is to be accepted – at least as far as Australian law is concerned – it has almost nothing to do with morality.

Indeed, when it comes to paying off people smugglers to return the hapless cargo to Indonesia, it may not even be good policy; as one historically minded commentator has reminded us, once you pay the danegeld, you will never get rid of the Dane. And moral, except in a strictly ends-justify-means sense, it most certainly is not.

Crooks bribing cops is what crooks do. But it is a bit different from cops bribing crooks, which is what we are talking about.

The best Abbott’s boosters have been able to say is that it is probably no more immoral than some other behaviour regarding people smugglers. Abbott’s bestie, The Australian’s foreign editor Greg Sheridan assures his readers that the smugglers often bribe Indonesian police to give them a green light. And no doubt they try it – crooks bribing cops is what crooks do. But it is a bit different from cops bribing crooks, which is what we are talking about.

And it has also been revealed that it was likely – again no one will confirm it – that in the past Australian officials have bribed people smugglers or their cohorts to provide information. Distasteful, certainly, but paying phizzgigs is accepted police practice. What is rather more unusual is paying the crooks to continue and resume their previous criminal activities, especially when there are innocent victims who may be involved.

However this fine distinction has successfully confused the issue to the extent that has taken the government largely off the hook at a time when it appeared to have been floundering. Two ministers, Julie Bishop and Peter Dutton who should have been in the loop initially responded by indignantly denying that it had ever happened, only to tacitly admit after more mature consideration, that they had perhaps misspoken. Since then both they and all their colleagues have followed the rote mantra of offering the lawful line, while refusing to discuss what they call operational matters. Bribery is operational? Some operation.

This ritual secrecy is, of course, somewhat selective; Sheridan, for one, seems to have little trouble unearthing his version of what happened when it is in the interests of the government. And the Indonesians are far from satisfied – but who cares about the Indonesians? What matters is the domestic politics, and it is here that Bill Shorten, having announced that he would prosecute the case to the utmost, has once again folded.

It is almost beyond belief that Shorten and his advisers were apparently not aware, or did not check, that the bribes had not emerged overnight; the cops and spooks were just as likely to have slipping their backhanders to willing traffickers in the Rudd-Gillard years, if not before. A modicum of due diligence would have had Shorten prepared for the counter attack, and to be able to explain the gross discrepancy between what happened then and what has allegedly happened now. But it appears that the Labor leader is just as myopic about the past as about the future.

Instead of going after the shadowy figure of Agus (clearly an assumed name – perhaps a mispronunciation of Argus, the ever-seeing watchman of the gods) and the broken deal that saw the crew and their hapless passengers to transferred to two other vessels with a minimum of fuel and food, as a result of which one ran out of juice and the other, now overloaded, ran aground and needed rescue by the long-suffering locals – instead of pursuing this clear evidence of cruelty, betrayal and danger to life attested by both the crew and the asylum seekers, the leader of the always loyal opposition again fell into silence and went to water.

And the same lack of prescience has now caught up with the allegations over his trade union dealings in the past. He called the Heydon commission a witch hunt, and predicted that it would be used to target Labor leaders and particularly him, but he apparently did nothing to forearm himself when the attack boiled over from the courtroom into the parliament and the media. Now he is again on the defensive. He may clear himself of the charges, but he is unlikely to allay the feeling that he has been an opportunist, always looking for personal advancement as the main chance.

Talk that he is vulnerable as the party leader is fanciful; not only he is protected by the Rudd rules, but a justified fear that he would unleash a fearsome retaliation and vengeance against any move to challenge him has potential contenders effectively cowered. The party room is secure. But the electorate is another matter. After a long period of indecision, the voters are moving increasingly to the conclusion that Bill Shorten simply can’t hack it.

His position is perhaps similar to that of an opposition leader of some 20 years ago; in 1996 Malcolm McGregor noted that the only reason John Howard won that federal election was because he was standing against Paul Keating. If he had been unopposed, he would have lost. So Shorten must be desperately hoping that Tony Abbott can hang on as Prime Minister. That looks like being his last, best hope.




Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Succinct and to the point as usual. Only thing is, strictly speaking the boats haven’t been stopped. Maybe they’re not reaching Australia but the bullshit line pushed both parties about “breaking the people smugglers’ business model” obviously hasn’t worked. If anything, if paying them to turn back is what’s happening, then like any smart business operator, they’ve changed their model to adapt to the new conditions and are probably doing very well!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Can Council’s overturn their decisions?

NSW Labor planning minister, Paul Scully, when asked about the Wallum estate by local MP Tamara Smith (Greens)  in parliament on March 20, said,...

The bridges of Ballina Council

Ballina Shire Council has started preliminary investigation works at Fishery Creek Bridge, on River Street, and Canal Bridge, on Tamarind Drive, as part of their plan to duplicate both bridges.

Tweed Council wants your ideas on future sports facilities

Tweed Council is looking for feedback from residents about future plans for sport and recreation in the area.

REDinc’s new Performing Arts Centre is go!

It’s been a long wait, but two years on from the 2022 flood REDinc in Lismore have announced the official opening of a new Performing Arts Centre.