12.3 C
Byron Shire
April 14, 2021

Koalas become a political football

Latest News

Local sailor triumphs in blustery Brisbane to Gladstone yacht race

Local sailor Craig Watson battled near gale-force winds on Coopers to have one of his best ever Brisbane to Gladstone yacht races claiming fourth place in line honours.

Other News

Vehicle sanitisation stations roll out

Enhanced safety measures for point to point transport such as taxis, hire and rideshare vehicles are being rolled out in Byron Bay, Ballina and Lismore with the opening of three free temporary vehicle sanitisation stations.

Industry response to Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety

As the pandemic has again highlighted the standard of treatment of our elders, Australia’s aged care industry has urged...

Sick to my stomach

Gabi Giacomin, Ocean Shores I cannot believe it! We have voted for a Green MP, a Green Council, we have...

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and beyond for the week beginning 14 April, 2021

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and beyond for the week beginning 14 April, 2021

Murwillumbah Arts Trail coming in May

The sixth Murwillumbah Arts Trail is all set for the weekend of 29-30 May 2021. From its beginnings in 2015, the arts trail has grown to be a major festival for the visual arts, as well as a vibrant community event.

Armed robberies in Northern Rivers

Police have been investigating two armed robberies this week, one in Byron Bay and one in Lismore.

The controlling rightwing Byron shire council faction have again delayed action on saving the region’s dwindling koala population, citing their inability to understand a key document aimed at the marsupial’s preservation.

Additionally, ‘glaring errors’ and legal issues were claimed by Cr Di Woods, along with its potential to ‘lock up land’.

Four years in the making and at a cost of $60,000, the Koala Plan of Management (KPoM) outlines legal parameters and sets a course to improve local koala numbers, which are estimated to be below 200.

The KPoM was prepared by consultants Douglas Jardine and Dr Stephen Phillips, with input from a Project Reference Group comprising key stakeholders and state and local bureaucrats.

But at last Thursday’s meeting, Crs Hunter, Woods, Cubis and Wanchap outvoted Crs Dey, Spooner and Cameron (Crs Ibrahim and Richardson were absent) in adopting the long-awaited plans. Staff also recommended adopting the KPoM.

Instead, a peer review will be commissioned, to be undertaken by a ‘preferred’ competing consultancy, the Koala Ecology Group, based at the QLD Uni. No costs associated were discussed.

Cr Woods told the chamber that while she was ‘determined we will have a comprehensive koala plan of management, when we we do it, it will be a workable document, and not 78 pages long.’

She then accused the authors of ‘glaring errors’, and said, ‘The suggestion to use [instead] the QLD Uni consultants is to get it away from NSW, as result of legal advice we have had.’  When pushed by Cr Spooner to reveal specifics, she said that advice was confidential.

She said, ‘I have major concerns we will be challenged many times over unless we get it right. Our area is huge, and I read a report last night from NSW Local Government. Our Shire wasn’t even mentioned as a critical area… we are not doing what we are supposed to be doing here, we are just locking up land.’

Similarly, Cr Wanchap challenged the KPoM, arguing that it focused too much on the loss of habitat while not paying attention to other factors that are leading to koala deaths, such as disease. But it’s a position unsupported by the NSW Office Of Environment & Heritage. Their website www.environment.nsw.gov.au/animals/TheKoala.htm states, ‘loss and degradation of habitat’ is the ‘main threat’ to koala populations.

Additionally, leading koala conservation groups such as www.koalasincare.org.au also hold that view.

Regardless, Cr Wanchap told the chamber the answer is to create a sanctuary on two hectares of West Byron land to house the remaining population as a tourist attraction. She even said it could house ‘all our wildlife’ and tourism will fund it. She criticised the KPoM for not including tourism solutions or government funding possibilities, as outlined in a report for Port Stephens Council.

‘It’s very confusing,’ she said, ‘many points are unclear and ambiguous.’

‘I wanted the revised plan in red to see the changes. I wanted a workshop instead of being slammed with it in seven days.’


Illiterate councillors v flawed reports

So is the KPoM too hard to understand and flawed, or are the majority councillors just blocking it for political reasons?

While a submission on the KPoM by the Planners North group in early 2014 agrees with Crs Woods and Wanchap that it is dense and difficult to read, they argue that the KPoM is technically proficient and comprehensive.

‘[It] is not a document aimed at capturing the imagination and enthusiasm of the great bulk of the community,’ their submission reads.

And that view is supported by Cr Duncan Dey (Greens), who told The Echo, ‘The lack of logic [from Crs Wanchap and Woods] is sad: it is a planning document that will guide development, and it must thus withstand court challenges. The planners and lawyers are the folk who have to understand it. A better stance by the Councillors would have been to adopt it, and have a plain English summary published.’

He added, ‘The problem is that by the time we get a KPoM, there may be no koalas to accommodate in the habitat that the KPoM should preserve/create.’

Additionally, Friends of the Koala president Lorraine Vass agrees the delay is entirely political and questioned the councillor’s competency in understanding basic planning instruments.

She told The Echo, ‘In my view the resolution is quite mischievous and demonstrates to me that Council’s pro-development cohort doesn’t want any sort of planning framework for managing Byron’s coastal koalas. They may protest that the draft plan doesn’t measure up but from what I’ve seen and heard their understanding of State Environmental Planning Policy (SEPP) 44 and comparable comprehensive koala plans of management are at best confused.’

‘As for preferring the UQ Koala Ecology Group to peer review the CKPoM and mapping, I would have hoped that such a review (given the resolution) would be unquestionably independent and unbiased. That seems unlikely, given the very public critique that the UQ Koala Ecology Group has published on the SAT methodology used by Biolink, and the less public disagreement over the impact of music festivals, etc.’


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. It is obvious to all, that Woods, Wanchap etc ( the gang of five ) have about as many principals as Adolf Hitler addressing the Jewish Welfare Society. This group will singlehandedly be the main instigators in the extinction of the Kolas in our Shire.
    The only thing that they seem to do efficiently is to be the bum boys/ bum girls of the developers with no consideration for the welfare of our native Fauna/Flora or any thing else that requires protection.
    The next Council elections cannot come quick enough.

    • Would you expect anything else from the gang of five.
      This group will singlehandedly, together with their developer mates be the main instigators in the extinction of the Koala in our shire.
      The next Council elections cannot come quick enough.

  2. “Cr Wanchap told the chamber the answer is to create a sanctuary on two hectares of West Byron land to house the remaining population”
    Well, that’s got rid of the koala problem, now we can build!

  3. The inability of Councillors to understand technical and scientific reports is not unusual, hence the need to rely upon educated and experienced staff. The further inability to link destruction of habitat to an increase in stress related disease as a major killer of koalas flies in the face of good science. The ridiculous suggestion that we establish a fenced sanctuary to house our surviving wild koala populations misses the whole point. Saving a species is not about establishing zoos and tourist parks, it is conserving the habitat and natural linkages that allow the iconic species to survive in the wild. It seems as though we have gone back to the 1960’s!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Local girls go big at Oz grom cup

Byron Bay’s Leihani Kaloha Zoric won her second Billabong Oz Grom Cup title, taking out the 10-and-under girls division at Park beach in Coffs Harbour last weekend.

Sprout lovers

Sprouts can sometimes be overlooked on the weekly grocery list… except for those in the know, of course!

Interview with Mitch King from Dream Bigger

Dream Bigger is presenting Lismore Youth Festival in partnership with numerous organisations in Lismore. Dream Bigger connects established artists with potential future artists to make their ideas a reality through engaging workshops and collaboration. The Echo spoke to Mitch King from Dream Bigger.

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and beyond for the week beginning 14 April, 2021

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and beyond for the week beginning 14 April, 2021