13.8 C
Byron Shire
May 22, 2024

We won’t eradicate ISIS by bombing them

Latest News

Trains on roads

Soon we will have electric self-driving cars. The number of cars around the world could drop to ten per...

Other News

Mullum Road upgrade

Construction is expected to commence in December to improve the flood-prone Mullumbimby Road near Uncle Tom’s corner.

Danny’s world

Danny Wakil would have us believe that Israel is a sweet little peace-loving ‘sister democracy’ that can do no...

Dance for Brazil

The Mahico and Aruanda crews are joining hands to invite the entire community to be a part of Dance for Brazil – a day to flood Brazil with support, this Sunday in Byron Bay.

Feudalism alive

The increasingly restrictive parking at New Brighton shows feudalism is alive and well. It is understandable – wanting to protect...

Shh – it’s Secret Bridesmaid’s Business

It is the very eve of Meg’s wedding – her mother is fussing over every detail and her best friends are doing little to help. The wedding is the gala event that Meg has dreamed of since she was a girl and one that has taken far too long to come true. But, anything that can go wrong does until the veil is lifted on an unhappy secret, and Meg’s dream is rocked by a revelation she doesn’t want to be true.

Big tech, porn, violence and young blokes

I know it’s time we talked. The trouble is, I don’t know exactly what to say. But let’s try this...

Richard Mordaunt. Photo Jeff Dawson
Richard Mordaunt. Photo Jeff Dawson

Richard Mordaunt

None of us in our lifetime have seen such atrocious public assassinations as those carried out by IS.

It is the latest stage of the tragedy in Syria, with Islamic State’s publicized killings carried out to terrify the rest of the world.

Each day brings new heartbreaking stories as people risk everything to rescue their families from this war torn hell. With three million refugees and 200,000 dead, ending the four-year civil war between Sunni and Shiites in Syria has taken on an increasing urgency as  Islamic State gains more and more territory, assets and recruits, increasingly carrying out large scale terror attacks across the planet. The Ottawa parliament, the Lindt Cafe, Charlie Hebdo and now the atrocities in the centre of Paris.

Across the western world and south east Asia, there is now a new urgency to find  a solution in Syria and to create a global alliance countering Islamist violence  and preventing it from being brought home.

Islamic Sate has made it clear, this is ‘payback time’ against every western government that has occupied Muslim land. These are expressions of rage against history, past and present, that lurk within modern Islam and is animating militant fundamentalist Islam across the planet. This is particularly true of the Middle East.

40 years of American wars

At the end of the First World War, when Germany and the Ottoman Empire were defeated, the Middle East was divided between the empires of England and France, which spread across the planet. Syria was mandated to France and it wasn’t until the end of the Second World War that nationalist governments challenged the colonial set-ups and started to rebuild a new sense of identity.

In Egypt, Syria, Iraq, Libya and Iran, this meant military strongmen grabbing power. This coincided with vast amounts of oil being discovered and into this new equation came the US, with the Middle East becoming America’s new sphere of foreign policy interest.

It is the last 40 years of American wars across the planet that have produced the newly radicalized generation of young Muslims. One in five persons on this planet firmly believes in the prophet Mohammad and the Quaran granted permission to all persecuted Muslims the right to defend themselves.

Making matters worse

Wherever US, English, French or Australian forces are in a foreign country, they will be seen as an occupying force by part of the population and violent opposition to them will grow and their countries will become targets.

Grappling with this threat is now a key part of all our futures.

Conservative governments want to wipe out Islamic State, to eradicate them, but we know from history that this doesn’t work.

Tony Abbott took us deeper into the Middle Eastern War by sanctioning Australian bombing in Syria, even disregarding national boundaries. He was a fighter and knew no other way and would have put ground forces into Syria, just like the US military wishes to do.

This would create another Middle Eastern War just like Iraq but far worse.

Obama, who so many criticize, has refused to let the US military take this next step.

It was Blair who took Britain into the Iraq war with George Bush, to protect US and UK interests in the Middle East. The Iraq war is now regarded as an enormous mistake.

Islamic State have proclaimed the new caliphate to be ruled by sharia law. It was Mohammed who created the first caliphate and his succession was bitterly contested, dividing Muslims into Sunnis and Shiites. Shiites believed Ali, Mohammed’s son-in-law should have been his successor. Ali was assassinated, as were his sons Hasan and Hussein, creating the divisions within modern Islam.

Each Middle Eastern country now has its Sunni and Shiite populations. But there are many people throughout the Middle East who do not want to be ruled by sharia law.

The Middle East has many problems and it must be left to sort them out, country by country. This will have to include rewriting sharia law so that women’s rights are written into a modern secular constitution. We have meddled for too long and so often got it wrong. We must demand that out new PM brings our army, navy and air force home. Malcolm Turnbull is an intelligent man. He knows we should not be there.

Richard Mordaunt is one of Australia’s most experienced documentary filmmakers. One of his first films was shot in Syria in 1961. In 2010 he returned to the country and made The Secret History of the Assassins, just months before the current uprising began.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Correct,
    None of us were in Syria as we would be investigated by the Federal government for terrorism if we even thought of going there.

  2. So no international (or at least Western) intervention in Syria? How bad would the destruction, intolerance, human rights abuses, genocide, expansionism etc committed by the caliphate have to get before you thought it better to act. You suggest this caliphate is a new idea born of western meddling in the Mid East but it’s actually a very old and dangerous idea sanctioned by a religion that claims to be the only and final word of god. All the revealed religions are bad and have all had their periods of particular infamy. It’s Islam’s turn and the sooner moderate Muslims are able to bring on a reformation the better.

  3. OK, 40 years of American wars. Seriously dude?? Put aside your Far Left bias for one minute and answer this–where would these Muslim nations without US aggression. general mayhem and obvious evil intent? I’ll tell you, just in case you haven’t had an “a ha” moment. These tribes (they wouldn’t have evolved into nations) would be blissfully trekking the landscape on camels trading in bazaars, etc. and generally keeping their murderous sectarian habits in-house. You see, American and European technology gave them the wherewithal to join modern civilization. Guess what was behind it all? That heinous liquid of Satan — evil black gold–that stuff you (yeah, you Richard) and me use every day to lubricate our lifestyles. Muslim fanatics created Muslim terrorists, dude. It’s been going on for eons. Thanks to modern technology, they can now take the show worldwide. The world faced the same dilemma 75 years ago. But “evil” didn’t prevail. People got together and bombed the friggin’ hell out of them, chased them through the jungles, mountains, and city rubble until they were eliminated. It worked. Probably not a bad idea now.

  4. It was John Howard who ignored the largest democratic protests in the history of the planet, who then decided to invade Iraq.
    This was exactly the action that Hitler perpetrated and led to WW11.
    We lost the war on terrorism on 9/11 when it was demonstrated that no matter the power of a country’s armed forces, the country is vulnerable to any small group who cares to destroy the heart of the power structure .
    Sit back and get a good seat for the start of WW111! You sat back and allowed this to happen , now face the consequences.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Posters gone

I am writing to bring attention to a growing issue in our community – the removal of community posters. As a resident of this...

Bimbo Jimbo

For Treasurer Jim Chalmers to say that it was ‘simpler’ to just give everyone the energy rebate of $75 per quarter is stupid but...

Cartoon of the week – 22 May, 2024

The letters deadline for The Echo is noon Friday. Letters longer than 200 words may be cut. The publication of letters is at the discretion of the letters editor.

We Like to Tiki: Caper festival closing party this Sunday

North Byron Hotel is the official watering hole of Caper Byron Bay Food & Culture Festival 2024. To celebrate what is set to be...