Patten backs Abbott over Rhodes dispute

Oxford University chancellor Chris Patten. AAP Image/Alan Porritt

Oxford University chancellor Chris Patten. AAP Image/Alan Porritt

London, RAW – The chancellor of Oxford University has joined Tony Abbott in warning against rewriting history, in his first public comments on a student campaign to remove a statue of 19th century colonialist Cecil Rhodes from one of the university’s colleges.

Inspired by protests at the University of Cape Town in South Africa, which led to its statue of Rhodes being removed last April, the ‘Rhodes Must Fall in Oxford’ campaign says the statue at Oriel College in England celebrates a brutal racist.

Former Australian prime minister Abbott, himself an ex-Rhodes scholar, waded into the Oxford dispute in an email to British newspaper The Independent in December.

‘The students of Oriel should be clear-eyed about Rhodes’ faults and failings but proud of his achievements,’ Abbott wrote.

‘The university should remember that its mission is not to reflect fashion but to seek truth, and that means striving to understand before rushing to judge.’

The dispute is one of a growing number of university controversies over issues of history and identity, often pitting freedom of speech arguments against demands for symbols deemed offensive by some students to be removed.

In the United States, southern campuses have been rocked by arguments over the confederate flag, while at Yale a row erupted when an academic pushed back against suggestions that students should self-censor Halloween costumes to avoid causing offence.

Chris Patten, Oxford’s chancellor, spoke against removing the Rhodes statue in a speech widely reported on Wednesday.

‘Our history is not a blank page on which we can write our own version of what it should have been, according to our contemporary views and prejudices,’ he said.

A fervent imperialist and mining magnate, Rhodes was a central figure in Britain’s colonial project in southern Africa, giving his name to Rhodesia, present-day Zimbabwe, and founding the De Beers diamond empire.

A student at Oriel in his youth, Rhodes left the college money when he died, which helped fund the construction of the building where his statue stands in a niche on the facade.

The student campaigners see it as a ‘veneration’ of a man who made his fortune from the exploitation of African miners, secured power through bloody imperial wars, and paved the way to apartheid with his beliefs and measures on racial segregation.

‘(Rhodes Must Fall in Oxford) is NOT an attempt to ‘rewrite history’, but its opposite – a campaign to bring its uncomfortable truths to salience,’ said Jack Kellam, a political theory student at Oxford, on Twitter after Patten’s speech.

Patten, whose role as chancellor is largely ceremonial, told BBC Radio 4 that Oxford should welcome debate on historical issues, no matter how uncomfortable, but that taking aim at physical monuments was the wrong way to go.

‘Our cities are full of buildings that were built with the proceeds of activities, the slave trade and so on, which would nowadays be regarded as completely unacceptable,’ he said.

He asked rhetorically what should be done about Trinity College in Cambridge, which was founded by King Henry VIII, who had two of his six wives executed.

Patten, a former Conservative politician and governor of Hong Kong, also said that Rhodes’ views on race and empire were ‘common to his time’ and probably not very different from those of Britain’s World War Two hero Winston Churchill.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsors Artstate Lismore and NORPA. Sponsors-747-ArtState-NORPA-480px