13.8 C
Byron Shire
June 26, 2024

Egalitarianism versus libertarianism

Latest News

Cinema: Despicable Me 4

With the school holidays fast approaching it’s time to rev up the kids to see the ever-lovable Minions in the first Despicable Me movie in seven years.

Other News

Dirty Three with Eleanor Jawurlngali

New expanses to create. New music to share. The legendary trio Dirty Three are coming to The Green Room, Byron.

Yes, peace is the solution

Both Duncan Shipley-Smith and John Scrivener yet again display the same responses that I talk about over, and over...

Assange appeal

Yet another year has passed and Wednesday, 3 July is Julian Assange’s 53rd birthday. It will be the sixth birthday...

Interview with Steve banks

Steve Banks and The Sidemen are back for an intimate, partially-unplugged show at the Brunswick Picture House in Brunswick Heads on Saturday, July 6. The Sidemen – Jeff Burstin, Mike Mills, Grant Gerathy, Tony Slavich and Geoff Wright – are heading into a new venue, with new songs and a new format.

Martial arts legend to visit Byron Bay

Chan Cheuk Fai will visit Byron Bay to conduct a black belt grading for Jin Wu Koon Karate on Friday, July 5, and a combat seminar on Saturday, July 6.

The 2024 Lismore Eisteddfod will be bigger and better

Organisers of the Lismore Eisteddfod, the Lismore Musical Festival Society, are getting excited about their program for this year’s event. The regular competition venues are still unavailable owing to post-flood repairs continuing for a few more months. So this year the Bangalow A&I Hall will be used for the primary and secondary schools competitions as well as the Speech and Drama competition.

Geoff Dawe, Uki

The beginnings of civilisation with the Neolithic revolution can be seen as a vast mistake rather than a sign of Homo sapiens coming into its own.

The signature of the revolution was ploughing and animal husbandry. Science has since found humans are able to eat healthily without animal products and ploughing has been one step forward, two steps back.

Moreover, egalitarianism, or the understanding one human is worth no more than another, was mostly continued by tribal, pre-literate peoples. The civilised instead regressed to hierarchical social structures. ‘Regressed’ because hierarchical structures are part of the hominid world, whereas civilisation was supposed to be an advance from the limitations of human hominid origins.

The growth of narcissism in western society can be seen as children reaching adulthood without successfully negotiating the personal growth stages where the ‘me’ of childhood naturally metamorphoses to ‘us’. Idealistic young adults are one of the symptoms of successful negotiation of childhood where they look outward and attempt to aid the whole rather than particularly themselves.

The political movement of libertarianism, on the other hand, can be seen as narcissism operating as encouragement of a current dysfunctional competitive rather than cooperative (or reciprocal) economic system. Libertarianism can be conceived to be based in ‘me’ rather than ‘us’, in the immature rather than the grown human, in the law of the jungle rather than compassion.

Civilisation has been mostly a process of causing humans to turn their backs on humanness.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Geoff, you are sort of on the right track there but your timelines are way out – might I suggest you read a good introductory text on anthropology. Modern humans have long been omnivorous, and have lived in small groups that both hunted and gathered for many tens of thousands of years – traditional indigenous Australian life is a good example. Basic small scale swidden agriculture followed much later as did more complex animal husbandry. A more belligerent cultural pattern accompanied the move to closer settlement with the growth of more powerful individuals, but not hereditary classes. Traditional Papua New Guinean life is a classic example. More recently more intense sedentary agriculture accompanied the growth of hierarchical classes – Bali and Java are the best nearby examples. None of this has related to genetic changes. Modern humans live today in all three of the historic food gatheing/production forms, as well as in our industrial and post-industrial economies – and often in mixes of these (some indigenous Australians still hunt and gather but move around their country in Falcons and Commodores). I think your description of the growth of narcissism is good. I myself believe the reason is that we have not created a credible and widely accepted belief framework that enables people to grow to adulthood – Indonesians refer to that sort of selfless maturity as “jadi orang” – to become a human. I believe we can create a new understanding of our place in the realm – a new religion if you will – and though they might not call it as such many people on the North Coast are struggling to do that, with a concern for the environment and fairness to others that is exemplary in regional Australia. Spend some time around more liberal – not libertarian – churches like the Uniting Church and you will find people trying to relate their understanding of Jesus and his humanity to creating a sustainable, meaningful and not self-centred life in a post-industrial world.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Do gin and art mix?

  If you’re an artist, and want to win $5,000 for having your art and your name featured on a limited-edition bottle of gin, plus...

The masters of ‘zero to hero’

The masters of ‘zero to hero’ pub rock, The Tenants, are bringing their live show and Aussie humour to Mullum’s Courthouse Hotel for one night only on Thursday, July 4.

Gin with a slice of rainforest

Cape Byron Distillery, the B-Corp certified distillery from Byron Bay has released a gin flavoured with rainforest botanicals carefully selected by the five winning...

Dirty Three with Eleanor Jawurlngali

New expanses to create. New music to share. The legendary trio Dirty Three are coming to The Green Room, Byron.