7.8 C
Byron Shire
June 13, 2021

Nationals candidate missing in action at forum

Latest News

Sailor rescued from ocean in overnight operation

In a dramatic overnight rescue far offshore North-East of Yamba, Marine Rescue IIuka Yamba volunteers were able to bring to safety a woman who fell overboard from a dismasted catamaran in the dark.

Other News

Sailor rescued from ocean in overnight operation

In a dramatic overnight rescue far offshore North-East of Yamba, Marine Rescue IIuka Yamba volunteers were able to bring to safety a woman who fell overboard from a dismasted catamaran in the dark.

Healthy cane juice

We’ve all been there - walking through the Farmer’s Markets, a little parched, because we didn’t plan ahead. How...

High school attack

Dan Reade, Ocean Shores Mandy Nolan’s ‘Soapbox’ claim that schools have remained unchanged for the last 200 years, seems only informed...

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and beyond for the week beginning 9 June, 2021

All the fun and frolics of the shire in one happy place

Ballina’s Mariann Lloyd-Smith and her mission to stop toxics in the environment

Living quietly in beautiful Ballina is one of the global heavy-hitters in the fight to eliminate and control toxic chemicals, Dr Mariann Lloyd-Smith.

Developers aim to double Bayside suburb

Developers seeking to double the size of Bayside, a small suburb on the outskirts of Brunswick Heads, have responded to Echo questions around potential traffic congestion and the lack of open spaces.

Richmond candidates (l to r): Justine Elliot (Labor); Russell Killarney (Christian Democrats); Neil Smith (One Nation); Dawn Walker (Greens); and Angela Pollard (Animal Justice). Failed to attend: Matthew Fraser. Photo Hans Lovejoy
Richmond candidates (l to r): Justine Elliot (Labor); Russell Killarney (Christian Democrats); Neil Smith (One Nation); Dawn Walker (Greens); and Angela Pollard (Animal Justice). Failed to attend: Matthew Fraser. Photo Hans Lovejoy

Chris Dobney

A two-month election campaign is a long time, and no doubt an exhausting one, but the audience at last night’s Richmond candidates forum at the Byron Theatre was clearly disappointed that Nationals candidate Matthew Fraser was unable to make it.

Mr Fraser called in sick yesterday afternoon, an understandable situation, but democracy is poorer when candidates, especially key ones, are not available to face the voters directly.

That left Russell Killarney of the Christian Democrats and Neil Smith of One Nation to represent the right wing of politics.

Looney right

Just how far right became evident by some of their commitments: Mr Killarney wanted to take the fight up to some apparent plans to implement Sharia law.

To be fair, he did support full funding of Medicare and emergency services but seemed to have terrible trouble getting his mouth around the simple word ‘gay’.

One Nation’s Mr Smith, who described himself as ‘a retired engineer and a political virgin’, said he was running on ‘the inadequate penalties for criminals, the size of government borrowings, foreign aid, tax reform.’

‘Pauline’s a bit timid on tax reform. She wants to wait until she gets in until she does anything about it,’ he smilingly admitted.

During the debate Mr Smith was tripped up when he couldn’t nominate a figure or a percentage of GDP for Australia’s foreign aid, despite wanting to abolish it.

Cuddly left

At the other end of the spectrum, from the ‘cuddly left’, was Angela Pollard of the Animal Justice Party.

Ms Pollard, who cut her political teeth on the marriage equality campaign, said that while her party ‘doesn’t have policies on everything’ its overarching criteria of compassion and coexistence would determine how she voted.

The format of the forum saw each of the candidates in turn asked a specific question by MC Phillip Frazer, followed by an opportunity for audience questions.

His first question was for the absent Mr Fraser and it was a doozie; he asked it anyway and left it to the audience to judge.

‘At your launch you said, “people are genuinely sick of people working for big business, bank and unions instead of ordinary folk like us”. How can you represent locals “like us” when the coalition you work for represents big business and overseas interests?’

Justine Vs Dawn

But with Mr Fraser absent, it was clear the interest in the room lay overwhelmingly with Labor’s Justine Elliot and her neck-and-neck rival, the Greens’ Dawn Walker.

Ms Elliot is a veteran campaigner and spoke cogently, needless to say, but she also showed a greater willingness to depart from the party line than in the past, especially on the issues of party donations from fossil fuel companies and the approval of new coal mines.

Fossil fuel donations

Mr Frazer’s question to her reflected just this concern among many would-be Labor voters. ‘Do you believe accepting money from fossil fuel companies would have any affect on ALP policies? Doesn’t taking their money encourage the idea that corporations have assumed the right of being financial backers of government systems?

Ms Elliot responded, ‘I agree with just about everything you’ve said. I’ve signed the 350.org pledge in my own campaign, [not to take donations] from CSG miners but don’t think they would approach me anyway.

‘My personal view is I don’t think there should be any form of donations like that across the political spectrum. I personally would like to see a system of public funding for elections. But I feel particularly strongly regarding my campaign and how it’s run, although I acknowledge that may be different to party policy,’ she said.

Each of the candidates were given a brief time to respond to the others’ questions and Ms Walker argued on this issue that, ‘the policy of the two older parties on climate change is weak and confusing.’

‘In one ear they’re listening to community but in other ear they have the fossil fuel industry speaking loudly through the hip pocket. For every $1 donated they get $2k back in subsidies. The Greens don’t receive one cent [in fossil fuel company donations], never will, never want to.’

Ms Walker also spoke persuasively about the emerging role of the Greens in the regions as well as the cities, including her colleagues in state parliament, Ballina MP Tamara Smith and MLC Jan Barham.

Senate voting system

Mr Frazer’s question to her was on the Greens siding with the coalition to pass changes to the Senate voting system weeks before the double dissolution.

‘The Sex Party’s lead NSW Senate candidate described reforms’ primary purpose as being “to wipe out smaller parties.” Do you think Greens under Richard Di Natale have announced themselves as “open for business” with the big deal he would like to make [being] a formal agreement with ALP to govern?’ he asked.

Ms Walker responded that she was ‘very proud a longstanding policy Greens has finally been seen to fruition.’

‘It’s about allowing people to choose who to vote for. In the lower house we’ve got a system where people do need to number every box. The Senate changes were taking that sort of idea to that massive long ballot paper that was becoming unwieldy – people are now able to number 1-6 instead of just 1 and then not knowing where those preferences were going. In many cases that vote was ending up not even close to the original voter’s intention in the ballot box,’ she said.

All candidates agreed that there was a great deal of confusion around the Senate voting rules both before and after the changes. The fact that they were implemented so close to the election was part of Ms Elliot’s objection.

‘The ALP thought it was unfair for the minor parties,’ she said. They are part of democratic process.’

She added the party also had concerns about the potential ‘high rate of exhaustion of votes.’

There’s still some confusion at the booths. The Libs think will be an advantage to them but I don’t think it’s democratic or fair,’ she said.

Audience questions

Some colourful questions came from the floor too.

Former Greens MLC Ian Cohen asked Ms Elliot, ‘Would you prefer coalition government rather than governing with the Greens?’ which leader Bill Shorten has emphatically ruled out.

She responded, unsurprisingly, that she would prefer a Labor government with a majority.

‘Being realistic and honest, we want to deliver real reform, positive policies. We want to form a majority government to deliver and invest in future,’ she said, despite this seeming like a fading prospect.

At the other end of the spectrum, former CDC candidate Vivian Stott asked Ms Walker the most bizarre question of the night: ‘You want to subvert traditional marriage and motherhood… why are you trying to legalise cannabis?’

Ms Walker understandably didn’t know where to begin with this question and in the end uttered some platitudes that clearly didn’t satisfy Mr Stott, who walked off still raving.

A more direct question from Michael McDougall on the subject of  marriage equality drew an awkward response from CDC rep Russell Killarney, who said the party supported ‘the rights of people to be gay’ to titters from the audience.

Neil Smith from One Nation was equally mealy mouthed, saying, ‘marriage equality is not something we comment on in regards to our personal opinion. We want to go to a plebiscite and will accept the outcome.’

There were more questions from the floor on everything from climate change and the state of the reef to Gonski and why the Greens don’t have a 10-year education plan, the NBN, and Australia’s defence alliance ‘that attacks third world countries to support corporate interests’.

The responses were pretty much as expected, with Dawn Walker using the alliance question to raise the issue of the Trans Pacific Partnership and the Greens’ opposition to it.

By the end of the forum the audience, which itself was depleted compared to the number of attendees at the 2013 debate, seemed exhausted, while the candidates continued to smile and manoeuvre their way around the crowd. So that’s what it takes to make a politician.

The upside? There are just 10 days until polling day, and it’s all over for another three-ish years.

If you missed it, or want more, there will be a further Richmond candidates’ forum at the Mullumbimby Civic Centre this Sunday, June 26, at 1pm.

More stories on the 2016 federal election

Greens’ Richmond campaign ‘people powered, not fossil fueled’

The record vote by the Greens in Saturday’s federal election in Richmond has encouraged candidate Dawn Walker Greens to keep the ‘Green’ momentum going across the northern rivers.


Thus Spake Mungo: The worm turned, the maggots squirmed

My fearless prediction is that the coalition will end up with between 76 to 78 seats in the House of Representatives, a thin but decisive majority. But this is not the way it was meant to be.


A hung parliament? It may be the best we can hope...

Nearly three years ago, on the eve of the last Federal election, this web site warned that a Tony Abbott-led Coalition government presented a grim outlook for clean energy and climate change, and we warned too that it could be even worse than most people feared.


Elliot, Hogan retain their north coast seats

Incumbent northern rivers MPs Kevin Hogan (Page, Nationals) and Justine Elliot (Richmond, Labor) have retained their seats after a knife-edge federal election result which could see a hung parliament.


A voting guide for dummies

Still haven't made your mind up who to vote for yet? Well, crawl out from whatever rock you've been hiding under and pay some fricking attention. 
It's really quite simple. Just match your ideology with one of these political parties and away you go.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. You can always rely on Justine Elliot MP and Dawn Walker to turn up and contribute to community forums and answer truthfully. Both women are awesome and are100% for the community. I wish I could say the same for the Nationals. Sadly, they don’t – at least that’s been my experience with our community forums on local domestic and family violence forums.

  2. All smiling, all grinning as the cool winds blew in an election meeting of candidates for the people to grill. At any BBQ in the country Tony Windsor would say “You get 10 points for turning up.”

  3. There’s nothing cuddly about animal cruelty and Angela Pollard most certainly wouldn’t describe animal issues in this way. Nor is the Animal Justice Party left wing: its members, volunteers and voters come from a wide range of political perspectives, united in their desire to see animal issues taken seriously.
    Seeing as Australians have contacted their MPs about animal issues (live export, greyhound racing and puppy farms) more than any other issues in the past year, I’d like to see the AJP getting more than just a brief mention in important articles such as this one.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Three men stabbed in Goonellabah

Police say a man has been charged and will face court, while three men remain in hospital following an alleged stabbing yesterday.

Running out of time

Chibo Mertineit, Lillian Rock I just returned from the ‘Festival of Resistance’, which happened outside of the weapon expo at the Brisbane Exhibition and Convention Centre....

Three stabbed, man arrested – Lismore

Three men remain in hospital and a man’s been arrested following a stabbing in Lismore this afternoon.

Celebrating 35 years of The Echo

The Echo Awards, held every five years, was a great success on Wednesday night as it celebrated 35 years of local independent journalism in the Northern Rivers and the community that have supported it throughout those times.