13.8 C
Byron Shire
May 22, 2024

Turnbull intransigent as economy goes down the gurgler

Latest News

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Why are we so blasé about violent pornography?

Why is it a turn on to hurt us? Recent intersectional studies have shown that online misogyny and violent pornography are contributors to a sharp rise in domestic violence. In NSW alone, police attend 500 incidents every day. If there were 500 threats or incidents at banks, or to the government, we would be in a state of emergency. Instead we stop, shake our heads, we listen to good men in government speak empty words, make a few promises, and move on. If you’ve ever lived through violence, it’s pretty well what your abuser does after hitting you.

Other News

Fastest billycart clocked at over 40km/h at Bangalow Billycart Derby

Sunday saw around 5,000 people head to Bangalow to enjoy the Bangalow Billycart Derby with Greg Nash, Bangalow Lions Club President, telling The Echo that it was a ‘glorious autumn day'.

Pickleball takes Alstonville by storm as new courts open

Alstonville now boasts tournament-standard pickleball courts that opened to an enthusiastic crowd and players last Saturday despite the rain.

National Service

I have to say that having been conscripted into the army in 1970 I couldn’t disagree more with Peter...

Cabarita Beach powers up with new EV fast charger

The future of sustainable transport is rolling into northern NSW with the opening of a new electric vehicle fast charging station at Cabarita on the weekend.

Will Tweed Council support a community climate change forum?

A motion to support the creation of a Community Leaders Forum that would look at identifying projects and actions that the community can take in response to climate change.

Cartoon of the week – 22 May, 2024

The letters deadline for The Echo is noon Friday. Letters longer than 200 words may be cut. The publication of letters is at the discretion of the letters editor.

MungoMungo MacCallum

The constant refrain of economists who get it wrong is that we should never rely on just one set of figures.

And so when the September accounts emerged far worse that even the most pessimistic practitioners of the dismal science predicted, they hastened to assure us that once the entrails of next quarter’s chooks had been assessed, things would be better.

And they’d want to be: the GDP collapsed from rising by 0.6 per cent in June to falling by 0.5 just 12 week’s later – a drop of over a full percentage point, the worst result since the Global Financial Crisis.

Various excuses were proffered; the weather, the timing of the arrival of some helicopters, and perhaps it was really all Western Australia’s fault. And then there was the election itself, which had apparently engendered uncertainty and confusion rather than the jobs and growth promised. So we have negative growth; now for this week’s news on jobs, or the lack of them.

Malcolm Turnbull managed to ignore the first three months of his narrow escape; this was no more than a bump in the road, he had other things to shuffle aside. But his Treasurer, Scott Morrison, could not avoid comment, which he did initially by blaming Bill Shorten and the Labor Party for everything.

And his own solution? A demand to get behind the government’s program, a plea for a partnership with someone (presumably the crossbench) to join him in legislating company tax cuts. Given that by Treasury’s own forecasts it would add just one per cent, less than the drop in the last quarter, over the next 20 years, this was not the most enticing prospect. But it appears to be the only the one he can think of – tear a giant hole in revenue in the hope of a derisory return long after he and his colleagues are snug in their well-funded retirement homes.

So perhaps fortunately the caravan moved on, to watch Turnbull in his customary position – denying his own previous promises and convictions, ignoring physics, economics and common sense in yet another futile grovel to assuage the insatiable lunar right of his party room.

It is true that the wingnuts have their share of climate denialists, but the unpalatable fact is that the government, however reluctantly, is forced to do something about the international consensus that global warning cannot be ignored.

In the process he threw the hapless Josh Frydenberg under a bus, forcing him to perjure himself in supplication for daring to hint what all the experts had told him – that it might be worth considering – only considering, mind – an emissions intensity fund in the electricity industry would actually provide a cheaper and more reliable method of dealing with the mounting problems of the sector than doing nothing – which is, apparently, the government’s preferred option.

Even in the right’s own terms this does not make sense: it is true that the wingnuts have their share of climate denialists, but the unpalatable fact is that the government, however reluctantly, is forced to do something about the international consensus that global warning cannot be ignored. Turnbull, Frydenberg and even such outliers as Barnaby Joyce have agreed that the Paris accord to limit emissions must be met.

So that being the case, it would surely make sense to do so in the cheapest and least painful way possible – the way all the economists, the environmentalists, the government’s own chief scientist Alan Finkel and even those within the industry concur. But not in the coalition party rooms. Carbon tax, of course, cannot even be mentioned, as Turnbull trumpets. But nor, the prime minister now insists, can the merest suggestion of emissions trading. This is not rational – it is not even ideology. It is simple bloody mindedness.

And in the end it is utterly counterproductive: electricity prices will go up, more than they need to, and supply will be threatened. And while Australia will probably meet its emission reduction target in 2020, the prospect of making the Paris figure in 2030 is wildly impractical – unless, of course, this government, and incoming ones, are forced either to spend vast amounts of public money to overfund the manifestly inefficient mechanism of what is misleadingly called ‘Direct Action’, or more probably to see reason and return to market solutions like emissions trading. Hush my mouth.

And on this matter at least, it appears that our plastic prime minister is implacable. When the premiers met at COAG last week with a plea for a national agenda to end the state-based confusion on climate policy, Turnbull simply reiterated his – or Tony Abbott’s, or Cory Bernardi’s – current policy: no carbon pricing, no emissions trading. No nothing. We will bumble along as usual.

But he has not been entirely idle. Yet another leak tells us that the government is set to ditch Abbott’s signature Green Army – the bunch of youthful conscripts dragooned into an expensive make-work program to mask the real extent of youth unemployment. The real Greens’ Richard di Natale said it was about time – the Green Army was never an environmental initiative, which seems a bit harsh; some trees were planted, some weeds pulled.

But it led to few if any real jobs and will not be missed – any more than the rest of Abbott’s absurd Direct Action plan would be if Turnbull ever had the ticker to pull the plug. Once again it was a slap at Abbott which did no more than enrage the increasingly feisty pretender when what was need was a killer blow.

And the other news on the environment front is that Turnbull is still considering a billion dollar loan to the multinational mogul miner Adani on mate’s rates, although the company has already admitted that it doesn’t really need it in order to dig up a large part of the Queensland landscape and further endanger the great Barrier Reef in the process. Still, it would be a friendly gesture, so why not? The hell with GDP.

In spite of all this Turnbull remains determinedly upbeat: innovation (although not obviously, on environment policy) is still the key to everything, we must keep on keeping on, and sooner or later, something will come out right. It must, mustn’t it? The law of averages says so, and that is one scientific truth Turnbull is still willing to espouse.

Of course in the meantime he risks being exposed as an unprincipled coward, a fraud and a poltroon. But that will be just another poll. And you should never rely on just one set of figures…

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Trains on roads

Soon we will have electric self-driving cars. The number of cars around the world could drop to ten per cent because most people won’t...

Posters gone

I am writing to bring attention to a growing issue in our community – the removal of community posters. As a resident of this...

Bimbo Jimbo

For Treasurer Jim Chalmers to say that it was ‘simpler’ to just give everyone the energy rebate of $75 per quarter is stupid but...

Cartoon of the week – 22 May, 2024

The letters deadline for The Echo is noon Friday. Letters longer than 200 words may be cut. The publication of letters is at the discretion of the letters editor.