22.1 C
Byron Shire
December 2, 2021

Tirade at the unemployed a smarmy swipe

Latest News

Accusations of false dam claims in Cr Cadwallader’s mayoral campaign

Ballina Shire Council candidates against the idea of a new dam in Byron’s hinterland are accusing fellow candidate Sharon Cadwallader of false claims in her electoral campaign.

Other News

Pryce Allsop seeks reelection for Tweed Council

Cr Pryce Allsop was a Conservative member of the previous Tweed Shire Council and hails from Murwillumbah.

Why not both

The tender for the first section of the Rail Trail starting from Murwillumbah indicates that it is not more...

Kingscliff Public School gets long-awaited upgrade

If you were wondering what is happening at Kingscliff Public School, construction is well underway on an upgrade.

Cr Cadwallader ready to backflip on the dam?

So it was all one giant attention grabbing scare campaign about drinking piss and draining aquifers. In her interview with...

Lismore Council elections

I’m somewhat bemused by the candidates for the Lismore Council election. One ticket has 14 candidates, when there are...

Former Byron Mayor talks about the ‘Green challenge’

It’s not easy being green, it never has been, but we are proud of our long-term commitment to Greens...

John Scrivener, Main Arm. 

Colin Clarke’s latest tirade – Bangalow food hub opponents elitist – sets a new low for letters to the editor.

When he’s not spruiking for nuclear power and genetic engineering, Colin likes to use the Echo’s letters section to attack fellow letter writers and ‘you people’ who sit around doing nothing all day.

I can’t help but cringe when I read phrases like ‘too many people are happy to lean on the rest of society and take unemployment benefits’, especially when written by someone who likes to promote an industry that leans heavily on the rest of society, requires multi-billion dollar subsidies from governments but employs relatively few people.

The insinuation that unemployment is a result of people being happy to live on handouts not only smacks of prejudice, it completely obscures the actual causes and function of unemployment. Colin’s rhetoric might sound plausible to those who have never known economic hardship, but the truth is poverty sucks, and unemployment in this society equals poverty.

No one chooses to live in poverty: it is forced upon them by circumstances beyond their control. Many economists recognise that unemployment is due in large part to changes in the structure of the economy, for example manufacturing jobs going to countries with cheaper labour and fewer regulations. Technological advances such as automation also contribute to unemployment, with machines and computers now doing much of the work once done by labourers. Furthermore, it serves the interests of corporate owners to have a pool of unemployed workers, which helps keep wages down and workers submissive.

Jobs cost money and someone has to pay for them. How do we calculate the cost of a job for a politician, or a soldier? More money is spent on the employment of a few hundred politicians or a few thousand soldiers than is spent on a hundred thousand unemployed people. Think about the comparative value of these expenditures, all of which are paid by the taxpayer.

Most of the money going to politicians and the military ends up in off-shore tax havens and the coffers of multinational corporations, whereas every cent spent on the unemployed goes straight into the local economy. The unemployed play another important role: they serve as a scapegoat that can be smeared with impunity because, unlike the nuclear industry, they can’t afford an army of lawyers and lobbyists to protect and promote their interests.

Unemployment benefits are like a ball and chain that stigmatise and constrain the individual. These so-called benefits are not given out easily or willy-nilly by bureaucrats, despite claims to the contrary. They are provided only after applicants have jumped through hoops, navigated multiple obstacles and completed endless forms contrived to dissuade all but the most desperate.

I don’t accept the premise advanced by Colin Clarke, that the unemployed in our region are living in a false world, devoid of honest toil. I think his tirade amounts to little more than a smarmy swipe at the least privileged in our community.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Yo John, great letter but should you be in North Korea, China and maybe Russia for the tirade you have exacted from Main Arm. Your living in the wrong place dude.

  2. Hey John,

    Absolute garbage. Everyone has the abilty to make a choice and if people choose to flock to and live in Byron Shire when it is well known there are limited work opportunities, then they are indeed just lazy bludgers that are happy to live off the hardworking. There is ample work in Australia and if the poor young snowflakes are so determined to work, well then, why dont they move to an area where work is plentiful.

    The main problem with the shire is that every dreamer, wannabe life coach, therapist etc think its their right to enjoy the region while rarely contributing to the economic aspects that keep a society alive.

    More investment equals more jobs, wealthe creation for all and more happy families.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Minor flooding may occur Friday morning at Coraki and Bungawalbyn

Heavy rainfall on Tuesday and Wednesday have caused river level rises along the Richmond and Wilsons Rivers with the Wilsons River peaking overnight and the...

Lismore saw one new case of COVID-19

A new case of COVID-19 was confirmed in Lismore in the 24 hours to 8pm 30 November.

Want to make your own nest box and help with bushfire recovery on Friday?

Conservation Volunteers Australia are running a nest-building workshop in one of Australia’s most biodiverse hotspots, the Nightcap Range, ‘to create homes and hope for wildlife’.

Storylines – An escape from reality

I am a teacher. I teach at University Canberra, on Ngunnawal country, in ACT. This university went into ‘Lockdown’ about four months ago. We were...