Sea Shepherd activists investigate murky shark-net waters

The Sea Shepherd crew on watch. Photo supplied'

The Sea Shepherd crew on watch. Photo supplied’


Mia Armitage

Sea Shepherd activists say they were caught in a ‘Mexican stand-off’ with NSW government contractors three kilometres off Ballina’s shoreline on Sunday April 23.

It was the third mission Apex Harmony QLD campaigners have undertaken to check Ballina’s shark nets for wildlife in an effort to provide more ‘transparency’ on the north coast shark-meshing trial, co-ordinator Jonathan Clark said.

Mr Clark said his crew of four inspected nets at Shelly, Sharpes, Lighthouse and Seven Mile Beaches and observed fishers hired by the Department of Primary Industries (DPI) as they headed out to sea, in case they were towing a shark. 

Fewer checks

According to data in the first four monthly DPI bycatch reports, contractors have yet to achieve consistent twice-daily checks as per requirement, leading to the activists’ concern for wildlife.

DPI figures for the month March 8 to April 7 showed contractors netted the five trial beaches an average of 18 days of the 28 and then checked nets for wildlife less than once per day on average.

The average number of net checks per day for the trial since it began in December has now dropped to 0.98, DPI figures showed.

A Mobula Ray caught in a shark net off Shelly Beach. Photo contributed

A Mobula Ray caught in a shark net off Shelly Beach. Photo contributed

Despite poor visibility in the aftermath of ex-Cyclone Debbie, Mr Clark said a specialist diver onboard Sea Shepherd’s Grey Nurse was able to identify and photograph a dead Mobula Ray caught in the net off Shelly Beach, around 11am.

‘It was really quite decomposed,’ Mr Clark told The Echo, adding he thought it had been ‘predated’, or bitten by another animal.

‘That’s gotta be a shark attractant,’ he said.

‘Given the murky conditions and low visibility, I question whether [the contractors’] way of checking can be done effectively.’

Unless DPI contractors are alerted to trapped marine life outside of scheduled checks, animals either survive long enough to free themselves or are freed at the next inspection, or die struggling.

Contractors have recorded 80 dead animals found in north coast shark nets since the trial began nearly five months ago compared to 105 released alive.

The percentage of dead wildlife has increased each month from 28 per cent in the first DPI by-catch report to 56 per cent in April’s report.

Mr Clark said he and his crew first spotted DPI contractors around 9am at Lighthouse Beach on Sunday. ‘We thought they must have checked the other nets already, so maybe we were wasting our time’.


‘But they kept away from us; they didn’t check the net at that time, they left and headed out to sea. 

‘We followed them three kilometres out to sea. We weren’t sure, [we suspected] they might be towing a shark but we didn’t see that.

‘We were on the port side; they may have had something on the other side. They ended up stopping and waiting; it was a bit of a Mexican stand-off.’

Mr Clark said his crew eventually returned to their net-checks, whereupon the Mobula Ray was found. 

DPI contractors were later seen at Lennox Head.

‘We didn’t see them do any work on nets or drum lines,’ said Mr Clark. ‘We’d guess maybe they didn’t want to work while we were there’.

Mr Clark said there was no verbal interaction between his crew and DPI contractors.

A DPI spokesperson later confirmed contractors checked Ballina shark nets on Sunday morning and again in the afternoon but did not confirm a sighting of activists or any towing activity.

‘The boat remained on the ocean until the afternoon due to tide conditions making a crossing of the bar not possible,’ the spokesperson said.

$22K fines

Fines of $22,000 can apply for anyone caught tampering with shark meshing on the north coast compared to fines of $5,500 in Sydney for similar offences.

Federal environment minister Josh Frydenberg gave the NSW government special permission for the north coast shark meshing trial to begin in December last year as one response to a spate of shark encounters.

The trial was originally meant to last six months, excluding times when nets were removed from the sea, and is now due to end November 17.

As we went to press a senate inquiry into shark-mitigation strategies, chaired by Tasmanian Greens Senator Peter Whish-Wilson, was underway in Byron Bay. Witnesses included scientists, surfing representatives, environment groups and local councils.

3 responses to “Sea Shepherd activists investigate murky shark-net waters”

  1. Members of various marine conservation groups who gave evidence at the Senate inquiry into shark mitigation and deterrent measures yesterday in Byron are angry and disappointed that the DPI haven’t ensured that they will remove the Ballina Shark nets when the trial is finished and for the duration of whale season. Other NSW regions have already removed their shark nets to prevent the possibility of Whale entanglement and death during the coming migration. It was also noted that the Mayor of Ballina appeared keen to have the Shark nets stay in place when the trial ends this month.

    Marine conservation groups including Australian Seabird Rescue, Sunshine Coast Environmental Council, Migaloo 2 Foundation and Ex Greens Senator, Ian Cohen, agreed during the lunch break at the enquiry to write to the Environment Minister Josh Frydenberg, the Chair of the Senate inquiry into shark mitigation and the Ballina Mayor David Wright, insisting that an independent thorough review be conducted at the end of the trial. The letter will ask that Shark nets be removed asap inline with other NSW regions so as not to endanger the lives of the migrating humpback whales.

  2. Mary L Grant says:

    Sea Shepherd men are brave people willing to stick their necks out to help the innocent victims of shark netting.
    Wish more people would support the Wildlife cause in our Oceans.
    Beautiful creatures suffer incredibly painful deaths just to save the “humans” who WILL swim and surf in murky waters and at times of poor light {sunset and early dawn}


    Paul Watson and the Sea Shepherd Men do a great deal to protect the Whales, Marine Turtles, and Marine Animals in Australian Waters

    • Thank you Mary.
      I’d just like to note that our crews are made up of men and women. I have been skippering our small boat on our missions bringing some transparency by monitoring the catch and the behaviour of the authorities. I am very proud and in constant awe at the skills and bravery of our divers who are willing to take camera gear down to document these nets. It is risky work and we have to be very very careful.
      We will not stop.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsors Vast Furniture & Homewares Ballina and Falls Festival Byron Bay.