18.6 C
Byron Shire
December 6, 2021

Potholed and falling apart – a closer look at Byron’s roads

Latest News

Cadwallader, Lyon and Krieg most likely new Far North Coast mayors

With most of the votes cast, and counting over until tomorrow, the New South Wales Electoral Commission stats would suggest that there are three clear winners of the mayoral contests in Ballina, Byron and Lismore Shires.

Other News

A disappointed dog

It’s taken a whole week for my dog to read to page 21 in last week’s Echo. She’s been...

Time to ride the election cycle

Bicycle advocacy is vanishingly rare in our community. Amid all the noise about net zero, my search for bicycle advocate candidates to vote for on Saturday only turned up vague references to ‘reducing our reliance on cars’ and ‘increasing public transport connectivity’. The closest thing to policy was: ‘It’s time to create bike paths all over the Shire.’ 

Realistic, local agendas!

On Saturday 4 December we need to vote for people who focus on issues that can be controlled by...

Coal shame for Queensland and Australian

Local Whitsundays resident Paul Jukes took action this morning against the continued development of the Adani Carmichael Coal Mine.

Responsible dog owner

I read with interest Alison Drover’s article on dog management and the follow up letters last week, and I...

Evidence-based claims on Dunoon Dam

Why is it that all I hear from the pro-dammers is: ‘Save Our Dam’, ‘Build the dam’ or some...

Much like black holes where gravity is so dense that nothing can escape, potholes are so strong they can potentially bankrupt local governments who suffer under the weight of huge visitor numbers and an increase in secondary dwellings. Image oldstersview.wordpress.com
Much like black holes where gravity is so dense that nothing can escape, potholes are so strong they can potentially bankrupt local governments who suffer under the weight of huge visitor numbers and an increase in secondary dwellings. Image oldstersview.wordpress.com

Hans Lovejoy

Do we get value for money when it comes to road repairs?

At the June 22 Council meeting, resident Ivan Saric presented councillors his own assessment of the condition of Coolamon Avenue and the workmanship of roads in the Byron Shire.

He told the gallery he recently moved to the area.

‘My car’s suspension has been trashed,’ he said, and he questioned whether the thickness of the road is adequate. ‘I don’t believe it is a funding issue, it is sloppy work,’ he said.

In the same week Council admitted the Shire’s 502 km  of roads were indeed falling apart.

Staff said in a press release on June 20: ‘Roads that were built many years ago on poor alignments and on poor sub-base were never going to withstand such a harsh climate and intensification of vehicular traffic.’

‘Chronic under-funding of essential road maintenance and renewal by successive councils has well and truly come home to roost.’

What’s needed, says general manager (GM) Ken Gainger, is road reconstruction over ‘many kilometres of sealed roads across the Shire,’ which costs $715,000 per kilometre.

Road repair will accelerate now after councillors and IPART approved a rate rise (special rate variation) in May.

The extra revenue will be dedicated to infrastructure renewal says the GM; it’s a condition that is part of the IPART [Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal] approval.

Expenditure each year will be audited by the NSW auditor-general, says the GM.

Additionally, roads to be upgraded are not being chosen ‘on political or community advocacy imperatives, but rather they were selected as part of a sophisticated strategic asset management approach which analyses and prioritises works based on their condition, usage and expected lifespan.’

And on top of all this, annual roads expenditure has increased, says the GM, ‘from $4m in 2012 to $16m in 2016.’

The Local Roads and  Drainage department are responsible for renewal and repair. Along with that crew, who are employed by Council, are contractors who are awarded the job through a tender process. Local Roads and Drainage falls under Council’s largest department, Infrastructure Services, and is headed by Phil Holloway.

Infrastructure Services also look after water, sewerage and open spaces, such as sports fields and children’s parks. 

Committee oversight

As for oversight, there are three main committees that independently look over the operation of that department (and others): the internal audit advisory committee, the finance advisory committee and the community infrastructure advisory committee.

These committees – and others – are made up of councillors, staff, and members of the public who are generally experts in that field. They meet every three months and all meeting agendas and minutes are available online.

Deputy mayor Basil Cameron is on all three committees. 

He told The Echo that over the years as a councillor, he has seen a positive change in Council’s financial outlook, management and culture, especially after the Finance Advisory Committee was established in late 2010.

Cr Cameron said, ‘The creation of this and other committees enabled councillors to see how resolutions impacted on the budget, and gave a better understanding of how the organisation works.’

He says that the Internal Audit Advisory Committee* was brought in just before the state government made such committees a requirement for all councils.

‘I’m not convinced that tendering gets best results,’ he says, ‘yet I haven’t seen anything that is a better process.’

And it appears there are no specific audits carried out on the Local Roads and Drainage department; only on the tender process that employs contractors.

The Echo asked, ‘Is it adequate that there is no independent oversight of that department?’ He replied, ‘There are four budget reviews annually, in addition to community membership of the transport and infrastructure committee.

‘The community also have a say through the community strategic plan. In 2016, the entire financial health of Council was tested independently by the IPART, with a particular focus on Council’s plans and ability to reduce the roads and drainage works backlog.

‘Through this process, additional funds raised as part of the special rate variation are quarantined for roads and drainage.’

Within committee meetings where tender contractors are discussed, most are marked ‘confidential’. 

The Echo also asked, ‘Do you support Council’s being more transparent with these meetings by publishing them in full – except where costs are associated with the tenders? From memory you have previously supported such an idea but I understand no councillors have pursued this’.

Cr Cameron replied ‘Yes.’

‘We got behind with roads a long time ago,’ Cr Cameron says, and claims tourism is one of the main drivers for the worsening of roads. 

When asked if the proliferation of secondary dwellings have also had an impact, Cr Cameron replied: ‘Yes – although I voted for secondary dwellings DA costs to be reduced around six or seven years ago, I raised the issue at the time that traffic could increase if more infill housing were built.’

Another aspect of Council’s asset management is the requirement by the state government for councils to provide a replacement value cost.

Cameron says, ‘All these assets [roads, land, buildings etc] now have a replacement cost, based on depreciation.

‘But who will buy it? This is not a saleable asset – it’s an artificial view, which actually looks bad because it increases depreciation charges that can result in a deficit.’ 

Yet one of the main improvements for Council management in recent times, says Cameron, is that asset audit evaluations have now been completed and will be available online.

‘We have never had this before,’ he says, ‘and an asset management system is now in place and being improved each year.’

Infrastructure asset audit

Council’s Infrastructure Services manager Phil Holloway and his staff undertook an asset audit not only of the road network, but all of Council’s infrastructure assets prior to the rate hike in May.

His department found that 42 per cent of sealed roads were considered poor, 35 per cent fair and just 23 per cent good. Unsealed roads were not as bad off, with ‘30 per cent poor, 10 per cent good and 60 per cent fair.’

Bridges and footbridges, however, need attention, with only 34 per cent of them considered good.

Similarly kerbs and gutters rated 64 per cent as poor, while 18 per cent were fair and 18 per cent good.

As for causeways, 29 per cent are poor, 21 per cent good and 50 per cent fair.

* For more info on Byron council committees visit www.byron.nsw.gov.au/committees.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. It’s bad enough that I look like a drunk driver, trying to doge the potholes, during the day. I’m really apprehensive about driving anywhere at night, and especially in the rain, for fear of a) having an accident and/or b) damaging my car. Our roads are DANGEROUS.

  2. You only get what you pay for. But not in this case .You get nothing for what you pay for , Byron shire council is run by Morons. We need a Newspaper that prints what people are saying. Not sugar coated Stories. Dont print this ? Budgies will have something to read on Bottom of there cage. Echo! More like Greeno.

  3. Is the Upper Pocket access seen as a road, or a track? Its so narrow and rough, a good chance for vehicle damage or accident anytime …and has been for a long time. There has never been anything done about it, and right now looks less chance for improvement than ever.

    Meanwhile, it was said we are losing 400,000 bucks a year to maintain a poorly placed and done and used “sports facility” on the packed road into Byron.. a huge tax payers loss that would help repair roads.

    And at Wategoes Beach, after parking there to surf for over 50 years I know of, the Council removed about thirty car parks and made it into a walking track for tourists instead..with no community notice at all. The cars now have to pack the narrow resident road above instead, for the high rate paying people that live there..a real slap down to everyone, except walking tourists and car visitors who don’t pay tax.

    Something is very wrong with our “Council”, that we all pay for, except tourists.
    Deaf, blind and dumb Freddy could do better.

  4. I really don’t know how this Council was supposedly NOT considered a serious candidate for amalgamation – all Councils seem to be ‘broke’ – but many that have amalgamated never had the shocking road conditions that we have here. So the Council is supposed to be solvent? Then why not fix the roads!

  5. This is one of the most boring write ups I’ve seen on a such an important issue. Who cares about which council department or committee does what or which councillor says what? Shouldn’t the Echo simply have asked in short: WHEN WILL OUR ROADS BE FIXED?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Growing number of dogs

Thanks to Alison Drover for her informative article in last week’s Echo regarding the growing number of dogs in the Shire to be managed...

Responsible dog owner

I read with interest Alison Drover’s article on dog management and the follow up letters last week, and I couldn’t agree more. I am indifferent...

Dogs need control

I agree with Alison Drover’s recent article and her final line ‘wildlife needs more love, and our dog owners need a tighter lead’. But the...

COVID update December 3: One new case and advice for international travellers

One new case of COVID-19 was reported for Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWLHD) in the 24 hours to 8pm 2 December. Northern NSW Local...