16 C
Byron Shire
May 23, 2022

Flood insurance rejected? It’s not too late for a challenge

Latest News

Australian politics transformed

Following an election like no other, Australia looks set to change course on climate and corruption, with the Coalition's Scott Morrison being prised from office and Anthony Albanese about to form a new Labor government with the support of Greens and teal independents.

Other News

Sue Higginson MLC: a woman on a mission

Local mother, grandmother, partner, activist, farmer, and lawyer, Sue Higginson, can now add NSW MLC Senator to her list of hyphenates.

All smiles at Ballina pre-poll

People were queued out the door at the pre-poll booth in Ballina Indoor Sports Centre yesterday, with brightly dressed volunteers and AEC officials offering assistance to voters.

Richmond candidates strut their stuff

With the federal election looming Saturday, candidates put themselves before the public at the Echo/BayFM ‘Meet the Candidates’ on Monday night in Byron. All candidates were present, except ‘ghost’ One Nation candidate, Tracey Bell-Henselin. 

Hydrogen hoax

This is very serious. Last year expert scientists published a warning via The Society of Chemical Industry: ‘blue hydrogen’,...


Morrison is the loose unit with the economy! Here’s some excerpts from a long, long list of corruption by...

‘Dining in the Dark’ at Forest, Byron

To celebrate the North Coast Festival of Flavour, Forest restaurant is turning off the lights so you can turn...

The water rose well over 1.5m to float this enormous log to the top of Sanctum’s drive.

Aslan Shand

Did your insurance claim from Cyclone Debbie get rejected? If it did then you are in the same boat as the local business Sanctum in Billinudgel, and you too might still be able to challenge the insurance rejection.

Following Cyclone Debbie ‘Many small business owners, such as myself, were left with extensive damage to our businesses,’ said Sanctum founder Greg Milham.

Like many local businesses and residents his insurance claims were quickly rejected by his insurer Vero.

‘The first thing the insurer says is “it’s flood damage – you’re not covered”,’ continued Greg.

‘The insurance company were relying upon a report from a hydrologist to suggest that my factories were flooded. We knew the report was incorrect owing to the topography of the area, direction of the water flow and the fact the water left in our factories was clear.’

Rejected three times

Nonetheless the claim was rejected three times by the insurer, who produced multiple hydrology reports to back themselves up. By their third hydrology report stating that the damage was caused by flood it became clear that ‘their third report disagreed with their first report’.

With the assistance of Lachlan Main from Main Lawyers and the Office of NSW Small Business Commissioner (OSBC) Greg was able to challenge the insurer’s claims. Greg joined a bulk submission to the Financial Ombudsman’s Service (FOS) from small-business owners from the region that has expedited the process of determining flood claims.

Decision binding

The decision of the FOS is binding on the insurer who is then required to pay the insurance claim if it is found to be valid.

‘In approximately five months, the FOS received our multiple submissions, three hydrological reports from the insurer (attempting to justify mistaken conclusions in the earlier reports) and personally attended our premises for a site inspection,’ said Greg.

‘Their expeditiousness, professionalism and commonsense approach to our situation was a breath of fresh air particularly when insurance companies are involved.’

The FOS determined that Sanctum’s main factory was damaged by stormwater run-off and not floodwaters; however, there were other areas of the damage that were not covered under the insurance claim.

‘Many of the (hydrology) reports I have seen that have been used to reject claims are open to challenge,’ said Sanctum’s lawyer, Lachlan Main.

‘Insurance companies are not always right and don’t accept their decision if you have doubts.

‘The event at the end of March 2017 was very different from a typical flood event. The levels of rainfall were extreme. If your insurance claim has been rejected, consider making an application to FOS. If you are unsure of whether you have a reasonable case, seek legal advice. Many law firms, such as mine, will provide an initial consultation free.’

The FOS can assist residents and businesses in relation to insurance-related complaints on 1800 367 287.

‘There are a range of insurance-related issues that have been raised with the OSBC following Cyclone Debbie including concerns about the rejection of claims, slow response and the quality and consistency of expert reports,’ said a Department of Industry spokesperson.

Greg highlighted that the majority of the hydrology reports produced by WRM in Lismore, Billinudgel and Murwillumbah were all very similar.

‘Anyone who has been beaten over the head by the WRM should seek advice. If it hadn’t been for Lachlan Main and Robyn Hobbs (NSW Small Business Commissioner) I would have given up,’ finished Greg.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Kevin Hogan returns for Page

Though the coalition government he represents is now in opposition, National Party candidate for Page, Kevin Hogan, has been returned to his seat and yesterday he released a statement to all media.

A gold star campaign and a result full of hope

It’s not surprising that Mandy Nolan got so many primary votes at Saturday’s election for the seat of Richmond – her campaign has been relentless and her volunteers all stellar.

Tibetan anniversary

May 23  marks 71 years since the Chinese Communist Party and the People's Liberation Army invaded and commenced  the ‘Liberation of Tibet’. In the first...

Richmond candidates 2022: The Greens, Mandy Nolan

Mandy Nolan needs little introduction to most readers of The Echo, where she has a weekly column. She is a comedian and journalist running as a candidate for The Greens in the federal seat of Richmond.