16.5 C
Byron Shire
May 25, 2022

Courageously avoiding responsibility

Latest News

Recognising 50 years of police service

When John 'Jack' Keough moved to Byron Bay police station in 1982 there was still a station sheep that kept the grass down and goats still roamed Cape Byron. Sargent Keough began his career in policing in 1972 when he walked into the Redfern Academy to join the police force. 

Other News

Australian politics transformed

Following an election like no other, Australia looks set to change course on climate and corruption, with the Coalition's Scott Morrison being prised from office and Anthony Albanese about to form a new Labor government with the support of Greens and teal independents.

Corporate beach

Tallow Beach is a great place to walk your dog and it has got a lot busier over the...

Will Morrison’s gas-led recovery delete the IPCC’s belief we need climate action now?

Most Australians know the news, or have had firsthand experiences themselves, of two years of floods, fires, coastal erosion, and storms, both here and overseas. In fact Australia has warmed on average by 1.44 ± 0.24 °C since national records began in 1910.

Get me a DA

In response to the recent flood meeting held at the Ocean Shores Country Club on Tuesday 10 May, a...

Richmond candidates 2022: Informed Medical Options Party candidate Monica Shepherd

Monica Shepherd is an organic naturopath based in Ocean Shores. She is running as a candidate for the Informed Medical Options Party in the federal seat of Richmond.

COVID-19 update for the NNSWLHD – May 23

The Northern NSW Local Health District reports that to 4pm yesterday, Sunday May 22, there were 40 COVID-19 positive patients in hospital in Northern NSW, with one of these in ICU.

Unlike Tony Barber or Larry Emdur, mayor Simon Richardson is not a TV game show host. Yet it’s hard to tell the difference.

Hans Lovejoy

Byron Shire Council have outsourced themselves because apparently we don’t trust them!

With the admission by council that they have a public trust deficit in their decision-making, councillors voted last week to pay consultants to help improve their image.

It’s the obvious gonzo political response, given no-one in the council appears to be able to hold a mirror to themselves and accept that they made the mess in the first place.

A citizens jury will be established, which will be a panel of randomly selected 28 anonymous locals who will decide on how to spend the rate-rise money on infrastructure projects. What could possibly go wrong?

Rather than just doing the job they are paid to do, councillors will outsource their powers to unknowns who won’t be held accountable.

Consultants New Democracy claim they have had success in regaining public trust with their model, something the mayor was keen to impress on the chamber at last Thursday’s meeting. 

‘…We’ve heard loudly and clearly that our community does not trust us and that you think the feedback you’ve given in the past has been ignored or simply not acted on.’ Council press release

It’s like a real court jury, where random citizens are selected to decide major court cases. Yet these unknown locals will meet after 5.30pm and on weekends to come up with council expenditure plans.

But time is limited: they will have only a few weeks to come up to speed on major budgetary implications and become adept in the dark arts of manipulation, hypnotism and Jedi mind skills that will no doubt be inflicted upon them by council staff. Could it work? Perhaps; anything is worth a go at this point.

It’s like giving a toddler a surgeons knife, or asking a child of four where the broom-broom cars should go. 

So, as someone who has sat in council meetings and reported on local government for more than eight years, here’s my take on why there is a lack of trust and how councillors and staff can address it.

Equity missing

Equity is a cornerstone of government – it helps society to function because it instills a belief that the law applies evenly to every individual.

Of course it never has and this is all an illusion. But to maintain that illusion, attempts must be made to present to the public the idea of equity.

Equity has been sidelined for expediency in many cases by both councillors and staff in the last year, which has led to an erosion in public trust.

No amount of money spent on consultants or giving up their powers to a random mob of bored retirees will change that.

It’s been more than a year in office now, and the councillors in charge appear to be making the same mistakes their predecessors made; they are ignoring equity and instead blaming their problems on what they say are a small minority of vocal critics.

Or as the mayor keeps saying, there is a lot of ‘myth making’ about. Fake News! Sad.

Importantly, councillors have not focused on completing forward planning strategies, which help to underpin their legal arsenal in which they can defend against inappropriate development. The residential strategy is yet to be completed, for example.

Instead, mayor Simon Richardson and his supporters have ‘picked winners’ for developments, such as the Brunswick Eco Village and The Farm in Ewingsdale.

Further, the longstanding and clearly articulated opposition by informed community members to the activities of the government-run NSW North Coast Holiday Parks Trust in Brunswick Heads is another example of how public trust has been eroded.

The Greens majority have acted as personal lobbyists to this dubious corporation instead of backing the community.

It’s well known there is a split within the Greens; the previous ‘dark uncompromising’ Greens were ignored/ostracised entirely when the newer ‘urine-light-yellow Green’ mob took over.

It’s predictable the younger generation would want to make their mark with governance, but to cut off historical knowledge is not just idiotic, but is clearly dividing the community.

It’s not easy being light Green

There are no policies from the Greens available on the many issues that face the community, despite repeated requests. And it appears that the Greens councillors are not bound by any party policy that requires a steering committee around elected officials. Such a policy exists at the state level.

Overall, the mayor appears chaotic and unfocused – he seems easily led by simplistic and ill-defined catchphrases like ‘affordable housing’, ‘best practice’ and ‘sustainability’.

He is also often at odds with his state government counterpart, Tamara Smith, MP.

GM exits building

Here are just a few observations of previous general manager Ken Gainger, who recently retired for health reasons.

Early in his term he moved quickly to restructure what was a dreadful over-stacking of poor-performing top-level managers.

He also helped the council get back into the black after threats from the state government over the fit- for-the-future requirements.

Yet personal interference with major projects and a lack of discipline from senior staff to manage rogue employees led largely to a chaotic and untrustworthy environment.

The sale of the Ocean Shores Roundhouse site early on was a debacle, just for starters,

Conflating a Byron Bay bus terminal proposal with the masterplan (intentionally or not), without public consultation, was a major public-relations mistake. No neighbours were consulted on this proposal. Without a development application (DA), there are no public submissions and procedural fairness is lost.

Butler Street

The decision by the general manager to pursue Butler Street residents in the courts, after those residents lost defending their street from becoming a bypass, looked petty and vexatious. Councillors also seemed to not understand that it was happening.

The poorly managed and ultimately ineffective bypass that is the swan song of former Nationals MP Don Page would make a great episode of ABC TV’s Utopia.

Moving on, those who use the Byron Sports Rec ground complained that staff ignored their input about how to manage the space, and subsequently the council had to withdraw the last masterplan and present another.

Efforts to alleviate market stallholder concern on Butler Street Reserve have been largely unsuccessful and controversial because it all appears to be on the fly.   

While the general manager apologised for cutting down trees in Railway Park last November, there were no consequences. Mere mortals would cop a fine, but not here.

Only an inefficient bureaucracy would ask the staff member who chopped down trees without warning to write a report about it. Thankfully in this case, councillors rejected that report.

And let’s all remind ourselves: the actions of staff and councillors are no different from ‘normally’ functioning government institutions. This is just a region that takes a very keen interest in governance. It’s an almost unbearable amount of scrutiny to be under, but we, the unwashed masses, are the better for it.

In summary: if staff were kept in line by a stricter GM, and the GM didn’t interfere with politics, the council would be held in higher regard by the community.

And if the mayor and councillors focused more on where the wheels are coming off, the community would be better served.

There, heaps of money in consultant fees was just avoided. You’re welcome.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. OMG! Have we really come to this? How un-Byron can you get ! This is the ultimate confirmation that YOU HAVE LOST YOUR MORAL COMPASS !!!

    You want to spend my rate dollars on IMAGE !!??

    Just do the right thing and the image will fix itself … DOH !!!

    • If you don’t mind another point of view Rossco,
      I am sorry to inform you that, after many decades of observation, many will see this as exactly
      ‘ as Byron as you can get’…… and as merely a pseudo- Gold Coast I’m sure they have never had a “moral” compass, and image IS everything. The results ,in the real world, are too embarrassing to mention.
      Cheers , G”)

  2. How laughable is this ? They want to educate the public to like Byron Concillors instead of educating the councilors to do their job properly or even better to sack the lot.

  3. Pathetic………………………….absolutely disgusted.

    If those we elect would start listening to us who elect them, take time to go view what we are highlighting, instead of telling us to stop sniping when we protest, then we would truly live in a more democratic shire.

    And stop this Green mantra. It only exists for the feel good moments.

  4. Overall. I’m disappointed by this mob of councillors. I know they had to get up to speed but what ‘good’ have they done?
    In Bruns, they undid 20 years of fighting for our foreshores in one foul five minute swoop.
    It was traitorous and mean. Simon must have wanted kudos badly to do that. (I’ll be waiting with baited breath to see what fancy ‘appointment’ he will accept in the future.
    A couple of our Greens are trying to do the right thing but Simon seems to wave a magic wand and the eyes glaze over.
    We need a new lot with some gumption to serve the COMMUNITY not the ‘developers’!

  5. it’s past time for smiling simon to fall on his sword before it’s plunged in the backside.
    grow some balls mate and start a sewage moratorium.
    that will turn your image around.
    and to clean up council, hire fast bucks for new GM.

  6. Hans, You are one of the very few public voices speaking truth, conscience and reality. I only wish your platform reached out into the community more broadly and that your words were given more consideration from the public and council alike. Thank you!

  7. Well Hans,
    You might be quite disappointed with our Counsil.
    I’m always attentive to what you say, and sometimes I ponder if you realise just how important is your voice in the Shire. How people can miss use and miss interpret some of your concerns.
    I just hope that people realise how much worse off our Shire was with the majority of Liberal party members here.
    How we lost serious funds invested in shares in the past, etc…
    Let’s just make sure that whatever mistakes our current Council might be making, we have a great deal more of a public relationship with this political party than any other in the past 20 that I live here. I find that relationship a very strong prof of efficiency. Being able to hold public participation in hard times, is also an opportunity to engage the community in decision making, not a lack of professionalism in my humble opinion.
    I appreciate your comment and opinion regards to Equity, and I ponder if even you would be able to deal with the oldest “jumping-ants-nest” within the Byron Shire Counsil I don’t think that Counsil is ignoring the issue, but hitting a brick wall with staff members. They’re there making impossible mistakes for far too long, and not being held accountable for any of it.
    Kind regards


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

The postal vote that never arrived

At 91, there are many things that you can no longer do, but one of the things you still can do is have your voice heard in an election – but not for at least one Byron Shire resident.

Vale big Jez, Mullum troubadour

The Mullumbimby community lost one of the founding fathers of its counter culture last Thursday, when Graham Chambers, better known as Jerry De Munga, passed away at his home with the love and care of wife Chrissy, family and close friends.

Kashmir Miller: ‘the Green wave will expand’

Taking her first but definitely not her last steps into federal politics, the election campaign for Greens candidate for Page, Kashmir Miller, was exciting and tricky.

Large bioenergy facility gets nod

Byron Council’s plan to build a facility that converts waste into electricity at the Byron Bay Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) has been given the green light by the Northern Regional Planning Panel