18.9 C
Byron Shire
May 19, 2021

War of words over West Byron developments

Latest News

Police appeal for help to find missing teenagers

Police are appealing for public assistance to help locate the boy and a girl who were last seen in Alstonville on Monday.

Other News

Free mental health workshop for Byron businesses

Business owners in Byron Shire are invited to attend a free 'Healthy Mindset' workshop aimed at providing them with resources and tools to improve mental health and wellbeing, as well as the opportunity to connect with other business owners.

Why the fuss?

Neil Buhrich, Suffolk Park Why do those responsible for containing the coronavirus become so concerned when they identify just one...

Editorial: The vulnerable at risk

Most of us would hope that the taxes we pay go towards key areas such as health, education and to supporting the most vulnerable in our community.

Cartoon of the week – 19 May, 2021

We love to receive letters, but not every letter will be published; the publication of letters is at the discretion of the online and print letters editors.

Police appeal for help to find missing teenagers

Police are appealing for public assistance to help locate the boy and a girl who were last seen in Alstonville on Monday.

Water and the dam

Dr Roslyn Irwin, Caniaba An organisation called ‘Our Future NR’ is distributing and promoting information intended to put the Dunoon...

Get in to have your say – again – on the West Byron proposal. Even the traffic consultants admit there are no plans to alleviate the existing traffic problems.

Ballina MP Tamara Smith and Nationals Parliamentary Secretary for Northern NSW Ben Franklin have become embroiled in a ‘who said what’ stoush over proposed development at West Byron.

Ms Smith took a swipe at Mr Franklin in parliament as she questioned NSW Planning Minister Anthony Roberts whether the government would act on concerns raised by the community about the social, environmental and economic impacts of the mega development application for West Byron.

‘Having previously raised with the Minister our community’s concern about the detrimental impacts of the West Byron proposal on the Belongil estuary and Cape Byron Marine Park, to the threatened koala and Wallum froglet species on the site and the known horrendous traffic impact of the development on residents and tourists; I asked the Minister on the floor of Parliament today to act on those concerns,’ Ms Smith said.

‘I was able to secure a commitment from the Planning Minister to monitor the developments but the message I got loud and clear is that we as a community need to make sure we express our concerns formally if we stand any chance of reining in this mega development.

‘While I was asking this question in the Legislative Assembly, the National-Liberal coalition in the Upper House voted down a Greens’ motion against the West Byron mega development.

‘One of those who voted down the motion was the National’s Northern NSW spokesperson who on 2 March was quoted in the media saying he had ‘serious and genuine concerns about the development – particularly with regard to its size and scale.

‘I was informed that the Parliamentary Secretary for Northern NSW has never raised any concerns about the West Byron development with the Planning Minister. As they say: actions speak louder than words.’

Ben Franklin responds

Mr Franklin expressed his disappointment in the Ballina MP regarding her press release on West Byron.

Ms Smith referred to a motion in the Upper House opposing the West Byron development and suggested that Mr Franklin was ‘one of those who voted down the motion.’

‘This suggestion is untrue. I did not vote against the motion. The Government Whip objected to it being passed. The rules of the Legislative Council state that when any single member objects to a motion it stays on the notice paper to be debated at a later date. I look forward to contributing to that debate in the future,’ Mr Franklin said.

Ms Smith also said in her media release that she ‘was informed that the Parliamentary Secretary for Northern NSW has never raised any concerns about the West Byron development with the Planning Minister’.

However in his response to Ms Smith’s question Minister Roberts stated that ‘I have been advised by the Parliamentary Secretary for the North Coast, Ben Franklin, that he has heard from many locals who have also expressed many reservations’.

‘Ms Smith may have asked a question, but it’s a shame she didn’t listen to the answer before sending out her press release,’ Mr Franklin said.

‘I do however agree with her on one thing. It is critical that the community formally make a submission before 29 March to ensure that their views are known on the West Byron development.

‘My position on West Byron is clear. I believe existing infrastructure is inadequate for such a development. If it is approved it is critical that the JRPP put in place conditions that address the nature of the development and the infrastructure necessary to deal with it.’

Submissions on the development can be made to [email protected]

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. I am an ex resident of Byron, who returned interstate to attend family matters. Your little squabbles only break the hearts of people like me, who have little monetary currency, and cannot return to a place we loved dearly.

    Surely. Someone has the heart and knowing, to step forward. Offering a resolution where everyone wins. No humbug.

    • Kathleen, most of us I am sure sympathise, but if you came back now you might soon find it isn’t the same place you loved dearly. If developments like this one keep occurring it will be even less so. There are lots of locals selling up and moving to places like Ballina but their residences are increasingly bought up at increasingly inflated prices for the financial return from holiday letting.

      Believe me it isn’t a little squabble; it’s a losing battle to keep some degree of liveability for permanent residents.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Keith Duncan, Pimlico Thank God this corruption-riddled Berejiklian/Barilaro government does not have a majority in the NSW upper house. Environmentalists in NSW have just breathed...

Man jailed over South Golden Beach dog shooting

A local builder who shot his neighbour’s dog with a bow and arrow in South Golden Beach has been jailed after unsuccessfully appealing his conviction in the District Court.

Greens MP calls for greater workplace safety in government

Mia Armitage Greens Member for Ballina Tamara Smith has joined calls for improved workplace safety in government after accusations against a Byron Shire resident of...

Angsts, hopes and visions

Jo Faith, Newtown I love The Echo and all of the folk that passionately contribute their angsts, hopes and visions. How do The (struggling) Echo...