Menu

Thus Spake Mungo: PM’s absence makes voters grow fonder

Correlation is not causation. The scientific method instructs us that events which may often occur simultaneously or in close succession are not necessarily connected, let alone actually resulting in one another.

So it is probably no more than coincidence that Newspoll usually seems to improve for the government when parliament is not sitting, and to get better still when Malcolm Turnbull is out of the country.

After all, we are constantly assured that our current Prime Minister is the last, best hope for the coalition so it would seem logical to display him as frequently as possible in the most media-friendly circumstances, and nothing attracts the commentariat like question time in the House of Representatives.

And yet a disillusioned and dysfunctional backbench is increasingly coming to the conclusion that Turnbull is in fact part of the problem; that the voters have simply stopped listening to him. They fear that the punters feel positive relief when their leader shuts up, when the confected outrage, the bullshit and bluster, the schoolboy taunts about Bill Shorten cease for a couple of weeks while they take stock.

Morrison can make a virtue out of his latest backflip, and claim that the universal Medicare levy rise to pay for the NDIS is really not needed after all and can instead be tossed into the basket of goodies he is preparing for the budget.

And when they do, the news is not too horrible: wages are still down in the cesspool, but there are signs that things might finally improve, and that no thanks to the politicians, the increase in commodity profits and hence company taxes means that there will be tax relief for some real people as opposed to the corporate geniuses who are bringing us the Royal Commission.

Thus Scott Morrison can make a virtue out of his latest backflip, and claim that the universal Medicare levy rise to pay for the NDIS is really not needed after all and can instead be tossed into the basket of goodies he is preparing for the budget.

In some ways this looks more like desperation than serious policy; the Medicare levy needs to be raised as a more or less politically painless measure, not just to secure the NDIS but to help fund the ballooning cost of our health system overall. Of course nominating a tax rise for a designated purpose is always a con; all tax goes into consolidated revenue for Morrison and his apparatchiks to dole out wherever and whenever they feel inclined.

However that has not stopped Morrison, Turnbull and many of their lesser acolytes saying that the new tax was absolutely necessary to save the NDIS from the penury from which Julia Gillard’s government had consigned it and that Shorten was leaving the blind, the crippled, the halt and the lame to die in misery if he did not endorse it.

We now know that this was not true, that the funding was always a matter of priorities, and given that the levy had no hope of passing the senate in its original form, it was sensible politics to dump it. There are enough distractions already, as the daily horror stories from the Royal Commission continue to unfold, and will likely do so right up to the election.

And on this front Turnbull is doing the best he can, but frankly it isn’t all that much. His fall-back position seems to be that he initially resisted the inquiry because he wanted to put other reforms in place first; thus the forgettable tweaking of ASIC, APRA, and the lectures to the banking executives, all proving in the end to have been completely ineffectual.

But the point is that if Turnbull was determined to push ahead with them, there was nothing to stop him from starting up the Royal Commission at the same time. Only last week Morrison introduced serious legislation while the Commission was sitting: there was no suggestion that he should have to wait until it produced its findings. And during the previous Royal Commission into the unions, the government was celebrating the new laws it was introducing with no restraint at all.

Turnbull has at last admitted that delaying it, mainly because it was the idea of the Greens, then adopted by Labor, was a mistake, but it seems that he is still unsure what to do next. For starters, who is to pay – and for what?

It is now being argued by the remaining supporters of the wayward banks that inflicting drastic penalties on them would be a form of overkill: either they would simply pass on the costs to their hapless customers or they would have to reduce their dividends to their innocent shareholders. But hang on, are the shareholders really so innocent?

Presumably they knew the banks were bastards – everyone else did – when they invested their hard-earned savings. But they hoped for rewards, and for a long time they got them. But now, as it has emerged that the banks were involved in fraud, theft, perjury and heaven knows what other shenanigans, it appears that at least some of those welcome dividends were the proceeds of crime – the shareholders were the receivers of stolen goods.

No one is seriously suggesting that shareholders should give them back, but perhaps they could be persuaded to accept a small haircut in the immediate aftermath.

Similarly, the apologists want to separate the Commission from Morrison’s cherished corporate tax cuts: we should not, they tell us sternly, think of imposing some kind of morality tax. Well actually almost all our laws are based on morality – or at least we thought they were; their aim is to protect the public from harm in various forms. That is why we put ordinary criminals (but seldom corporate ones) in jail.

So the withdrawal of huge tax bonanza could be seen as a hefty fine for misconduct, which seems entirely legitimate. And this dilemma will remain the heart of the budget: can Turnbull afford to give the impression that he is rewarding the banks? Next week’s budget will tell the story – and also the next Newspoll.

And the debate that follows will show us whether the glimmers of hope that appeared while Turnbull was overseas will translate into a genuine recovery. And if the past is any guide, the mob will not be impressed if Turnbull reverts to form and uses parliament as a platform for his Kill Bill strategy.

If he does, and the following Newspolls mark him down, then the backbenchers may decide that he is unable to change by himself, so perhaps they will reluctantly have to act in sheer self-preservation.

Correlation is not causation, but there are definitely times when absence makes the heart grow fonder. And, it can appear, make Newspoll kinder.


7 responses to “Thus Spake Mungo: PM’s absence makes voters grow fonder”

  1. Len Heggarty says:

    Mungo,
    If correlation is correlation and it is the relationship between two or more things and causation is causation and is anything that causes an effect then in the true meaning of causation there is a relationship between two or more things and it could be hypothesised that they are the same thing in a given situation with the right vocabulary and scientific terms used.

  2. Tuatha says:

    One of the major errors of politics & public perceptions thereto is post hoc ergo propter hoc.
    Humans seek patterns, good or bad, from random events.

  3. Mulch says:

    Maybe you could also give a critical analysis of why Shorten is a complete waste of space …

  4. robot says:

    I stopped fusing Labor when it became apparent they were only segmenting all the divisions with whatever promise was necessary. They still play this numbers game. Howard went to his first bout with an unwinnable GST. Abbott floated the boats scenario and won flippers down. Shorten is still on the numbers racket, you can always bet on health and education, though noone is willing to admit the problem is anything but funds. Medicine has new treatments and equipment on line every new day, more and more is treatable, though the AMA would never admit our inevitable susceptibility anyway , God bless. Turnbull is also banking on an outsider, corporate tax cuts. Because somewhere we look for real answers. As for the Greens, they don’t look for ultimate power, as yet; just the control of it. They’re your real rackateers.

  5. robot says:

    And the banks stop, everything goes down. And no amount of mutualisation will adjust the carbareutter right. Communism was always adjusting the screws. Like a good old Holden that was alright then. Now it’s rocket science, for good or for bad. Were we ever a nation to point the bone, so much it hurts?

  6. robot says:

    We’re all aristocracy to a tuk tuk driver who earns enoug for a nightly meal and that above a compound liver who has to sell his body. And the factory worker who’s good for a few years is middle class, earning two dollars. Of course the wires are crossed. So are the expectations. It’s the hypocrisy gets to me, these synods in Kyoto or Geneva, Tokyo, Rio. Endless witless.

  7. robot says:

    But a good point about correlation and causation … like reading between the lines, just a hunch.

Leave a Reply to Mulch Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Become a supporter of The Echo

A note from the editorial team

Some of The Echo’s editorial team: journalists Paul Bibby and Aslan Shand, editor Hans Lovejoy, photographer Jeff Dawson and Mandy Nolan

The Echo has never underestimated the intelligence and passion of its readers. In a world of corporate banality and predictability, The Echo has worked hard for more than 30 years to help keep Byron and the north coast unique with quality local journalism and creative ideas. We think this area needs more voices, reasoned analysis and ideas than just those provided by News Corp, lifestyle mags, Facebook groups and corporate newsletters.

The Echo is one hundred per cent locally owned and one hundred per cent independent. As you have probably gathered from what is happening in the media industry, it is not cheap to produce a weekly newspaper and a daily online news service of any quality.

We have always relied entirely on advertising to fund our operations, but often loyal readers who value our local, independent journalism have asked how they could help ensure our survival.

Any support you can provide to The Echo will make an enormous difference. You can make a one-off contribution or a monthly one. With your help, we can continue to support a better informed local community and a healthier democracy for another 30 years.”

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsor Vast Ballina and Falls Festival