18.8 C
Byron Shire
April 21, 2024

Planning panel okayed medical centre without community input

Latest News

Cockroach climate

The cockroaches in the Byron Council offices are experiencing bright daylight at night. They are trying to determine whether...

Other News

Mayor defends promoting sale of Wallum lots

Is the role of mayor Michael Lyon as a negotiator with Wallum developers, Clarence Property, compromised? With talks with...

School holidays at the market

Victoria Cosford School holidays shouldn’t only be holidays for children. Parents too are entitled to a break in routine, the...

Musicians and MLC support the save Wallum fight

As the drama unfolded between police and protesters at the Wallum Development in Brunswick Heads yesterday, people were drawn to the site by the red alerts sent out by the Save Wallum organisers.

Funds sought to complete clubhouse

Byron Bay Football Club may finally get the funds to complete its new clubhouse, with Byron councillors to consider loaning the club $200,000 at this week’s meeting.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: Shopping Centres Scare Me

I feel trapped. There isn’t a single time I attend where I don’t check my proximity to the exits, or imagine what I’d do if there was a fire, or worse, a shooter. The sense of being enclosed is unnatural, I can’t tell what time of day it is, I lose my sense of direction. It’s designed to be disorienting. It feels otherworldly. And never in a good way. They are designed to make you stay longer. They are by design, disorienting.

Architect’s plan of the medical centre approved by the Joint Regional Planning Panel. Image supplied

Hans Lovejoy

It’s emerged that a recent decision to approve an $8m private hospital DA on Ewingsdale Road and McGettigans Lane by the JRPP was made without any community representation.

The Joint Regional Planning Panel (JRPP) comprises nine panels that determine large-scale developments across NSW and approve almost 100 per cent of applications before them.

The Northern JRPP, headed by former National Party MP Garry West, will soon be deciding upon the contentious West Byron suburban/commercial greenfield development.

The debacle throws into light the lack of any community input with large developments across NSW.

While elected councils determine all development applications below $20m, unelected JRPPs decide on DAs estimated over $20m as well as specialist DAs under $20m, such as medical centres.

The private hospital proposal by Melbourne-based developers comprises medical and specialist consulting rooms, a day theatre, pharmacy, 12 overnight-stay units, cafe and basement and ground-level parking.

Last week JRPP chair Garry West dismissed questions by The Echo regarding how increased traffic from the hospital will be managed.

One of the local representatives on the JRPP, mayor Simon Richardson, does not support the decision and told The Echo he resigned from the panel owing to the ‘inherent flaw’ of not being able to speak publicly to the JRPP on contentious developments while also being a panel member.

Council staff say other community members are Cr Basil Cameron and David Milledge, but they were not present.

Mayor Simon Richardson describes the JRPP process as ‘non-democratic and it was established to be so.’

Failure to appoint

Despite the mayor’s resignation from the panel, Council staff and the JRPP failed to ask community panel replacement David Brown to attend last week’s meeting.

Brown, an urban planner, told The Echo, ‘I was appointed to the JRPP at the last (August 22) Council meeting. I was not invited to the McGettigans Lane [and Ewingsdale Road] meeting.’

So who observed last week’s JRPP meeting? Ewingsdale Progress and Public Hall Association vice-president Lindsay Wootten told The Echo that he attended, along with longtime resident and immediate neighbour George Flick.

The Echo also confirmed the manager of the Bright Side Medical Centre in Bayshore Drive also attended, but they declined to comment.

Wootten told The Echo that ‘The meeting was not well publicised,’ that the ‘process was unfair,’ and that he believes the local medical fraternity do not think this facility is needed.

Yet Wootten said his association is ‘not against development of this lot.’

‘However, the view of the association is that this development is too high and too large overall for the size of the lot. The lot is in a very prominent position and with three storeys it is likely to dominate the view from surrounding areas.

There should also be buffer zones between the development and surrounding lots.

‘In addition, the development will exacerbate the already very poor traffic situation at the intersections of McGettigans Lane/Quarry Lane and Ewingsdale Road and increase the danger to road users. There are frequent accidents in and around the intersections.’

Cr Paul Spooner (Labor) told The Echo that the state government needs to undertake a review of the operation and conduct of the Northern JRPP. ‘The recent approval of the Ewingsdale Road Private Hospital demonstrates the lack of planning controls that local councils like Byron Shire now have in NSW.’

He said, ‘The Ewingsdale Road Private Hospital approval demonstrates if a developer keeps knocking on the door of the state government they can eventually expect to get an approval. This particular DA has been to the JRPP three times over the last 12 months.

‘Each time, it was recommended by Council staff for refusal primarily owing to concerns about traffic management at the intersection of Ewingsdale Road and McGettigans Lane.

‘Why is the state government allowing a panel to progress without local representation?’

Questions to MPs

The Echo asked NSW Labor MLC Walt Secord, ‘If elected at the next election, will your party commit to abolishing the JRPP and returning large decisions like this to democratically elected councils? If not, why?’

The Echo also asked, ‘Given this recent decision lacked even basic community input and will exacerbate traffic, how can Byron Shire residents have confidence in this unelected planning panel?’

Secord replied that he broadly supports the JRPPs but said, ‘There is growing concern that the Berejiklian government has stacked out the Joint Regional Planning Panels (JRPPs) with Liberal and National party-affiliated individuals across the entire state.’

Local NSW Nationals MLC Ben Franklin has previously told The Echo he supports JRPPs.

What are the panel paid?

According to the NSW Public Service Commission – NSW Government Boards and Committees Remuneration (August 2017), the yearly pay-packet for the chair of the Northern Joint Regional Planning Panel is $51,315.00. And the remuneration amount for the chair, per day (if applicable) is $1,866. A member of the panel receives $39,463, according to the Public Service Commission.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. JRPP panels consist of five people: three, including the chair, are appointed by the state government, and two are appointed by the local council involved.

    It is logical that each council have at least two nominees ready to attend JRPP’s as well as at least four alternates in the event, as frequently it happens, their nominees either have a conflict of interest or are unavailable on the day.

    With this particular JRPP Byron Councillors had rejected this application so Council had an obligation to have its two members up to speed on the issues, able to attend.

    It is clearly a disgrace that neither the staff of Byron Shire Council, nor its elected representatives, had ensured that at least two Council appointees or their alternates were able to attend the JRPP meetings in relation to this issue where the council had an opinion as did the local Ewingsdale community.

    Despite Mayor Simon Richardson describing the JRPP process as ‘non-democratic and it was established to be so’, if all members of the JRPP attend it means that the state government has only a majority of one on the Panel.

    So the question the Echo should also have asked is whose fault was it: the Council staff or our elected members?

    And given that the JRPP has a full-time Sydney-based Secretariat, surely the Secretariat or its regulations have a responsibility to request that the relevant Shire has its two appointed nominees in attendance, or else the meeting is postponed.

  2. This is corruption… no doubt! Both State and Federal Liberal “governments” trample over the will of the community to the benefit of their mates. Follow the money… someone is getting a fatter hip pocket!
    This kind of development needs to contribute substantially to the infrastructure costs as you can bet their profits will not be returned to the community.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

A grim commemoration

US President Jo Biden, responding to a question, made the comment that the US is considering the dropping of the prosecution of Julian Assange. How...

Infrastructure for east end of Mullum

Mullumbimby was founded 135 years ago. In the 1960s sewerage was introduced, as was I suppose drainage infrastructure. Are we living in the 1920s...

Save Wallum now

The Save Wallum campaign has been ongoing and a strong presence of concerned conservationists are on site at Brunswick Heads. How the state planning...

Can Council’s overturn their decisions?

NSW Labor planning minister, Paul Scully, when asked about the Wallum estate by local MP Tamara Smith (Greens)  in parliament on March 20, said,...