17.1 C
Byron Shire
June 4, 2023

Thus Spake Mungo: Welcome to chaos

Latest News

Why are white Australians even being asked to vote on the Voice?

The fast-approaching Voice referendum is a complete clusterf**k for all Australians. It stinks of failure at each and every...

Other News

Help kids fly…

Spaghetti Circus is calling for supporters for their Scholarship Program in 2024. Spaghetti’s passion is creating healthy, active, happy kids....

Private partnership sought for bioenergy facility proposal

Byron Council have been forced to explore the possibility of a public private partnership to fund its planned  bioenergy facility in Byron Bay.

Vale George Davidson OAM former Tweed Shire Councillor

A funeral will be held today for George Davidson OAM who was once a Tweed Shire Councillor and a passionate advocate for the Tweed.

Pushing-Up for mental health in June

Australia’s largest fitness-based mental health event, The Push-Up Challenge, is back in 2023, encouraging Australians to push for better mental health.

Will NSW Labor pay on-call emergency service volunteers?

The newly elected NSW Labor government have stopped short of committing to paying volunteers who attend emergencies such as fires and floods, but say there is investment and initiatives underway to support those who volunteer as emergency service members.

Greens for survival

At the recent Nimbin Town Hall where Sue Higginson, among others, was active in an affirmative action workshop where...

Emergency warning: off the streets, go to the storm shelters immediately. It is too late to flee – save yourselves as best you can.

We have, we have been reliably informed, been plunged into instability and chaos. Many of us would regard this as business as usual – it has, after all, been the pattern for months, if not years.

But our 30th (and counting) prime minister says you ain’t seen nothing yet. The apparent ascension of Kerryn Phelps has meant that any hope of safe and steady government has been and gone in Wentworth.

Scott Morrison’s fledgling administration has now gone into minority, and, as the leader warned, threatened and even promised repeatedly during the campaign, the result will be horrific. And he should know – he is not just a politician but an advertising man, so we can trust him implicitly. Fasten your seat belts and hang on to your hats.

This, was his story until last Saturday. But then, suddenly, it was all about back to work on Monday, delivering what matters to the Australian people, not being distracted by the Canberra bubble – that’s all over, nothing to see here.

‘ScoMo’s tirade on Saturday night included the admission that Liberals has been angry, and obviously some 20 per cent of them were very angry indeed. But Morrison offered nothing to appease them…’

Time to put it behind us and move on. After all, Julia Gillard governed in a minority for nearly three years and she only had 73 members while Morrison has 75, with the promise of at least two more committed to sticking with him on no confidence motions. Instability? What instability?

Well, perhaps the bit between ScoMo’s slightly protruding ears. His tirade on Saturday night included the admission that Liberals has been angry, and obviously some 20 per cent of them were very angry indeed. But Morrison offered nothing to appease them; instead he decided to be angry himself and proceeded to shout ritual abuse against Bill Shorten.

It was a performance curiously reminiscent of Malcolm Turnbull’s petulant outburst after the 2016 election, a performance that did Turnbull no good whatsoever. And speaking of which, the mad right has no doubt at all whom to blame for the debacle: it was all Turnbull’s fault. Just because he was ousted in a vicious and shambolic coup, there was no need for him to do what he always said he would and leave the parliament.

After all, when he knocked off Tony Abbott, Abbott stayed around, and look how well that has turned out. If Turnbull had any sense of loyalty (unlike the plotters and insurgents who undermined, sniped and wrecked until they destroyed him) he would have stayed around in Point Piper and campaigned for Dave Sharma.

Given the clear mood of the electors of Wentworth this would almost certainly have damaged Sharma’s campaign further, but so what? Someone has to wear the obloquy. And it wasn’t going to be Morrison, although if anyone could be accused of damaging Sharma’s campaign it had to be him and his dysfunctional colleagues.

Even the dumbest pollster must have discerned that two very serious issues in in the affluent suburbs are climate change and asylum seekers. Morrison completely ignored climate change, which 40 per cent of the electorate named as their number one concern, and floated the idea of revisiting the New Zealand solution (albeit under draconian and possibly unconstitutional restrictions) to move some of those stranded on Nauru.

But even if his solution was workable, and it probably isn’t, it would merely scratch the surface. Jacinta Ardern has offered to take 150, but that would still leave nine tenths of the victims behind, with no obvious salvation in sight.

Anyway, it was only an idea – as was the wizard wheeze to move the Australian embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. This thought, says our prime minister, emerged from the planet-sized brain of Sharma himself – but it had absolutely nothing to do with the by-election, or the fact that Donald Trump had announced similar policy few months earlier.

No one believed either assertion – even Sharma admitted that he only started thinking about the suggestion after Trump moved. And for Morrison to say that this could move the peace process forward was ludicrous: West Jerusalem was always envisaged as the capital of Israel, but the only feasible site for a Palestinian capital under the two state solution would be East Jerusalem, and neither Trump nor, crucially, Benjamin Netanyahu and his theocratic government would ever entertain the notion: for them, Jerusalem is their indivisible and eternal city given to them by God, and others can only be allowed grudging visiting rights.

‘This is not responsible government – indeed, it is not government at all. This is vaudeville, slapstick, the Keystone Kops without the subtlety and sophistication. And now this unrepentant mob is gearing up for a custard pie fight over religious privilege.’

And, of course, the idea was manifestly against Australia’s national interest: the blow-back from Indonesia alone has made it clear that there could be considerable economic and political damage from Morrison’s thought bubble. And it won few, if any, votes in Wentworth: hard line Jews were going to vote Liberal anyway and moderates were more likely to be repulsed by Morrison’s cynical shenanigans than wooed.

Instability and chaos – but that wasn’t meant to start until next week. And that was without even mentioning the Pauline Hanson and the Okay to be white fiasco, the superfluous Melissa Price insulting the former Kiribati president Anote Tong in a Canberra restaurant and Father of the Year, Barnaby Joyce, offering to graciously take back the leadership of the Nationals if they really insisted – it would be churlish to refuse them.

This is not responsible government – indeed, it is not government at all. This is vaudeville, slapstick, the Keystone Kops without the subtlety and sophistication. And now this unrepentant mob is gearing up for a custard pie fight over religious privilege.

Morrison must be tempted to simply write the end of 2018 off as an aberration and hope that by the new year his party will have purged itself of the massive amounts of shit on its collective liver and be ready for a bit of good news – at least as far as the economy is concerned. Then it can all be cleared up before the real election, where the incomparable Dave Sharma can be returned to his rightful place and normal transmission can be resumed.

Well, he can hope. But science tells us that entropy always increases: the tendency is for chaos to get steadily worse, not better. Fortunately, ScoMo the ProMo is not too hung up about science – this is why he told the farmers to pray for rain rather than acknowledge the reality of climate change. So the power of prayer may be his last, best and only chance.

Nothing else is working. If you really want stable government, go and live with the horses – they make more sense than the coalition.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. And as dramatic licence takes over Mungo’s page, stay calm, take a deep breath, be a bit calmer, Dave Sharma still has a chance in Wentworth, for what it is worth, Mungo Wentworth McCallum.

  2. What’s so funny is the COALition is waiting for everyone to realise how ‘right’ they are. We will come to our senses and see that their way backwards is the only way forwards … or something ???

    Poor stupid voters!

    ScoMo & Barnaby!

    What more could we want?

  3. Whether or not Dave Sharma does scrape over the line in Wentworth doesn’t affect the points Mungo is making. Wentworth has been a catastrophe – to even come near losing a seat they’ve NEVER lost before is the nail in the coffin of Coalition hopes at the next election. We have short memories, but not as short as the odds.

  4. Scumo warning against instability in government is like the captain of the Titanic railing against the use of ice in the margaritas.

  5. No need to worry about the refugees; once we burn enough coal and Nauru and Manus are under water, they will drown and save us any bother.

  6. It is almost unbelievable a Govt can be so incompetent.
    In just a few short weeks the Liberals out of control majority religious RWNJ faction under Morrisons”leadership” have, knifed their leader Turnbull.
    The only popular member in the party proper would vote for, that could actually raise funds for the party that has had the AEC refuse it’s party allocations now for years because of donation disclosure irregularities.
    Lost the Wentworth by-election with a 19% against it and their parliamentary majority with it and wasted a million dollars, effectively bankrupting the party.

  7. Entropy is five days of a cricket test 32 beers ending in a draw. But not chaos. The opposite is more like igniting a bomb, like the period of expansion we see in idealigical warfare, or the creation of a universe. Or one protest after another with targets changing randomly as due the climate. As due the climate advertisers. As due its PR. Still, robots don’t have to think, it’s done for us, til NASA or THE IPCC insists orherwise.

  8. Wich may be your point, Mango, having reread. I don’t think Sharma has more than a lotto chance, Len. What is irritating is how so much of politics, and the commentary on it, now comes down to statistics. Pollsters earn a living on it and science is a democracy apparently. And that is entropy as well, or an analogy to it. Better know your number in the future.

  9. The only thing that can stop Phelps now is, every dirty LNIPA trick in the book, and they will use every one of them?
    There is an Australia wide movement that has just been established called. ANYONE BUT THE NAT’S. Get behind it, the Northern rivers must rid itself of this political party!

  10. Allow me to say “I’VE HAD A GUT-FULL OF THE LOT.”
    I like our independent. All we need now is a political
    party of ‘independents only’ & mostly women.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Congratulations to Chris Minns for bringing in the new regulations about so-called VIP rooms in clubs and pubs. It’s only a small step in...

To Mandy 

I love reading Mandy’s Soapbox, she reflects what I’m thinking, and many like me. In the 17 May column titled ‘A crown is just a...

Getting Real About The Voice

Responding to Ian Pratt in an attempt to ‘get real about the Voice’. The proposal does not challenge the historical fact of conquest i.e....

Police compassion

Mandy, you said (Echo, 17 May)]: ‘There’s not many 95-year-olds I wouldn’t be able to overpower if necessary’ and ‘to disarm a 95-year-old with...