21.6 C
Byron Shire
May 10, 2021

Thus Spake Mungo: Where’s Scottie?

Latest News

Deep listening and housing ideas under Mullum’s fig trees for RenewFest

Around a hundred presenters, musicians, other artists and community activators plus a bumper crowd of punters all came together under the fig trees at the Mullumbimby Showground over the weekend for Renew Fest 2021.

Other News

Native Title declared on Evans Head after 25-year fight

Last week the court met on Evans Head, where 52 small parcels of land covering a total of 7.2 square kilometres were given native title.

Love flowers at the market

As mothers across Australia look forward to (slightly burnt) toast in bed, the local farmers and producers in our...

Government fails to support dying at home in Northern Rivers

Approaching the subject of dying is always tricky, often awkward, and never easy. But when you are faced with caring for someone at the end of their life, it helps if you can find support from people who have already navigated the path.

Humans suck

Hannah Grace, Ocean Shores I heard on the local news, like, this afternoon (April 20), that 370+ kilos of tuna...

Rous County Dam

Jo Faith, Newtown Strong objections to the proposed development of this dam have been articulated by the Indigenous Heritage First...

Entertainment in the Byron Shire and Beyond

A huge amount of entertainment all crammed into one space.

Scott Morrison, his office informs us, is taking a short break – off to the country for a bit of biking, boating and fishing.

But not shooting; the image of our easy-going prime minister with a lethal weapon in his hands might send the wrong message.

And emphatically, he is not shooting through; Morrison must know that he needs a miracle to survive but, hey, his mentors at the Horizon Church where he ostentatiously worships assured their followers that it was God’s will for him to become prime minister, so a quick ten per cent turn around in the polling should be a doddle.

But Morrison, forever the pragmatist, is also looking to the secular: he will interrupt his break for a visit to the Sydney test match, a ritual almost as predictable as the annual well-publicised secret visit to the troops.

But for most of the time he will be deciding how to turn around the terrible opinion polls, which now suggest that he is almost universally disliked: even normally reliable conservative voters, the women, the elderly and the rural, are turning against him.

The only comfort, such as it is, is that nobody likes Bill Shorten much either. But a clear majority are prepared to vote for him and, so far at least, Morrison’s shouty abuse is not deterring them.

Morrison still has time to turn them around – just. But he will have to do more than carry on about sledgehammers and wrecking balls – that didn’t work for either of his immediate predecessors.

ScoMo obviously believes he is a better politician than either Tony Abbott or Malcolm Turnbull, and he may well be right – although he hasn’t much to beat; neither was a great exemplar, having both been left bereft in the intricacies of government.

And in any case, that is hardy the point: the contest is not with Abbott and Turnbull, but with Shorten, and all the indications are that for all his shortcomings, Shorten has emerged as a truly formidable political operator.

Shorten has played on the stability and unity of his troops, which may have been dubious at times but the contrast with the ramshackle coalition makes it look like the Rock of Gibraltar.

For most of the last five years – indeed, far earlier than that – he has been grossly underestimated by both his opponents and the commentariat. His union connections make him vulnerable, his factional manoeuvring made him suspect and his manifest lack of charisma made him all but unelectable – or so it was said. But the hard fact remains that not only is his party comfortably besting the government just five months before the only poll that counts, it has been in that position for all but a few weeks during the last five years.

Shorten has played on the stability and unity of his troops, which may have been dubious at times but the contrast with the ramshackle coalition makes it look like the Rock of Gibraltar. He has offered policy initiatives that the government has consistently derided but has signally failed to counter and, in several cases, has been forced to adopt – the Royal Commission into the banks being only the most dramatic of the backflips.

And, perhaps most importantly, he has largely avoided the demented negativity that has been the leitmotif of the government. It is not clear who devised the Kill Bill tactic, but it is quite clear that it has not worked – at least not so far, and time is running out. Playing the man rather than the ball has always been seen as an underhand, illegitimate approach in the Australian ethos – Morrison, not only a spin merchant but a rugby league buff, would surely know that.

But that, he threatens, is how he plans to run his belligerent campaign Shorten is far from impregnable, and Morrison has already signalled his points of attack.

There will be an onslaught against any change to negative gearing – an utterly fraudulent one, given that Morrison, as treasurer, agreed aspects of the policy were excessive, before being slapped down by his leader. But, at a time of falling house prices, it may gain some undeserved traction.

More effective, perhaps, will be a blitzkrieg about dividend imputation, Shorten’s promise to remove tax refunds from those who didn’t pay the tax in the first place. This lurk mainly involves the rich, who can be expected to vote Liberal anyway, but the Murdoch press will be only too happy to find pensioners fearing they will be reduced to penury by any change.

So killing Bill, or even wounding him critically, is unlikely to work. And even if it does, Morrison needs something positive as well, and that means not just standing on his highly dubious record.

And then there is the hardy perennial, border security – stopping the boats, as it used to be called when there were boats to be stopped. This has lost most of its potency over the years, and the cry that Shorten will leave Australia at the mercy of the asylum seeker hordes is rather less credible than Shorten’s 2016 Mediscare campaign which Turnbull called ‘the great lie’. It is hard to see it taking off as a real game changer unless there is a dramatic incident – and while Peter Dutton will be only to keen to exploit one, or even manufacture one if the opportunity arises, the hope of another Tampa arriving is slim.

So killing Bill, or even wounding him critically, is unlikely to work. And even if it does, Morrison needs something positive as well, and that means not just standing on his highly dubious record. His government has amassed huge treasure chest, or perhaps more accurately pork barrel, but spending it is problematic.

One of the government’s genuine achievements during its tumultuous period has been its success in restraining public spending. A gigantic pre-election splurge might not only tarnish that trophy, but could easily appear desperate and extravagant, a last-ditch attempt to bribe cynical voters into submission. And if that is the case it could backfire badly, as when John Howard tried the tactic in 2007. He was comprehensively rejected by the electorate, and Honest John had far more authority and credibility than ScoMo will ever have.

So Kill Bill remains the default option. It probably won’t work, but then nothing much else has either. And if the worst comes to the worst, there will always be biking, boating and fishing to go back to. Not to mention shooting through.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Happy New Year, Mungo.

    I always look forward to reading your column. May you write many more!

    I will be sad to see this Men-zies government go. I will then have to moan about good ‘ol Power Bill!
    Hopefully, the next government will contain plenty of independents. I feel it is Time! (Where did I hear that last? Showing my age there….)


  2. The nation is having a short break from the prime minister and his office staff have confirmed this separation that the PM is off while the nation is in the state it is in while the New Year comes in.

  3. Aah, so its Gods will for Scott Morrison to be PM?

    Surely this is proof that God has very poor taste in politics… And ideology (ala same sex marriage debate).

    Maybe God should spend less time narrating through his Chosen One, and more on things in this world that matter… addressing inequality in sexuality, gender, etc., chronic widespread destitution and suffering throughout much of the underdeveloped world, child abuse in it’s own church.. the list goes on.

    Theology and ideology should never mix. I’ll never fathom why its such an expected element of a politicians portfolio to mindlessly submit to him of which there is no proof whatsoever (see Julia Gillard). Not even a skerriick.

    And ironic that many of these so called Christian conservatives (a euphemism for science fearing troglodytes) reject that which there clearly is proof, backed by multiple layers of science. Climate change.

    How about ScoMo, instead of frolicking around ripping fish out of their natural habitat, consider the damage he and his fellow god-fearers are doing to the environment that God so lovingly created.

    Irony and hypocrisy reign supreme in Coalition ideations.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Eating vegan is no longer like Mac Vs PC

Remember back in the bad old days when you used either a PC or Mac? Those were your choices, and never the twain could meet. They were so many miles apart in operations that they were like different countries with different languages and appearances

‘Endless land releases’ not the solution for Byron’s housing crisis, says Country Labor mayor hopeful

Northern Rivers-based trade unionist and MBA student Asren Pugh has announced his candidature for Byron Shire Mayor in September’s local government elections on behalf of Country Labor. 

Global predicament

Dudley Leggett – Director of Sustainability Research Institute, Suffolk Park Phillip Frazer’s article, (Echo 6 January) is an excellent summary of our global predicament, and a...

How full is that glass?

Cr Alan Hunter, Byron Shire Council Council Staff recommend opposing the proposed changes in the Exempt Development provisions to be considered in this week’s Council Ordinary meeting. The...