17.6 C
Byron Shire
May 30, 2024

The ‘new gold’-diggers: water ‘miners’, desperate farmers and thirsty councils

Latest News

Kingscliff locals concerned over proposal to remove trees at Merve Edwards Fields for AFL

The potential of removing trees from the Merve Edwards Fields site at Kingscliff to accommodate the Kingscliff Junior AFL Club has raised concerns of locals and neighbours who say that this is not a proposal they support. 

Other News

Thumbs down for Council’s plans for Mullum’s main St

Residents have sent a clear message to Council regarding its plans for Mullum’s main drag, with staff reporting over 500 submissions were received for the Burringbar Street Concept Design.

Surf like a woman

Local surfing legend Pauline Menczer has told her remarkable story in a new book, 'Surf Like a Woman', which tells the story of how she overcame sexism, homophobia and rheumatoid arthritis to become World Surfing Champion.

Byron Shire roads update

The Rifle Range Road intersection upgrade has begun in Bangalow, says Council staff, after a false start last month.

First observations of meltwater eating away at Antarctic ice shelves

Scientists who have witnessed Antarctic ice shelf decay are escalating concerns that rising air temperatures will push these frozen masses to unprecedented fractures.

New community meeting room in Lismore

A new community meeting room, free for non-profit organisations and community groups to hire, has been launched at the Lismore Library.

Boorabee Dorper lamb: delicious, but how can it help your arthritis?

In a beautiful example of letting nothing go to waste, Dorper Lamb’s Warren and Marina Wiggins have created a...

Mia Armitage

‘Water for food growing and drinking is the new gold and we have to protect it,’ says Tamara Smith, state Member for Ballina (Greens).

With data from the Bureau of Meteorology showing total dam capacity in NSW as of 20 November at just 27.9per cent, the lowest in the country, water restrictions, it seems, are the new black.

Ms Smith’s comment was in relation to the Ballina Shire Council’s recent rejection of a controversial development application for a water extraction business in Alstonville.

Water extraction is the process used by most water bottling companies and is more commonly referred to as water mining, since the water comes from beneath the ground as mineral, oil and gas reserves do.

As local governments across the Northern Rivers announce increased water restrictions, more regional politicians are backing an end to water extraction for the bottled water industry.

Tweed bores running dry, says water alliance

The Tweed Water Alliance says it has the support of the Lismore and Ballina state members as well as the Tweed and Ballina mayors in calling on the NSW water minister to ban water mining for the bottled water industry.

Alliance spokesperson Pat Miller says the minister, Melinda Pavey, has extensive powers over water extraction and can order a temporary ban.

Mr Miller says with the state suffering the worst drought on record and an unprecedented bushfire season, water resources are being drawn down at rapid rates.

The environmentalist says some people are resorting to bores to keep stock and crops alive, only to find them dry, and firefighters are struggling to find standing water to protect communities.

Meanwhile, Mr Miller says, water extractors are still pumping water out of the ground and profiting by sending the water out of the region.

Water mining on the Tweed

So far, the Tweed Shire Council has used local planning laws to stop new water bottling companies from starting business in the region.

But the council has reportedly had to bear costly court appeals from rejected applicants and requests from existing operators to extract more water than initially approved.

Some residents, most notably in and around Uki, have long complained of water extractors breaking development consent conditions, including allowed business hours and limits of water taken.

In early November, the Tweed Shire Council refused a land swap with a water miner at Nobby’s Creek.

The council’s planning department had proposed the swap after the Nobby’s Creek operator built unapproved infrastructure on crown land.

Mr Miller said since the department ‘had some latitude in reallocating land use’ he would like to see the power used ‘to support productive local and community industry’.

‘This always seems to be impossible with enterprises like the Uki Community Garden waiting over five years to have their small plot given the go-ahead for a positive, beneficial purpose,’ he said in a media release.

The council gave landowner Garry Appleby 90 days to remove the illegal infrastructure with Councillor Warren Polglase telling Echonetdaily failure to do so could prompt the council to take Mr Appleby to court.

Council crack-downs costing rate-payers

But Cr Polglase, who voted against the land swap refusal, said it was also possible Mr Appleby would decide to sue the council for refusing the land swap.

Cr Polglase said similar land swaps had been approved before, thereby setting a precedent.

‘I voted against the refusal because I thought it was unfair and unjust,’ Cr Polglase told Echonetdaily, saying he suspected prejudice against Mr Appleby because of the nature of the Nobby’s Creek water extraction business.

Tweed Mayor Katie Milne said land swaps had to feature a community benefit and ‘there were concerns raised in the community in relation to this not being in the public interest’.

Cr Polglase said the council would have benefited via a ‘dedicated road’ as part of the swap.

Mt Warning from Clarrie Hall Dam in the Tweed Valley.

Tweed residents facing water restrictions

Water security has been a consistent theme for the Tweed Shire Council this year, with most residents relying on water from the Clarrie Hall dam.

Selling council water outside the shire is now banned as part of level 1 water restrictions. Further water restrictions are due to be put in place once the dam’s capacity falls below 75 per cent, an event authorities predict will happen by Christmas.

The council unanimously voted against granting an exception to the ban for the Falls Festival planned for the New Year period in the neighbouring Byron Shire.

There are also plans to raise the wall and thereby capacity of Clarrie Hall Dam.

‘It took us eight years to decide to do the studies and acquire the land,’ Cr Polglase told Echonetdaily, citing a cost of $12 million.

Cr Polglase said the project would cost up to $70 million to realise and relied on a combination of state and federal funds.

Call for Nats to lose water management responsibility

Meanwhile, The Sydney Morning Herald recently reported the NSW government had ignored multiple warnings since 2012 the state would need new water supply sources in regional areas within ten years.

The October report said the government had ignored calls from Infrastructure NSW via its 20-year plan, the State Infrastructure Strategy, for a state-wide dam program study as a matter of urgency.

Independent NSW upper house member Justin Field said the Nationals should be ‘stripped’ of the state’s water portfolio.

The Climate Council had previously called for immediate action across Australia on water security and climate change after last year’s report on deluge and drought in the country.

That report linked climate change with worsening droughts, including the current ongoing one, and other extreme weather events such as bushfires and floods.

It also identified water security as a source of grave concern.

The report showed if climate change effects were left unchecked, results for farming and other sectors would be devastating.

Three benefits of saving water now: 1. Reducing water use will also reduce energy consumption. 2. Simple changes can save you money on water and electricity bills. 3. Reducing demand on the region’s main water source, Rocky Creek Dam, will delay future water restrictions and the need for new infrastructure. Photo supplied.

Drought lingers on the Northern Rivers

A year later, residents in the tiny towns of Mullumbimby, Nimbin and Tyalgum have all been told of tightened water restrictions in the past fortnight and the Rous County Council has voted to increase the Rocky Creek Dam water level needed to trigger level one restrictions.

Mullumbimby went straight from level one to level three water restrictions in less than three weeks this month; Nimbin is on level two; and Tyalgum starts level four restrictions from midnight Sunday.

Meanwhile, Rous County Council Chair and Ballina Councillor Keith Williams says levels in the Rocky Creek dam are currently dropping by two – two and a half per cent each week.

Rocky Creek Dam supplies most town water in the region, including to most residents and businesses in the Byron, Ballina, Lismore and Richmond Valley shires.

Previously, level one restrictions for Rocky Creek dam users wouldn’t happen until the dam’s capacity fell to 60 per cent.

But advice to users in mid-November was to save water wherever possible to ensure ‘enough water in the system should fire impact any infrastructure that Council staff cannot immediately attend to’.

The warning came as an out-of-control bushfire on Mount Nardi moved towards the Whian Whian state forest, home to the Rocky Creek dam.

The dam was at 83 per cent capacity at the start of November and without significant rain, the figure reported via the Rous County Council website three weeks later was 76 per cent.

On Wednesday this week, the council voted to change the level one trigger to 70per cent.

Water restrictions: business as usual?

But most residents in the Richmond Valley and Kyogle shires have been on restrictions all year.

Kyogle Mayor Danielle Mulholland said when announcing level one restrictions back in January that it was an unusual time of year to have them.

Low flow in the Richmond River and a lack of input from Peacock Creek into the dam at Bonalbo had left authorities with little choice.

Richmond Valley Council Acting General Manager at the time, Angela Jones, told media that flow in the Richmond River was trending downwards even with WaterNSW increasing release from Toonumbar Dam from 18ML per day to 28ML per day.

Right now, most of the Kyogle shire is on level two except for Bonalbo, which is on level three.

The western half of the Richmond Valley shire, including residents in Casino, has been on level three restrictions twice this year.

Decent rain prompted a move back to level one in April but less than six months later, the Richmond Valley Council announced level three restrictions again.

Businesses including the Northern Co-operative Meat Company, Norco, concrete company Holcim and others who needed water as part of essential business activity were exempt and there weren’t any restrictions on stock watering.

But as Tenterfield residents have experienced since mid-February, level four restrictions are significantly tougher.

Getting bore-ing yet?

Owners of livestock in the village of Jennings were instructed to stop giving the animals water from the town’s water dispensing station in March.

In August, the Tenterfield Shire Council called for residents with knowledge of old water bores to share the information.

By then, the council had declared level four-and-a-half water restrictions and was hoping there were unregistered bores around that may have been missed in its search for water.

The council said level five restrictions were a last resort as they would have a dire effect on tourism in Tenterfield and would force the closure of many businesses.

Business chamber echoes calls for stronger water plans

By late September, Northern Rivers businesses were calling for immediate water solutions to ensure the region’s long-term future.

Northern Rivers Manager of the NSW Business Chamber Jane Laverty said after many reviews, there was still no long-term water strategy to prepare the state adequately for drought.

Ms Laverty told the media the drought had been made ‘so much worse’ through widespread water mismanagement and waste, over extraction, meter tampering, and over-bank flows.

The NSW Business Chamber called for an urgent state-wide water management strategy and for the NSW and federal governments to start talks on short-term and long-term actions they would take to address the water crisis.

New levels of water desperation

While impacts of the state’s continued drought on rivers, creeks and dams are obvious, NSW Water Minister Melinda Pavey is yet to release the findings of a second report from the state’s chief scientist on water extraction sustainability.

The Tenterfield Shire Council has delayed moving to level five restrictions in response to continued pressure from worried residents and instead declared a new level as of November: level four-point-seven.

This was despite wide-spread news of the council’s joy at finding two well-stocked bores in late October.

Tenterfield Council Chief Executive Terry Dodds said the council was about to advertise a contract for a $9.3m water filtration plant so recycled water could be introduced to the shire’s supply.

Will the water the Northern Rivers region was once so famous for soon only be as famous when bought in a bottle?

Residents in other parts of the country, including in the Gold Coast hinterland areas of Springbrook and Mount Tamborine are asking similar questions.

‘There is no social license or environmental license to use underground aquifer water on food growing land for industrial extraction,’ Greens Member for Ballina Tamara Smith has said.

Her party is against water mining but there are so far no signs of support from the government other than the delayed release of the second report.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. The water mining industry’s claim that groundwater and surface water (creeks and rivers) are unlikely to be connected is based on flimsy, biased and self serving ‘evidence’. The same hydrogeologist wrote three
    groundwater reports to support three separate development applications.
    The Tweed Water Alliance assert that these reports were never subjected to appropriate scrutiny. More
    eminent, highly credentialled hydrogeologist’s reports say a connection is highly likely. Simple
    intelligent logic would support this and skeptically refute the paid-for ‘science’. The three reports
    provided for the water miners were desktop studies, the refuge of the incompetent or the compromised.
    It is the stated position of NSW that groundwater and surface water are interconnected according to a
    commissioned and accepted 2011 paper.
    The water being extracted for the bottling industry is therefore missing from our water courses. It is still
    being extracted as the NSW government declares a state of emergency and bushfires destroy property
    and habitat. During the recent bushfire just west of Uki, a Rural Fire Service truck was seen heading in
    one direction with a water miner’s truck passing it travelling in the opposite direction.

  2. Water is the new Gold? It always has been in this country! What idiot can’t see that? And for councils to allows any water mining in any part of this country are also idiots! The “Spring Water” bottling industry must stop! Go to Bunnings and get yourself a filtration system for below the sink. If you can’t afford that, buy a Terracotta bench top systems. There are all sorts on the market. Even ones you can carry with you.
    Be responsible for your own water purification even if you’re traveling. The sooner bottled water gets off the shelf the better. Less plastic to recycle as well.
    Or just used to the tap water for the planet’s sake. Most places in this country tap water is fine. One day we will have to start drinking recycled sewerage or sea water at the rate were going!

  3. I am 81, living in Australia since 1997 and I understand the public’s concern about the subject that I now consider as essential namely the management of drinkingwater. Here are my thoughts:
    Clouds are formed from the evaporation of water vapour from the seas, lakes and rivers as well as from the earth. These clouds sail through the world and dump rain when they encounter condensation nuclei. Then the rain falls anytime and anywhere. So far, no one has appropriated it. This rain feeds the earth, trickles and ends up either in the basement or returns to the river lakes and eventually to the sea to redo its cycle. In form it does not yet belong to anyone.
    When it enters underground it feeds either the water table or forms underground streams or natural springs. These rivers form all over the world and take an indefinite direction. This water is still free (and hopefully unpolluted.).
    These water tables are a nature reserve. Operated by collective distribution organizations, it is normal for it to be billed for filtration and distribution. This water is managed on behalf of communities and remains a non-polluting life supply.
    On the other hand, if a landowner discovers a spring or a water table in his land, he appropriates it. In these circumstances he mistakenly considers that this water has self-generated and that it is intended for its own use and that it can enjoy it as it pleases. This is a serious mistake because by doing so, it can deprive its neighbours of this water which can also extend under their land or in case of underground streams, deprive the downstream communities through which this water can cross.
    Every time I use the Scenic drive, either to Tweed Heads or on my way back, I meet with 15 to 20 m3 trucks carrying sometimes at excessive speed, to Queensland a full load. The full tank of these trucks is in the vicinity of Bilambil. In the past I have read the actions taken by Tweed Shire Council against this procedure, which I approve. It doesn’t seem they’ve won.
    Having not conducted my investigation further forward, I suppose this water is destined for bottling and for sale. If this is true, in my opinion we are faced with many inconsistencies with disastrous consequences
    1) The landowner negotiates water that belongs to the community, so there is robbery
    2) The buyer, who acquires this water cheaply, sells it at a prohibitive price after packaging
    3) During this packaging, by truck of 15,000 liters, 15,000 plastic bottles are used. How many of them will be recycled? That it is the amount of raw material needed to make them. If we stick to a daily round of 20 trucks, we have 300,000 litres of precious liquid stolen from the community and 300,000 plastic bottles in the wild, polluting the land, rivers and the sea, the source of our lives. Since these rounds even take place on weekends, each week we could have 2,100,000 waste.
    I am not familiar with the Australian water management regulations but I know that in some countries it is strict and that even someone who is lucky enough to have a stream that runs through his property has to apply for capture before applying for to benefit. An investigation determines the impact of this capture on the environment and the community. This is normal because downstream residents may be deprived of this water.
    For more equity, this water must be integrated into the general management of this material, which is increasingly rare because it is indispensable to life and serve the community and not to private interests whose sole purpose is the carefree profit of pollution that this profit era.
    All over the world, these plastic bottles must be banned, just like plastic bags. The most important action is to make drinking all the water Earth avoiding being polluted by industries or by human action: there is a primary urgency to decontaminate it. Once the running water serving the community is made to drink, it will no longer be necessary to buy it in bottles. These, so harmful to the whole world, disappearing a great step will be taken to save humanity.
    Sincerely yours

  4. When has Polglase ever voted in favour of something that really benefitted either the community or the environment? Typical National self interest and catering to business mates and donors. How dumb are Tweed voters to constantly re-elect him after the repeated scandals over the past 20 years? Maybe they just have Alzheimers and can only remember voting National Country Party in the 70s and nothing else – well Doug Anthony is a good chap for deputy PM isn’t he?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Ballina Council to look into making tiny homes accessible 

The idea of living in a tiny home can seem like a simple solution to our housing crisis – but getting council approvals for a permanent tiny home on private land can be challenging. 

Council staff to look at limiting bulk and scale in Wategos  

A motion by Cr Sarah Ndiaye (Greens) to amend the LEP to reduce the building height limits in the Wategos residential area from 9m to 8m was unsuccessful at last Thursday’s Council meeting. 

Is this the next Bentley? New doco highlights value of Clarence River amid mining proposal

Mining plans for the region were discovered by two locals as they paddled down the Clarence River near Grafton. The question is what does it mean for the future of the Northern Rivers?

Editorial – Mining is back, baby! 

Nearly ten years ago in 2015, junior coal seam gas miner Metgasco was paid out handsomely – $25m of your tax money – after its approval to frack Bentley was fiercely fought off by thousands of well-organised protesters. But now they are back...