18.8 C
Byron Shire
April 1, 2023

Editorial: Watch out! It’s biased

Latest News

Tweed residents outraged at destruction of koala habitat on Cobaki Creek

A 'legacy' floodplain development on the tidal estuary of Cobaki Creek, known to have recent koala sightings, was approved in 1996 and is now being cleared.

Other News

Byron Council staff push for Mullum’s water supply to become part of Rous

A committee that makes recommendations to Council around water and sewage management in the Shire is calling for Mullum’s water supply to remain at Lavertys Gap weir in Wilsons Creek.

It’s Sunset and it’s Loooooong

If there’s one thing that indie music fans can all agree on, it’s The Long Sunset – the wanderlust music and camping festival set in the lush surrounds of the Canungra, Queensland hinterland on 29 April.

Goodbye to an inspiring scientist, activist and friend

Mary’s influence on me as a local activist, and later councillor, was profound – she opened my eyes to how water courses through and shapes this place.

Call for Labor government to reinstate logging moratorium – now

North East Forest Alliance’s Dailan Pugh has pointed out that a Minns NSW Labor government has given no commitment to quick and decisive action on behalf of our forests – but we need action 'now' he says.

Share flood stories at Mullum Farmers Market

To mark the anniversary of the 28 February 2022 flooding of Mullumbimby, which was followed by continued flooding throughout...

NEFA welcomes the election of a new government

The North East Forest Alliance welcomes the election of the Minns Labor government with their promise to create a Great Koala National Park, and calls for a moratorium on logging within the park proposal until the promised assessment is complete.

Hans Lovejoy, editor

Everyone has a bias – it’s a natural human condition. It’s always a surprise to hear a political actor complain that The Echo is biased.

The issue is really about fairness, not bias.

Judges have bias, as do police and educators. No one is immune; it’s all just a well orchestrated charade to keep the population placated while those who run the joint don’t get found out.

Imagine if the unwashed masses actually knew that?

Likewise, all government strategies and plans that underpin policy and law are also geared for outcomes, or bias.

New figures from Byron Shire Council show one in six properties in the shire are being holiday let. Photo: AirbnbSecrets

Take for example, Council’s holiday letting policy, now on exhibition. It’s called Short-Term Rental Accommodation (STRA), and aims to formalise using a residential home in Byron Shire as holiday accomodation.

After years of inaction from the state government (owing to Airbnb lobbying and the fact that many political actors own holiday rentals), they finally announced a policy last year.

Graciously, these overlords of local government allowed the limiting of letting in Byron Shire to 90 days per year. But the map that accompanies Council’s strategy suggests 365 days in some parts of the Shire. When asked why Council didn’t present the lower limit of 90 days, planning staff replied that, ‘Precincts for higher day-limits have been included as an option, although this may be reconsidered or revised for the final planning proposal, taking into account feedback from the community’.

So it’s up to you, dear resident, to make sure that your neighbours aren’t advocating for year-round holiday letting. That is, assuming you like to live within a community. 

Yet finding that out appears impossible, because there are no provisions for declarations of interests in this submission and survey process.

When asked why, planning staff replied, ‘We have received submissions from a wide range of people on both sides of the debate. All submissions will be considered on planning merits’.

The Byron Residents’ Group make a similar point about the survey in a recent press release: ‘…Although the survey asks for your postcode, it doesn’t ask if you are a holiday letting host or not. Airbnb contacted people prior to the last NSW state election, and told them to vote for the coalition, who have created the 365-day short term letting legislation. Airbnb will no doubt be lobbying the hosts of the 3,000-odd whole homes that are listed in Byron, and telling them to make a submission.’

It goes on: ‘Did you know that 1,331 listings for entire homes in Byron are listed by only 359 hosts? This is not just local people making some extra money, this is an industry that has its hooks in our Shire’. 

It’s a tough balance to get right where individual freedoms don’t impinge upon the freedoms of others. Unfortunately, the Byron Shire councillor majority have form in the area of putting developer interest over community. Just before Christmas, they waived through a massive-scale rezoning of rural lands to commercial. That looks like a looming clusterfuck, and was among one of the worst decisions in years.

Submissions for the STRA close January 30 and the documents can be found on Byron Shire Council’s website.

Three cheers for community!

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. The norm or normal is the average of the majority. That average then becomes the rule. Only people who think outside that majority of what the majority thinks have a bias as the bias the majority have is neutralised because there are so many people with the same bias.
    The political bias of the Byron Shire is to be Green as seen by people outside the Shire. Inside the Shire the people do not have a bias or seen to have a bias as that bias is in the majority. They all back each other up in being green.
    Byron Council, please take note for any deviation from being green will be voted on by the majority of the people at the election.
    There once was a Greens councillor, Rose Wanchap. She deviated from being green to more pro-development and she was voted out of Council.
    We are travelling down the same path with the present Byron Shire Council.
    There is a defining sentence in this article:
    “Unfortunately, the Byron Shire councillor majority have form in the area of putting developer interest over community.”
    That is indeed a defining sentence.

  2. Perhaps the Council needs to hire a data analysis company – like InsideAirBnB or BnB Guard and identify how many of the properties used for un-hosted STRA are owned by people who live elsewhere. This was done by Inside Airbnb for the City of Jersey. It gave the city council and the local resident population a very clear picture of who was benefiting from the massive conversion of housing and apartments to tourism. The data cuts through the marketing hype of the global platforms.

    Read the report:


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Murwillumbah Fire Station needs more firefighters

There is probably not one adult who hasn’t been grateful for the job that firefighters have done in this country, particularly in the aftermath of the The 2019–20 Australian bushfires.

Draw your puss to win cat pack prizes

The reason cats take up so much of the collective internet space is because they are just so incredibly cute – we love them! But we don't always keep them inside when they should be.

Dental clinic celebrates 30 years in Mullum

It’s quite an achievement to own and operate a business for 30 years and more so with your life partner and that’s exactly what David and Kim Smith have done.

Working with Nature at the Living Lab

Living Lab Northern Rivers has opened their new exhibition 'Working with Nature' this week in their Lismore shopfront space, giving visitors the chance to learn more about flood mitigation strategies.