Menu

Why do Black Lives Matter?

Jason Campbell, Delta Kay and Danny Teece-Johnson will march in solidarity with protesters in America and to highlight the ongoing racism and Aboriginal deaths in custody in Australia. Photo Tree Faerie.

Eve Jeffery

The question that many are asking is, ‘why do Black Lives Matter when all lives matter’? No one is arguing against the idea that all lives matter but at this time in history, with the recent death of George Floyd in the US – highlighting yet again the injustices toward black people that happen on a daily basis – people from all Indigenous cultures and ethnic backgrounds are feeling the pain of this man’s family, his community and his country and the global ache of yet more racism.

Australian deaths in custody

Local Indigenous woman Delta Kay said that George Floyd’s death triggers Aboriginal people about Australian deaths in custody. ‘We understand black Americans’ grief and shock. This is then compounded by a burning outrage as government and high ranking police officials cover the deaths in custody with lies.

‘Of course we are outraged here in Australia with over 432 Aboriginal deaths in police custody or prison custody since 1991, with no convictions for the murderers.’

Bundjalung ‘Bunyarra Dubay‘ dancers Ellie Davidson, Indira Arnold Freire, Belle Arnold, Delta Kay, Minyani Webber, Nickolla Clark and Rikkara McGuiness. Photo Jeff Dawson

The Bunyarra Culture Collective

Ms Kay is part of a local Aboriginal group called the Bunyarra Culture Collective – this group is hosting a peaceful vigil this Saturday in solidarity with Aboriginal people who have lost their lives in police custody. Bunyarra members wanted to stand together with their Aboriginal brothers and sister across the country at this pivotal time in world history.

‘Sadly Australians are racists. We cannot point our finger at Americans when so many Australians are guilty of racism – you can see throughout the media comments, I believe our Government breeds racism to keep minority Australians down.

‘Non Aboriginal people are asking me what can they do? Easy – learn about the Uluru Statement from the Heart.

The Uluru Statement from the Heart

‘By all Australians supporting the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a document that outlines a path forward for recognising Aboriginal Australians in the national constitution, you are showing that you believe Aboriginal people have a valid voice in the laws and policies that are made.

‘As a nation we need to bring the Statement from the Heart back to the table if we want to have systematic change and justice for Australia’s First Peoples.

‘This four day agreement-making and truth-telling between government and Aboriginal Elders was held in May 2017 and our Government turned their back on it.’

Yes we KNOW all lives matter – no one is arguing that, but today, right now, this is the house that is burning. Thanks to the very talented Kris Straub for creating this awesome cartoon. Check out more of his great work at: chainsawsuit.com.

Apathy towards Aboriginal Australians

Belle Budden is a member of the Bunyarra Collective. She says many Indigenous people were distressed by the events in the community, and more so at Australian’s outrage and support for the Black Lives Matter campaign in America, and apparent apathy when an Aboriginal person in Australia dies in police custody.

‘Bunyarra want to create a platform for our community members who have been triggered by these events to tell their stories of police brutality and deaths in custody so we can start the process of truth, justice and healing towards true Reconciliation,’ said Ms Budden. ‘The scenes we are seeing in the United States, and the clear message from their leader that property is more important than black lives has triggered many of our people. The event on Saturday is about telling this story so our people do not need to live with memories refreshed.’

Local Area Command Aboriginal Police Liaison Officers

Ms Budden says that in the Byron Shire, Bunyarra members maintain a positive and productive relationship with the Local Area Command. ‘There have been excellent Aboriginal Police Liaison Officers who have worked hard to build meaningful relationships and programs for our people. Each year they run the Tweed Byron Police Commanders Active Citizen Program and engage local Bundjalung woman, and Bunyarra Director Delta Kay as a mentor.

‘This is one of very few programs that actively targets our Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander young people and we acknowledge and commend them for their ongoing commitment. The Local Area Command were the first to contact Bunyarra and offer support to ensure that our message for the vigil is not hijacked.’

The Byron Shire community has criminalised Aboriginal people

Ms Budden say that it is the Byron Shire community and its economics that has criminalised Aboriginal people. ‘Affordability, cultural visibility and place here in community had huge impacts on our people.

‘Our cultural practices, outdoor, on country have been over-regulated, prohibited and criminalised. Being forced into over-crowded corners of the shire where there is no central place for us to practice our culture in ways that are good for our wellbeing has forced Bundjalung people out of the community and off their own country.

‘Byron Shire’s increasing privilege has left us locked out of this community and the discomfort and fear caused by our presence causes people to use the police to enforce their own prejudice.’

There is no treaty between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and the Commonwealth, and in Australia, black deaths in custody represent the ongoing genocide of First Nations people.

Aboriginal Australians the most incarcerated on the planet

‘Our people are the most incarcerated per capita on the planet,’ says Ms Budden. ‘This is largely a result of the poverty and racism experienced by our people. As a nation we need to accept that there is indeed much racism ingrained in Australian culture and psyche, and move towards a process of reconciliation that allows for truth, justice and healing.’

‘Locally our people need to have a meaningful place in this community that acknowledges the socio-economic injustices from the past, which addresses our struggle as well as celebrating our culture. Our people have so little in this community yet the Bundjalung of Byron Bay have, through years of struggle and hard work, wrapped this community in National Parks to protect country, which many businesses have capitalised upon.

‘We as a community, with true respect for First Nations People and real reconciliation, could lead the nation towards a better future – starting by standing together to say Black Lives Matter.’

The rally and COVID-19

Ms Kay says that there are some people in the Byron community who are condemning her for organizing this peaceful rally because of COVID-19. ‘The government has opened Byron up for visitors and we are told that hygiene is our responsibility, so our rally will have Harmony Keepers and local police reminding people to observe the social distancing rules.

‘We feel strongly that we must rally in support now while this issue is in the world spotlight as Australians won’t care in six months time.’

Ms Kay makes a heartfelt plea to the community. ‘Byron, please don’t turn a blind eye to Aboriginal people dying in police custody, have a say and read the Statement from the Heart for a stronger and united future for our children.’

A rally in Lismore on Saturday

The Lismore community is also having a rally – their Facebook event page says that they are protesting in solidarity on Widjabul Wybal soil with the uprising in the USA and against the murder of Aboriginal people – Black Deaths in Custody.

They are calling on elders, brothers and sisters to join the rally and protest, sharing this pain together, standing in unity and solidarity.

‘When we gather, let’s all bend our knee and raise our fists in silence for the loss of all our black brothers and sisters murdered.

The Lismore rally will begin on Saturday at 12.30pm in Spinks Park, Lismore.

The Byron Bay rally and march will begin at 2pm at the Rec Grounds in Marvel Street, Byron Bay.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


8 responses to “Why do Black Lives Matter?”

  1. Liz L says:

    ‘Black lives matter’ is a fantastic catch cry and I totally get it. Those who rail against the ‘Stop violence against women’ campaign – what about men! – just don’t realise how some groups are pretty subsumed, overlooked even invisible when the maths clearly indicate they should be the focus of the campaign.

    I hate though, being faced with this dilemma: whether you attend or stay away (as far as I’m concerned) you are making a statement. I want to show solidarity against racial oppression but, at this particular point in the war against sars-cov-2, I don’t want to be communicating a disregard for the communal effort, for which many have paid dearly, to keep us all safe. If everyone is sensible in places like Byron Bay (and that’s a huge if), there’s probably room to minimise danger but the potential capital city gatherings are terrifying.

    And the irony is, those disproportionately affected by Covid19 have been the African American population just as is likely for our indigenous siblings if the virus gets away here. Morality is a minefield.

  2. Emily Stewart says:

    The more the number of people increase on the planet the more life does not matter and the quality of life diminishes. The moment George Floyd died was the moment that a black life did not matter.
    Time went on and his death did not matter. His life did not matter and later as time went further on, the protests began and the streets were flooded with people and then the policeman was charged with murder. At that time George Floyd’s life and his death then mattered. His existance and his death lit a flame for the people to follow that they must speak out against inequality.
    And the days went on, and the protests went on and the violence began and what mattered then were the protests as they came to a peak noticed around the world as a fire steaming and screaming with heat and anger. From those protests many days later the other three poliemaen were then charged with murder and suddenly the life of a black man, George Floyd began to come up as a matter of conscience that stirred the people and politicians about equal rights and that all people have the equal right of others no matter what the colour of the pain is felt.

  3. Liz L says:

    Really really true, Emily – well said and the behaviour we ignore is the behaviour we condone. It’s not like there isn’t a huge downside though right now to mass gatherings and a virus doesn’t just seek out the guilty. It’s a question without a right answer.

  4. Salmon says:

    I share the dilemma that Liz describes so important to attend but with elderly parents I also am very aware of the spread of Covid.

    I drove past the 5G rally in Mullum yesterday and was shocked at the complete disregard for social distancing.

  5. Yes Liz…… morality is a minefield, always has been. When
    Social Distancing is kept at this time I cannot see why
    the protests can’t be held in a positive & supporting way
    because this ‘coming together’ is long overdue. It should
    be a rally focused on the incarcerated minority & the Uluru
    Statement of the Heart. As well, look to Native America.
    First Nation people are the Forgotten Ones.

  6. Nerida says:

    Mass gatherings during a pandemic is the stuff of self-indulgent ignoramus.

  7. John Lazarus says:

    Had the same dilemma, but attended. In respect for the 430 deaths in custody since the failure of the Royal Commission into deaths in Custody, and the hundreds of thousands of Aboriginal deaths prior, and with up to 1,300,000 Aboriginal residents at the time of occupation (but now, after 200 years past early mass deaths, only at 800,000), also for the lost Aboriginal souls of perhaps 5,000,000 Aboriginal children that were never born.

  8. Liz L says:

    Watching the national newsreels last night caused me the most disturbing conflict of emotions. It’s normally so reassuring and uplifting to see such huge displays of decency. But the bigger and more congested the crowds were, the more frightening to think of the implications for the pandemic. It was commendable to see so many masks and volunteers distributing masks and hand sanitiser. The organisers were clearly doing their best but physical distancing seemed often impossible. Let’s hope the measures taken were effective.

    .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Echonetdaily is made possible by the support of all of our advertisers and is brought to you by this week's sponsor, Enspire Furniture & Homewares.