9.6 C
Byron Shire
May 14, 2021

Byron Shire Council accused of maladministration over bypass

Latest News

Michael Lyon elected as Byron Mayor

Owing to the resignation of former Mayor at the end of April, a vote was held today to replace Simon Richardson, until the next election

Other News

Re Netflix

David Gilet, Byron Bay You would have to say that the Byron district has more than its fair share of wankers,...

Marvell Hall’s ‘Dangerously Poetic’ fundraiser

This Sunday Marvell Hall will host a tribute to some of the street-named fellows with poetry, music and portraits as a fundraiser for the hall.

False impressions

Fast Buck$, Coorabell I was under the impression that, upon the mayor resigning, the deputy mayor would automatically get the...

‘Natural’ cruelty

Richard Swinton, Clunes While I agree with Desmond Bellamy’s concerns about animal cruelty, the issue of ‘natural’ cruelty if the...

Govt’s new housing plan fails to impress local reps

Local government representatives on the Northern Rivers have expressed doubts over the state government’s new Housing 2041 Strategy.

Flickerfest tour returns to the Northern Rivers

Celebrating 30 years in 2021 Flickerfest is bringing its National Tour to The Regent Cinema Murwillumbah for one big film packed this weekend

Floodplain rainforest vegetation that has been cleared to make way for the Byron Bypass.

Aslan Shand

A formal complaint of maladministration by Byron Shire Council (BSC) over the management of the Byron bypass process and implementation has been lodged with BSC’s general manager, Mark Arnold.

However, the lodgement of the complaint has been problematic with the original emails sent on the 10 and 19 August going into both the GM’s and Council’s general email spam folders. After multiple phone calls the emails were finally retrieved, 15 days after they were sent.

Community Alliance Byron Shire (CABS), who lodged the complaint, stated that BSC was presented with ‘clear evidence of irregularity and inadequacy’ relating to ‘the shortcomings of their field work, assessment and biobanking approval conditions prior to commencement of the destruction of habitat’. This relates in particular to the impact on the Mitchell’s Rainforest Snail, which is the ‘first species to receive a Critical Habitat determination under the former NSW Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 and is listed… as a species that is “unable to withstand further loss”, including loss of habitat within its range’.

The endangered Mitchell’s rainforest snail.

Ongoing failures

The six-page document states that the failure ‘to adequately assess the environmental impacts of the protected Cumbebin Wetlands’ is the basis for ongoing failures throughout the process. This includes affecting the outcome of the NSW Land and Environment Court decision and both state and commonwealth approvals which CABS claim were based on ‘flawed and deficient data’.

If the importance of the habitat to the Mitchell’s Rainforest Snail had been recognised through effective fieldwork CABS state in the complaint that the bypass ‘would almost certainly have been stopped dead in its tracks’.

A bulldozer clears Malleleuca trees on the eastern side of Butler Street to make way for the Byron bypass. Image: Paul Bibby

Snail underpass

The underpass and biobanking solutions meant to compensate for the destruction of the snails’ habitat don’t adequately address the losses inflicted on the species by the building of the bypass, say CABS. They highlight that the 40m long concrete fauna underpass, that also doubles as a stormwater culvert, is likely to encourage predation of the snail owing to exposure, and that it lacks any natural ground cover. They further point out that Council’s solution, of placing logs and leaf litter in the culvert, will most likely be washed away in the first flood. 

CABS state that this is further compounded by the fact that the sites selected to offset the habitat losses of the snail ‘have not been demonstrated to contain the vegetation types associated with prime Mitchell’s Rainforest Snail habitat as claimed by their biobanking reports and public relations advertisements’. They also point out that there are no legislative or regulatory requirements for Council to ensure the commitments are carried out now or in perpetuity.

CABS are asking Council to secure additional land containing prime Mitchell’s Rainforest Snail habitat and set up stewardship agreements that would ensure the land is secured in perpetuity for the snail.

Council responded to questions on the issue stating that they ‘will not make any comment to The Echo on private correspondence’.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Well It has always been obvious where the focus of Byron council is, and has been for at least forty years, and it ain’t with no snail, or any environmental consideration that may stand between councillors and a bucket of money.
    The delights and horrors of the Gold Coast are the goal, and anything that stands in the way of casinos, property developers,whore-houses,bright lights and the playground for the idle-rich superanuated bludgers, won’t last long. The laughable strategy of “biobanking solutions” is ludicrous. I ask you how much habitat is intact along that coastline ? Blind Freddy can see that ANY remnant ecosystems in NSW are invaluable and must be preserved at any cost if there is to be any chance of surviving this age of the Great Extinction.
    However in the circumstances, where ocean levels will soon rise 66.6 meters as Greenland and Antarctica melt, it does become a moot point when the Lighthouse becomes the only visible ‘stranded asset’.
    Cheers, G”)

  2. Having returned to Wategos Beach after 31 years I for a moment thought I was having a flash back , same old pot holes everywhere, and still arguing about the bypass , whose land was purchased by 1989. Where have the billions in rates gone for 32 years , no signs of money spent , other than the Sydney barristers who now own some of the best houses courtesy of ceaseless multimillion dollar unsuccessful futile council litigation. ICAC fired the council General manager in 1996 for corruption , time for another investigation I fear!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Locals question placing homes in areas of inundation risk

It is where the community fought off Club Med and it is once again in the spotlight as the current owners, Elements, are seeking to have the zoning of the environmentally sensitive area in Bayshore Drive changed from tourism to residential

Go straight to the source on the Future Water Project

Rous County Council has announced a series of information days to be held this month where the community can ‘drop in’ and find out more about the revised draft Future Water Project 2060.

Free mental health workshop for Byron businesses

Business owners in Byron Shire are invited to attend a free 'Healthy Mindset' workshop aimed at providing them with resources and tools to improve mental health and wellbeing, as well as the opportunity to connect with other business owners.


Jillian Spring, Billinudgel In the article –  At a gathering of trainspotters, 21/4/21 by David Lisle, re Tweed Council Rail Trail, it is noted in...