18.6 C
Byron Shire
September 17, 2021

Bob Carr weighs in on Dunoon Dam debate

Latest News

Queensland passes voluntary assisted dying laws

Dying with Dignity NSW has welcomed the passage of Voluntary Assisted Dying (VAD) laws in Queensland and is hoping that NSW Parliament resumes next month so that this issue can be addressed in NSW without further delay.

Other News

First day out of lockdown – record high of NSW 1,599 new cases

NSW recorded yet another new record high 1,599 locally acquired cases of COVID-19 in the 24 hours to 8pm last night.

NRPP transparency questioned over controversial Evans Head Iron Gates development

Concerns have been raised over the transparency of the process of the Northern Rivers Planning Panel (NRPP), by which it reached a decision, in relation to the Iron Gates development in Evans Head, to ‘accept the amendment of the application under Clause 55 of the Environmental Planning & Assessment Regulations 2000’.

Local mum features in documentary about the impacts and possible solutions around suicide

Murwillumbah mum Ursula has lived every parents worst nightmare – her child, at the age of just 17, took his own life – and a lot of time and energy, questions and conjecture and finger-pointing can rumble around this, but at the end of the day Ursula’s precious boy is gone and he’s not coming back.

Cabarita Spirits – home of Soltera Rum

S Haslam How small-scale and personal do you need to get before you can be called a truly artisanal and...

Did NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian bow to media pressure?

After announcing last Friday that she would discontinue her daily press conference and the media backlash that followed, New South Wales Premier Gladys Berejiklian was back at her post at 11am today fronting the camera and question

New COVID venues of concern Lismore and Coraki

Following a second case being identified in Lismore, that is no longer in the area, several more COVID contact venues have been identified.

Bob Carr with Lismore MP Janelle Saffin at Terania Creek on the weekend. Photo supplied.

On Saturday the former Premier of NSW and former Australian Foreign Minister took a walk up Terania Creek, near The Channon.

Mr Carr is now Industry Professor at the Institute for Sustainable Futures UTS (Business and Climate Change). He was accompanied on the walk by a small group including Hugh and Nan Nicholson, Annie Kia of WATER Northern Rivers Alliance, and the Member for Lismore, Janelle Saffin.

Annie Kia said, ‘Yesterday’s walk to the Circle Pool in Terania was both good and sad. Good to walk with champions like Nan and Hugh Nicholson, who, with others, put their bodies on the line to save this extraordinary rainforest.

‘Good to walk with Bob Carr, who last did this walk last in 1986, having created the National Park as Environment Minister in the Wran government. A political leader who understands ecology. Good to walk with our local Member for Lismore Janelle Saffin, who is so very helpful. And to hear ecologist Rob Kooyman describe the Gondwanan lineages that live on in these forests.

Bob Carr with a burnt-out forest giant. Photo supplied.

‘The sad bit was seeing ancient, majestic giants that burned last year when the unthinkable happened, and fossil-fuelled fire came to the rainforest.’

Bob Carr visits proposed Dunoon Dam site

Yesterday Mr Carr also explored the area threatened by the proposed Dunoon Dam.

On Twitter he said, ‘In the Channon Gorge, crucial part of remaining 1 percent of Big Scrub rainforest. This area set to be demolished for Dunoon Dam is 6 percent of that remaining 1 percent.’

In another tweet Mr Carr said he was, ‘deep in the rainforest of Rocky Creek set to be flooded by Rous Council outside Lismore. Would fit Deputy Premier Barilaro strategy of Net Zero Koalas by 2050.’

On Facebook, the No Dunoon Dam Info group responded by saying, ‘We are very grateful that Bob Carr went into The Channon Gorge today, with Janelle Saffin the Member for Lismore.

‘When Bob heard that Big Scrub Rainforest was threatened, he wanted to come up here to see it. Bob gets the significance of this. When he was Environment Minister in the Wran government, he created the Nightcap National Park in 1983, and soon after walked with Hugh and Nan Nicholson to see the majestic rainforest his government had protected.

‘Yesterday he repeated that walk with Hugh and Nan to the Circle Pool in Terania to see impacts from unprecedented fires due to global warming.

Janelle Saffin with Bob Carr in the Channon Gorge. Photo supplied.

‘Today he came into The Channon Gorge, with Janelle. Warm thanks to both of them for their willingness to see this place first hand, and for their help.’

Time to ReThink Water?

WATER Northern Rivers Alliance is a community organisation representing six community groups.

They recently launched their website, with a statement from representative Simon Clough calling on Rous County Council to rethink water.

‘It’s time for Rous County Council to hit the pause button on its drive to approve construction of the huge Dunoon Dam,’ said Mr Clough.

‘Water security is a critical issue to industry, businesses and households, Australia’s peak water services association explicitly warns that new dams are “high risk investments”. Experts say water security is achieved by having a mix of supply options, including some that don’t need rain, such as purified recycled water, or green-powered desalination.’

Simon Clough. Photo Tree Faerie.

Mr Clough said the proposal for a new $240,000,000 dam on the same creek as the existing dam is going down the wrong track.

‘It will make our community vulnerable, not resilient because of the impacts of climate change. We need to heed what the experts are saying.’

Concerns remain

According to WATER Northern Rivers Alliance, major concerns about the dam have not changed since 1995 and 2014 when the dam was rejected.

Important Aboriginal heritage would be obliterated by flooding and the dam would destroy approximately 60 hectares of lowland rainforest, comprising 6% of the remaining 1% of the Big Scrub, unable to be replaced by environmental ‘offsets’.

Channon Gorge, threatened by proposed Dunoon Dam. Photo David Lowe.

The Alliance has called for Rous County Council to stop the dam and ReThink Water, based on what the Water Services Association of Australia and other experts recommend.

They say there should be public presentations from external experts on innovation in water management and site visits by engineers from Water Sensitive Cities projects such as Warrnambool Roof Water Harvesting.

They have also called for serious investigation of rainfall-independent projects, conducted by experts in these technologies.

‘We are at a crossroads,’ said Mr Clough. ‘We can expect worsening droughts as our climate heats up. We need to create a resilient water system, rather than adding to drought vulnerability with last century’s dam.

‘We are a very creative region. If we have the vision and commitment, we can create a water system fit for the 21st century’, he said.

Mr Clough urged people curious to learn more about alternatives to the Dunoon Dam to find how things got to this point, and why we need to ReThink Water.

More stories about the Dunoon Dam

Ballina mayor hopeful and Dunoon Dam advocate loses bid for new...

Cr Cadwallader said earlier this year she’d be running for mayor in the next local government elections and that water security, particularly the dumped Dunoon Dam proposal, would be one of her key campaign issues.


Cartoon of the week – 8 September, 2021

The deadline for the Byron Echo newspaper is noon Friday and letters longer than 200 words may be cut for the paper.


Dam it Dunoon!

Jen Ireland, The Channon It would seem that a dam at Dunoon is still on some people’s minds. It has actually been on a lot of people’s minds for a long time, and it is for this reason that it has...


Outdated dam greed

Léandra Martiniello, Whian Whian The ‘conservative progressives’ cry outdated greedy and destructive methods of supplying water to the people, driven by the colonial mentality (Dunoon Dam). I cry cultural genocide. The flooding of the graves of the ancestors of the Widjabul Wai-bul...


Widjabul Wia-bal and the Dunoon Dam

Those supporting the proposed Dunoon Dam seem to be living back in a time-warp of Terra Nullius.


Is population growth the real reason for the Dunoon Dam push?

It’s very clear that the State government’s push for population growth is the main driving force behind the proposed revisit of the Dunoon Dam


Independent assessment needed to determine use of Alstonville aquifers

The Save Alstonville Aquifer Group have raised concerns regarding the potential impact on the aquifer of making it part of the Rous County Council (RCC) IWCM (Integrated Water Cycle Management Plan). Chair of Rous County Council, Keith Williams has...


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. How ridiculous and unbelievable that sadly only 1% remains intact of the big scrub and yet, some people think we can off set this …HOW? The Channon Gorge is a magnificent area and many people put their bodies on the line to stop the logging of this rare & irreplaceable rainforest. Thank God (dess) Neville Wran was in power in the 80’s and created Nightcap NPark. Bob Carr was the best environment minister ( along with Bob Debus )this state has ever had. How tragic we have this useless & dangerous lot in parliament , what a sad contrast. Bob is right about Koalas being net zero by 2050, Thanks to Gladys & her team of ignorant eco vandals. What is sooooo damn hard to understand about the fact that this planet doesn’t need us but we sure NEED it??? By the way ‘media alert’ Koalas need trees & connectivity in order to survive, 2050 is a long way off .Koalas can’t wait that long.

    • The traditional owners cared for this beautiful country for thousands of years and western civilization has managed to destroy it in a few hundred. The anger, frustration and sadness from this ignorance, greed and stupidity is overwhelming. I can’t imagine how the ancestors of the Widjabal people and the Bundjalung nation must feel.

    • Bob Carr…. really echo?

      Bob instigated Public/Private Partnerships, like building motorways that are usually free but not once a PPP is involved, they add a toll. He was also in charge when Macquarie Bank bought Sydney airport. Bob could only wait 2 months after quitting politics to go and “work” for Macquarie bank. Guess who owns the speed camera vans in NSW? Hint – it’s not the NSW Govt but it is a bank!

      Labor and Libs are that close on major policies that seriously affect the livelihood of the masses and animals it’s laughable, as is the thinking that one set of politicians is better than the other.

      Nothing will change while vested interests fund political parties who in turn make policy in favour of the donors.

      Perhaps a fairdinkum party that only takes donations from the people, then they can do favours for the people!

  2. This dam makes NO sense whatsoever!!
    Use your brains Rous Water… think PLEASE…
    no big scrub left, no koalas left, no beautiful old trees… just more & more carnage!
    There are now so many alternatives available to use to supply us with water…
    Are we living in the 1800s?

  3. Creating Simon Clough’s water system fit for the 21st century could well be less expensive, but a number of influential people may have dibs on that quarter of a billion dollars so it might be a bit of a fight.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

A moment of your life?

Six questions for Jehovah’s Witness doorknockers: 1. Are you aware that the 2016 Royal Commission into Institutional Handling of Child Sexual Abuse investigated 1006 alleged...

Local mum features in documentary about the impacts and possible solutions around suicide

Murwillumbah mum Ursula has lived every parents worst nightmare – her child, at the age of just 17, took his own life – and a lot of time and energy, questions and conjecture and finger-pointing can rumble around this, but at the end of the day Ursula’s precious boy is gone and he’s not coming back.

The Greens and Ballina Council

With the Greens announcing their intention to contest the Ballina Shire local government election to be held in December this year, we can only...

New COVID venues of concern Lismore and Coraki

Following a second case being identified in Lismore, that is no longer in the area, several more COVID contact venues have been identified.