18.7 C
Byron Shire
September 21, 2021

Ballina changes tack on Dunoon Dam

Latest News

Long COVID and the science, so far…

Increasing COVID-19 vaccination rates as quickly as possible is currently a major focus for Australia.

Other News

Is all cannabis the same? How do its variations impact us?

Are you interested in learning more about the cannabinoids you use? Researchers from Monash University are asking both smokers and non-smokers to help research the variety of cannabinoids and their impacts.

Planning staff back Wilsons Creek DA, residents’ concerns downplayed

Residents living near a proposed 15-lot housing development in Wilsons Creek say it will negatively impact a precious wildlife corridor on the site, exacerbate traffic safety problems on the surrounding roads, and damage the peaceful character of their quiet enclave.

Hue and cry

Seeing and hearing all the kicking and screaming about our right to choose to not put on masks takes...

The Greens and Ballina Council

With the Greens announcing their intention to contest the Ballina Shire local government election to be held in December...

New COVID – casual contact location – BP Chinderah Southbound

NNSWLHD has been notified of a new casual contact venue visited by a confirmed case of COVID-19 who travelled between Sydney and Brisbane for work.

From Lismore XR to multi-faith ARRCC – now is the time for climate action

From XR to religious multi-faith networks the call is becoming stronger for real action on climate change.

Ballina Council meeting yesterday. Skype screenshot.

On the same day that it voted to write to the Prime Minister to change the date of Australia Day, Ballina Council has decided to reopen the Dunoon Dam debate, even though the project was stopped primarily on indigenous heritage grounds.

Yesterday’s motion was brought by Ballina’s Deputy Mayor Cr Sharon Cadwallader, with the support of Crs Eoin Johnston and Stephen McCarthy.

It called for Ballina Council to ‘send a clear message to Rous County Council that Council has major concerns about a secure water strategy for the region and ask that Rous County Council continue with further investigations as to the viability of the Dunoon Dam proposal.’

The motion also noted that groundwater on the Alstonville Plateau ‘has many demands on it and should not be relied upon as a major source of supply.’

Ballina council staff noted that a similar motion was lost at the last meeting.

Fear and doubt?

Bianca Urbina from Water Northern Rivers Alliance. Photo David Lowe.

Bianca Urbina from WATER Northern Rivers Alliance spoke against the motion, which she said was seeking to divide the community. ‘It is capitalising on fear and using the same strategy that Trump used in the United States.’

She said it was ‘aggravating through misinformation, creating false dichotomies and pitching one community against another instead of moving forward, and it is not in the true spirit of Ballina Shire.’

Ms Urbina reminded councillors that the Dunoon Dam had been rejected twice as it would be ‘criminal to proceed with the destruction of Widjabul Wia-bal cultural heritage, and a rare ecological community.’

There was also a deposition from former Ballina Mayor and former Rous Chair Phillip Silver, who spoke strongly in favour of the dam and against over-reliance on underground aquifers.

Traditional owners present

Uncle Roy Gordon with his daughter Waylard. Photo Tree Faerie.

Present in the Ballina council chamber were ten Bundjalung people, including several elders, amongst them traditional owner Uncle Roy Gordon.

Rous Chair and Ballina Cr Keith Williams told Echonetdaily, ‘I have never seen so many indigenous people attend a council meeting.’

He said that while most councillors acknowledged those present when they spoke, ‘no one really addressed the opposition from the traditional custodians.’

Cr Cadwallader said, ‘Having access to a safe secure water supply for our communities is the biggest most important issue that this council and our three neighbouring councils are facing today.

‘Being able to turn the tap on, fill a glass of water and drink it, cook with it and shower is of paramount importance,’ she said.

Sheer madness

Cr Cadwallader said it was ‘sheer madness’ not to keep all options on the table, including the dam, before studies were completed and data gaps filled.

‘The time has come for us to unite and send a clear message to RCC that we are worried about not having enough water for daily living without water restrictions. And that is where we are heading,’ she said.

Ballina Deputy Mayor Sharon Cadwallader. Photo David Lowe.

‘Our region is the wettest in the state with five times the the state’s annual rainfall. It is common sense to collect it!

‘Cost is a major consideration as well with the dam proposal being the lowest cost option,’ said Cr Cadwallader.

‘Families need to have enough money to to send their kids off to school with a good breakfast instead of spending their money on unnecessary water charges.’

She described desalination as the most expensive option, and said ‘the other options including groundwater and toilet to tap will cost an estimated $600M more than building a dam.’

Cr Cadwallader said that the region was looking at a water shortfall by 2060 of ‘5,630 Olympic swimming pools each year’ and said there was not enough definitive data about the Marom Creek aquifer to know if it could be relied upon as a major source of water.

Scare campaign?

Cr Jeff Johnson told Echonetdaily, ‘Cr Cadwallader is clearly running a scare campaign in her effort to keep the Dunoon Dam on the agenda.

Cr Jeff Johnson. Photo David Lowe.

‘There are such a myriad of options available that need further investigation that don’t rely on regular rainfall in a certain catchment area,’ he said.

‘For example the Warrnambool Roof Water Harvesting project has been government funded as a demonstration project to show how an increase in population (new buildings) can actually take pressure off the existing water supply by pumping rainwater into the catchment areas of the existing water storage areas.’

Cr Johnson said there was a ‘huge opportunity’ for similar initiatives in the Rous catchment area.

‘I’m hoping that Rous won’t just rely on ground water and that other options that reduce existing water runoff into our wetlands and other water ways are examined further.’

Cr Johnson said the only result of a scare campaign on water would be delays in further investigation of good alternatives.

The view from Alstonville

Cr Eoin Johnston voted for Cr Cadwallader’s motion to reconsider the Dunoon Dam. Citing a 2019 report from the NSW Chief Scientist, he told Echonetdaily that he opposed taking any more water from the plateau as the data on the groundwater source was inconclusive.

Cr Eoin Johnston. Photo supplied.

‘Rous Water claims to have determined accurately what is down there but that information, to my knowledge, has not been shared with the State Government.

‘The report states that bore water extraction can potentially impact water within the same aquifer, within a connected aquifer or within a connected surface water body, leading to changes in water quantity and quality,’ said Cr Johnston.

‘The concept of increasing water extraction from the Alstonville plateau to meet growing demands elsewhere should be rejected,’ he said.

‘The farmers and urban residents of the plateau must not be left high and dry when we live in an area with the highest rainfall in the state.’

Rous Chair and Ballina Cr Keith Williams responds

Cr Williams told Echonetdaily, ‘The Groundwater Strategy was fully laid out as an alternative in the Rous IWCM documentation and provides secure water supply beyond 2060.

‘Sharon claimed the Dam was $600 million cheaper. I pointed out the documented whole of life costs over 80 yrs were $650m v $900m. Much of that cost would be increased employment. This is not necessarily a bad thing.’

In response to the ongoing claims that not building the Dunoon Dam would put more pressure on the Alstonville aquifer, Cr Williams said, ‘The plans to upgrade the Marom Creek treatment plant and better utilise existing licences was to occur prior to the building of the dam and the plans are unchanged.

Rous County Council Chair Keith Wiliams. Photo David Lowe.

‘The upgrades would actually reduce demand on the Alstonville aquifer by sinking bores to a different aquifer at a much deeper level,’ he said.

Indigenous voices need to be heard

After the meeting, Cr Williams expressed his disappointment with the debate, saying the traditional owners have made it very clear they don’t wish to participate in another Cultural Heritage assessment.

‘They have clearly stated their opposition to the Dunoon Dam and remain resolute,’ he said.

‘There is no doubt the proposal is likely to subject to vigorous legal challenges on environmental and heritage issues.

‘I honestly believe the dam, whatever its virtues, will not be able to be built. Putting all our eggs in that basket becomes an increasingly risky strategy. We have viable alternatives,’ said Cr Williams.

Ballina first?

At the meeting there was also a separate motion brought by Cr Phillip Meehan (with amendments supported by Crs Nathan Willis and Sharon Parry) for Ballina to consider an independent water strategy to Rous County Council, with greater use of local water resources locally.

Rocky Creek Dam treatment plant. Photo supplied.

In response, Cr Keith Williams said ‘Ballina should not and could not consider going it alone. We are part of Rous and that is what guarantees our water security. 90% of Ballina’s water is drawn from Rocky Creek Dam.’

Although the Meehan motion and its amendments were lost, Cr Cadwallader’s motion succeeded, with the support of Crs Eoin Johnston, Stephen McCarthy, Ben Smith, and Phil Meehan.

Surprisingly, Cr Sharon Parry also voted in favour of the motion (although she said she was opposed to the Dunoon Dam), saying she wanted more data.

The next meeting of Rous County Council, which will consider a rescission motion on the Dunoon Dam, will take place on 17 February.


More stories about the Dunoon Dam

Ballina mayor hopeful and Dunoon Dam advocate loses bid for new...

Cr Cadwallader said earlier this year she’d be running for mayor in the next local government elections and that water security, particularly the dumped Dunoon Dam proposal, would be one of her key campaign issues.

4

Cartoon of the week – 8 September, 2021

The deadline for the Byron Echo newspaper is noon Friday and letters longer than 200 words may be cut for the paper.

0

Dam it Dunoon!

Jen Ireland, The Channon It would seem that a dam at Dunoon is still on some people’s minds. It has actually been on a lot of people’s minds for a long time, and it is for this reason that it has...

1

Outdated dam greed

Léandra Martiniello, Whian Whian The ‘conservative progressives’ cry outdated greedy and destructive methods of supplying water to the people, driven by the colonial mentality (Dunoon Dam). I cry cultural genocide. The flooding of the graves of the ancestors of the Widjabul Wai-bul...

0

Widjabul Wia-bal and the Dunoon Dam

Those supporting the proposed Dunoon Dam seem to be living back in a time-warp of Terra Nullius.

10

Is population growth the real reason for the Dunoon Dam push?

It’s very clear that the State government’s push for population growth is the main driving force behind the proposed revisit of the Dunoon Dam

10

Independent assessment needed to determine use of Alstonville aquifers

The Save Alstonville Aquifer Group have raised concerns regarding the potential impact on the aquifer of making it part of the Rous County Council (RCC) IWCM (Integrated Water Cycle Management Plan). Chair of Rous County Council, Keith Williams has...

3


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

9 COMMENTS

  1. I said it then. I say it again. BIG MISTAKE allowing Ballina onto Rous circa 1989. After refusing the option to be part of the original council and bear in the cost, Ballina said NO. Then circa 1989 was allowed to buy in for a PALTRY 8 million. Further Cadwaller, deliberately or in ignorance, fails to cite future water shortages only can occur with significantvpopulation increase and no additional supply. Increasing population federally and locally as an economic stimulus is treated as sacrosanct when in fact it is madness, especially in quality of life. Anyone making more beach?

  2. That is a great point of Sharon Cadwallader’s: “Our region is the wettest in the state with five times the the state’s annual rainfall. It is common sense to collect it!” I agree wholeheartedly. However, all that rainfall needs to be collected by each development to provide for itself and be paid for by the developer. Trashing Aboriginal heritage and irreplaceable environmental assets in the hinterland is unacceptable when Ballina lets all the water it needs just run away.

  3. Cr Cadwallader is just towing the state government line of building dams and endless population growth. Being a member of the Nationals she should be more transparent with her motivations. The fact of the matter is that this area, along with the rest of Australia, have poor water management practices. If new and stricter water management protocols were introduced to households and businesses this would mitigate the need for a new dam. Along with other sustainability measures such as water recycling, which have been outlined in reports by Professor Stuart White from UTS, it would prevent the need for a new dam and act as insurance for the next drought which is inevitable. Unfortunately I believe this is another case of conservatives pushing political and ideological agendas at the expense of the environment and the traditional owners.

    • Please check your facts before commenting. I am not a member of the National Party and am not towing any state government line. This is above politics . It is about the best most cost effective option of making sure our communities have enough water for daily living without water restrictions.

      • Well Councillor, didn’t you renew your membership after your failed attempts at preselection as a Nationals candidate? You obviously have views in line with the National Party and who is to say that you aren’t considering attempting it again with another party? There are already plenty of studies proving that alternatives are viable. There is also plenty of opposition from the community and local indigenous elders. Have you spoken to Mickey Ryan or anyone else from the Bundjalung elders council? We live in a unique environment that we should be trying to protect so why not show a bit of leadership like Cr Williams and make a stand to try and protect it and for once respect the wishes of the traditional owners. To say we need more studies completed is just another way of you saying that you don’t agree with previous studies and you are waiting for ones that are in line with your opinion. Finally, to address your point about it being more cost effective, there are numerous studies proving that dams are not cost effective and maintenance costs can blow out exponentially. They are also not water efficient. I think it is ‘sheer madness’ to want to go ahead with a dam at Dunoon given the declining state of the environment, the unique biodiversity at risk, the significant indigenous sites that will be lost and the evidence for viable alternatives.

  4. Councillor Cadwallader is actually out of touch with her state National Party colleagues who, by and large, have come to understand that dams are not reliable when it comes to drought-proofing urban water supplies. This has been clear for some time. Nor does she appear to have been paying attention to the details of the deep aquifer exploration, which would remove Rous’s competition with other users of the shallow Alstonville aquifer, and actually reduce demand on it! The management of all of this, of course, is overseen by the Water Minister, Melinda Pavey, in whom Ms. Cadwallader seems to have little trust, but whose department DOES understand water options and water security.
    Given Ms. Cadwallader’s previous support , in actually moving adoption, of the Rous Future Water Plan which included the groundwater options that she now claims to be so concerned about, it seems she either hasn’t reading and listening, OR she is engaged in some mischievous council pre-election campaigning.

  5. Ha. the ocean is available. When the ocean is available for conversion to fresh water, it makes a laughing stock of Ballina Council.
    The NSW state government have legislation in place to protact koala habitat.

  6. Who do these councillors think they are? The Dam is not happening, spend your time doing your job and representing your community’s wishes instead of blindly toeing a party line and work towards a sustainable water solution for the region’s future. Talk about out of touch.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

ScoMo does it again

ScoMo recently travelled from the ACT to Sydney, not something to be recommended at the moment. What is an essential worker? Surely someone paying 50...

Teacher survey

The Echo’s survey of local teachers regarding vaccination was as illuminating as it was disappointing. One respondent popped their head out the rabbit hole...

10pm Monday – update of COVID venues of concern

The Northern NSW Local Health District has been notified of a number of venues of concern associated with confirmed cases of COVID-19 in the region.

A new COVID-19 case flies into the Far North Coast

The Northern NSW Local Health District has confirmed that there is a new case of COVID-19 in Northern NSW today, and they will be included in NSW Health’s official reporting tomorrow.