16.1 C
Byron Shire
August 3, 2021

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: When it’s the Law that is Crazy

Latest News

Railway and rail trail working together

Chris Abraham, Mullumbimby Creek The rail service between Casino and Murwillumbah was suspended by the NSW Government without any public...

Other News

The Block mute over its plans for Byron TV show

Plans by reality television TV show, The Block (Nine), to base an upcoming series on  Sunrise Boulevard in Sunrise, Byron Bay, has upset an elderly neighbour.

Shooting in Nimbin

There is a police operation currently underway in Nimbin following a shooting earlier today.

Open-air art walk by the river at Murwillumbah completed

The Ages of the Tweed mural that accompanies the open-air riverside art walk has now been completed.

New digs for Bangalow Lions Club

After 30 years of using a makeshift shed at the Bangalow Showground for their bar and barbecue, the Bangalow Lions Club have opened their newly constructed Lions Kiosk.

Byron’s bioenergy facility DA

David Dixon, Byron Bay I am concerned Council’s bioenergy project has received no external financial scrutiny and that my requests for...

To kill all Jews? No…

Subhi Awad, Mullumbimby With respect to Wakil and Macklin (Letters, 21 July) the assertion that the Palestinian resistance wants to kill...

Britney Spears

Imagine losing agency over your life decisions. That’s what happened to Britney Spears. For 13 years this woman, capable of generating personal assets around $US60 million, has lived under the rule of a court-appointed conservatorship (Aus version is a guardianship) that placed her father in charge of her life decisions.

This is a story played out in the public eye that reminds us of how vulnerable people can be who have lived experience of mental illness. I remember reading the story of Frances Farmer and thinking ‘That kind of institutionalisation and cruelty could only happen in the 1950s’. But no, people with disabilities are at risk of having legal arrangements put in place that remove their control, even today.

And of course, if you want to challenge those controls, you have to endure psychological testing. I don’t know about you, but if I had to sit in front of a panel of strangers to assess whether I was able to control my finances or have my contraceptive device removed, I think I’d lose the plot. I’d swear. I’d be angry. I’d cry. I’d beg. I’d threaten them. I might even knock over furniture. This would be triggered by the injustice and the sense of powerlessness. Then they’d say: ‘Yep. She’s crazy’.

How does anyone maintain their ‘sanity’ in such an insane scenario? It’s gaslighting of the highest calibre. I would say that if you approached an assessment like that –without losing it – then possibly you weren’t in charge of your mental health to begin with. A person should be outraged. A sane person would fight.

This is hard enough played out on a small stage for people with no public profile. I can’t imagine the sense of shame and humiliation this poor woman must feel to have had her life sprawled in front of the media, for more than a decade. The fact her father would happily have her out working – earning more money in a year than most would earn in a lifetime, says something about his mentality.

Her Britney: Piece of Me ran for four years at the Planet Hollywood Resort and Casino, grossing around $138million over 250 shows. Seems like everyone really did get a piece of Britney. Except Britney. That’s a pretty major accomplishment for someone considered not able to manage her own affairs.

The world has sat by and watched a woman be completely exploited, bullied and shamed. Her breakdown in 2008 became the butt of so many jokes on social media. Magazines scrambled for photos of her painful downward spiral. There was certainly a bizarre sense of media titillation in Spears’ story.

So at 39, when she wants to get married again and have a baby – she is not allowed to go to the doctor to have her contraceptive device removed. She is not allowed to make decisions over her own body, but she can stand on stage in Vegas and show her body to generate millions of dollars that she can’t access. She has been forced to perform. She is forced to take lithium. She is forced to do therapy against her will.

How can a woman under this amount of psychological distress be properly assessed?

I watched a story on a breakfast TV show where the hosts attempted empathy. They said ‘She appears to be compos mentis’. I guess that’s how it goes. Is this legal version of institutionalisation considered okay for a person with a mental illness? Shouldn’t a person with lived experience of mental illness be allowed agency over their own body? Over their own income? Over their own choices? Britney’s story shows the real risk of manipulation and coercion that people with disabilities can face from those in their life who feel they should be controlled.

What an incredible survivor Britney Spears is. I had no idea. I don’t know many compos mentis folk who would have endured what she has endured. The fact she’s still here is testament to her strength. It’s a crazy story. But she’s not crazy. The law is fucking crazy.

Maybe the people should get a conservatorship over that?


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

4 COMMENTS

  1. “Imagine losing agency over your life decisions.”

    Yes, imagine someone other than you, dictating what you should wear, where you should and shouldn’t go, who and how many people you can have visit, how you must use your mobile phone to “check in” with QR codes and undergo a medical procedure to keep your job. Hmmm…

    • Wha????!!!! So driving on the right side of the road and stopping at red lights are impinging on your life decisions?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Fifteen arrested in Brisbane protest

Police say they have arrested fifteen people following protest activity in Brisbane CBD this morning.

South East Queensland lockdown continues for another five days

Queensland Health has issued a statement that says the current lockdown in South East Queensland will continue for another five days as a precaution following new cases in the state.

Pennings and Adani to continue court battle

The Supreme Court has formalised orders agreed out of court by both Adani and Ben Pennings in relation to a decision handed down on 25 June 2021.

Can you help save 74 million lives?

Killer carbon – a new study has coined another metric for estimating the damage inflicted by climate change – this time, looking at the ‘mortality cost of carbon’.