21.1 C
Byron Shire
January 28, 2022

Onsite build of manufactured homes in South Tweed deferred

Latest News

Two deaths in Northern Rivers in previous 24 hours, 29 across the state

There were another two deaths reported in the Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWHD) to  8pm 26 January with 44 people in hospital and five in ICU.

Other News

More government support needed for nurses

What would it take to keep our nurses and paramedics from resigning en masse as the current crisis in the NSW health care system worsens?

NRAS about to kick off 2022 adoption days

Local animal charity Northern Rivers Animal Services has kicked off 2022 with a bang, with more cats, kittens and puppies needing homes in Ballina than you can shake a rescuer at.

Children: to vax or not to vax?

With the option to vaccinate 5–11-year-olds now available, The Echo took the time to talk to local Byron Shire Dr Joel Hissink about vaccinating children.

Editorial – Fake, fumbling and fabricated

Morrison’s incompetence, however, is epic; it seems to derive from his belief that God has appointed him to rule in these end times, so that it is impossible for him to be wrong.

Lismore Citizen of the Year 

Recognising her tireless work in helping people living with Parkison’s Disease Di Lymbury was awarded Lismore Citizen of the Year. 


In another room now Somewhere… Somehow… Move again in five days’ time. Getting used to the rhythm. Getting used to the rhyme. Huge...

Mayor Cherry and Cr Milne argued moved an amendment to reject the onsite building of manufactured homes on site.

Correction 23 July: The variation was deferred not refused.

The estimated $13,800,000 manufactured home development (DA17/0358.01) slated for 30 Fraser Drive, Tweed Heads South was seeking a variation to its development consent to allow the building of the manufactured homes onsite rather than offsite as required by the legislation.

Three options were put forward by Tweed Shire Council staff 1. to support the construction of the manufactured estate on site, 2. To support it with some specific sites excluded and 3. to refuse the request.

Allow them to build

Councillor Warren Polglase (Conservative) proposed that council allow the manufactured homes to be built on site. This was seconded by Councillor Pryce Allsop (Conservative).

Crs Polglase and Allsop argued for allowing the manufactured homes to be built onsite.

Councillor Polglase argued that with the big demand for these types of homes that they should allow it to happen onsite. He also noted that the council had previously allowed manufactured homes to be built onsite at the caravan park at Banora because they couldn’t get the trucks with the houses on them under the bridges.

Refuse onsite construction

However, Mayor Chris Cherry (Independent) argued against allowing the houses to be built on site and moved an amendment that supported the third staff recommendation that the council refuse the onsite construction. This motion was seconded by Councillor Katie Milne (Greens).

‘I think we obviously we do need this kind of home estate to be built and I do support it. But the legislation there for a reason, to protect the amenity of residents,’ said Mayor Cherry.

Speaking against the amendment by Crs Cherry and Milne, Cr Allsop argued that by not having them constructed onsite that they may be losing jobs for locals in Tweed.

‘I guess we are going to have people potentially constructing these homes outside of Tweed, maybe in Queensland,’ he told the meeting.

‘I just think there is a lot more potential for construction on the site [for] local jobs. There will be cost impacts by bringing in large trucks. There will be a lot less impacts and a lot less issues with the site being a development site and not bringing in big trucks that will be manoeuvring on that road.’

Councillor Milne spoke in favour of the amendment and rejecting the onsite building of the manufactured home telling the meeting that there is ‘law in place that these things should be constructed off site. We should only veer away from that if that is warranted.’


‘They haven’t done enough work. Cr Allsop may be right in regards to the jobs but he might not be right. There just hasn’t been enough evidence to say we should veer away from this. What is the alternative impact? We need a more substantial justification than “this will just be better”. They do not want to transport to the site because it must be more financially beneficial. They know that they are supposed to be manufactured off site. They should have gone into the detail like Cr Allsop suggested… but they haven’t.’

Other concerns raised were the impact on existing residents of the drawn out onsite building process and the fact that ‘some of the neighbouring residents are only four meters away’ according to Mayor Cherry.

Cr Allsop then foreshadowed the amendment by Cherry and Milne to defer the vote to seek further information.

Council resolved that council defers this item and seeks further advice on the justification to build onsite including but not limited to comparative analysis of on-/off-site build in regards to the size of trucks, crane required, where the manufactured home will be purchased and supplied from, can they build in one location on site and move to final position? number of movements for off site build and estimated time for on site construction.

The matter will be brought back to the 5 August council meeting for a final decision.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. “Polglase Conservative”?
    Is it not far more appropriate to state clearly that Warren Polglase is or was Tweed National party chairman and former National party campaign manager for the 3 times failed federal National party candidate at the last federal election?
    We have a council election coming up and these candidates should stand on their real party and voting record!
    Many Tweed residents are amazed there is not strict legislation demanding transparency and real accountability of council election candidates, decades of long term political party affiliations? Other candidates Labor and Greens are proud of their party affiliations.
    Actually I believe that any member of any other political parties standing as a candidate, as anything other than an endorsed party member would mean automatic dismissal?
    Why do residents always have to notice this tendency of the Nationals every election. always attempting to obscure their membership and long standing party affiliations at election time?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Vaccinating koalas against chlamydia

Koala chlamydia affects 60 per cent of koalas that are admitted to the Currumbin Wildlife Hospital and is having a significant impact on koalas in the region. The figures have continued to rise each year.

Lismore Citizen of the Year 

Recognising her tireless work in helping people living with Parkison’s Disease Di Lymbury was awarded Lismore Citizen of the Year. 

RAT upcycling available in Mullum

Most of us have been far more concerned about how to get hold of rapid antigen tests (RATs) over the past few months than what happens to the plastic testing kits after use.

Bill will not prevent social media trolling: Law Council

The nation’s peak law advocay legal body, The Law Council of Australia, is calling for a nationally consistent approach to law reform as ‘the best defence against social media defamation’.