16 C
Byron Shire
May 29, 2022

Labor MP calls Greens election ad ‘untruthful and misleading’

Latest News

Primex Sustainable Farming and Primary Industries Expo new date confirmed

After being postponed due to the flooding and ongoing wet weather the 2022 Primex Sustainable Farming and Primary Industries Expo and will now go ahead on November 10–12.

Other News

Corporate beach

Tallow Beach is a great place to walk your dog and it has got a lot busier over the...

Incarceration Nation screens as part of Reconciliation Week

As part of Reconciliation Week (May 27 to June 3), Sisters for Reconciliation and the Cavanbah Reconciliation group will host a screening and discussion of the powerful documentary, Incarceration Nation.

Action after the flood: Mullum residents discuss flooding

Mullumbimby Residents Association (MRA) held a public meeting at the Ex-Services Club on May 16, and with approximately 150 attending it exceeded expectations.

Recalcitrant dogs

I could be a lot richer collecting $1 from all those who have told me to ‘get f****ed’ with...

Reactivating Lismore with markets

Lismore CBD is about to receive a boost with two of its largest markets coming to Lismore’s CBD to help reactivate local economy and sense of community. 

Entertainment in the Byron Shire for the week beginning 25 May, 2022

The Jezabels The Jezabels are on a national tour to celebrate the 10th Anniversary of their multi-award winning Gold Album Prisoner. For the first time, the...

Federal Member for Richmond, Justine Elliot. Photo supplied.

Last week’s election ad placed in The Echo by Greens candidate, Mandy Nolan, has been described as ‘untruthful and misleading to voters in the Richmond electorate’, by sitting Labor MP, Justine Elliot.

Two claims by Ms Nolan have been refuted by Ms Elliot, namely: ‘we’ve had the same backbencher for 17 years’, and ‘Labor just approved 114 new coal and gas mines’.

As for the ‘backbencher’ claim, Ms Elliot told The Echo, ‘I was privileged to serve as Minister for Ageing in the first term of the Labor government, becoming Parliamentary Secretary for Trade after the 2010 election’.

‘I resigned from the later appointment to devote all my time and energy to our community campaign to stop the Nationals’ plan for harmful coal-seam gas mining on the North Coast – a campaign we won’.

As for the claim of Labor approving ‘114 new coal and gas mines’, Ms Elliot said, ‘Ministers in governments approve mining projects, not the Parliament. Federal Labor has not been in government since 2013. This claim is a blatant lie’.

Deliberate lies

Ms Elliot added, ‘Our elections are robust, and we have diverse views and candidates in our region, but Mandy Nolan’s deliberate lies show that the Greens are as untrustworthy as Scott Morrison’.

‘It is disappointing that Mandy Nolan is deliberately misrepresenting and attempting to erase another woman’s achievements. Women have fought long and hard to achieve representation and a voice in Parliament’.

AAP FactCheck concluded that the Greens claim was ‘mostly true’ regarding 114 coal and gas projects in Australia’s investment pipeline ‘which, if completed, would produce emissions estimated to be more than double the current domestic carbon emissions of Australia’. AAP say, ‘However, there is uncertainty in the calculation of the potential emissions and emissions from exported fossil fuels’.

In reply to Ms Elliot, Ms Nolan pointed to state and territory Labor governments (and oppositions) who are supporting new coal and gas projects.

‘I don’t know what planet the member for Richmond is on’, says Ms Nolan.

‘It’s like being on the backbench magically excuses her from the decisions of her party. I don’t buy it, and the electorate doesn’t either’.

‘Our electorate is the second most at risk from climate change in the country. We’ve just experienced devastating flooding right across the electorate. You can’t fight the climate crisis while you’re pouring fuel on the fire. That’s why we need people like me on the crossbench, to push Labor further and faster on climate. I can do that because I’m not beholden to coal and gas donors’.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Yea a vote for Mandy is a vote to retain the coalition. Remember the greens voted with the coalition on a number of times including sinking a carbon trading scheme in the name of purity. Voting green makes you feel better if the coalition gets in as you can say it wasn’t my fault I voted green.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Reasons to be cheerful

After nine long years of being led by the least among us, Australia’s future feels optimistic. Thanks, Western Australia, you were instrumental in booting those numpties out! 

Regrets for treatment of Wardell CORE?

After Ballina Council's recent decision, at its Finance and Facilities Committee Meeting, to effectively evict the Wardell Community Organised Resilience Effort (CORE) from the War Memorial Hall, in mid-flood recovery, some were having second thoughts at their Ordinary Meeting yesterday.

Keep your eyes and ears open for Albert’s Lyrebird

Tweed Council is asking that you put your best bird listening ears on this June and capture the sounds of a rare bird.

Progress at Ross Lane?

The perennial question 'is Ross Lane open?' edged closer to an answer yesterday, with Ballina Council discussing a range of options to solve the flooding problem which regularly cuts off Lennox's main access to the west. Ross Lane has been closed again this week.