13.2 C
Byron Shire
July 6, 2022

Elliot’s still sore

Latest News

Taqueria in Byron celebrates four years

Chupacabra Mexican restaurant in Suffolk Park is turning four this week! Through the ups and downs of the past...

Other News

Attempt to manage Byron’s fragile coastline impeded by State Government, report finds

Insufficient funding and guidance from the State Government is inhibiting Byron Council's attempt to effectively manage its famous but fragile coastline, a Council report has revealed.

Destruction of Brunswick Heads mahogany

The foulest crime against the planet was committed secretly in the heart of Brunswick Heads during the pandemic lockdown....

Koori Mail wins NAIDOC Week award

Local media outlet and responder to the February and March floods, the Koori Mail was honoured at the annual National NAIDOC Week Awards held on Narrm Country on Saturday evening.

Dry July to help you and Our House

In July 2008, three mates, Brett, Kenny and Phil, wanted to take a break from alcohol, so decided to abstain for the month of July, coining it their 'Dry July'.

Australia Anti-Nuclear Delegation

We are delighted to share the news that Australia will attend the first Meeting of State Parties to the...

Scandalous Council

How much of these pro-developer actions by Council are we supposed to put up with? Council give away land...

You (The Echo), rightly so, have a dig (in Backlash) at right-wing media outlets for mindless repetition of discredited ‘talking points’, but then you run a ‘story’ (50 per cent press release direct from Justine Elliot’s office?) in which Elliot trots out that tired old disingenuous dig at the Greens for not supporting Labor’s CPRS back in 2009, ‘which then led to a decade of inaction on climate change’, she claims.

The comment was barely relevant to the story, and it’s just wrong. Why help them to keep their self-serving lies alive? To provide balance to the Labor party propaganda printed without proviso, here’s an edited version of the Greens’ account:

In 2009, the Greens voted against the CPRS because it would have locked in inaction on climate change. According to Treasury modelling, under the CPRS there would have been no reduction in emissions for 25 years! Taking us up to the mid-2030s… funny that… But the big polluters would all have got to wave faux-green happy flags in the meantime and pretend they’d done something to address the issue, and they would have made a profit from doing nothing because the CPRS gave billions in handouts to coal companies and big polluters while locking in emissions targets that actually failed the science. And they’re still failing with this ‘43 per cent reduction by 2030’ talk.

Worse still, under the 2009 CPRS, any future attempt to strengthen the scheme would have resulted in billion-dollar compensation payouts to the big polluters. Even Rudd’s own climate change advisor said it could be better to start over.

In 2010, just a few months after the Greens voted against the 2009 CPRS, they worked with the Gillard government to introduce world-leading climate legislation. The Greens-led package put a price on carbon that worked to reduce emissions, it established the Clean Energy Finance Corporation and the Australian Renewable Energy Agency.

The carbon price was working – and it set a world-leading example since adopted in other countries – until the Abbott government told porky-pies (calling it a ‘carbon tax’), ran a massive scare campaign, and tore it down. That’s why nothing has been done. Not because of the Greens’ actions in 2009, which stopped Labor from getting away with green-washing, but because Labor and the coalition have continued to take donations from the big polluters and because they keep pretending we have decades up our sleeve to act decisively on climate change.

A Campbell, Rosebank

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Yep and left Labor hung out to dry, resulting in almost a decade of coalition denial and confusion. Come on, voting with the Tories showed how politically pure the greens thought they were.

  2. You really can’t take these Greens seriously they would rival One Nation and that crazy Qld redhead for opportunism, grandstanding and hypocrisy, their successes are as rare as hens teeth; they now hold four seats in the House of Reps and it seems to have immediately gone to their heads. They are really no closer to ever forming any sort of Govt with anyone; their only ever claim to fame was when they coerced Julia Gillard’s minority Govt into breaking an election promise and introducing a carbon tax. The Greens can spin it as much as possible but it was always going to fail because Julia had no mandate and just gave the Coalition all the ammunition it needed to bring down her Govt. The Greens will now struggle to maintain their 12.3% election result because we now have a Labor majority Govt that is serious about tackling climate change and the Greens will be less relevant. And after securing a clear majority of the vote the Labor Party does not need any lecturing from the Greens, and nor does Justine Elliott need advice on how to best represent her constituents in Richmond, she has been doing that very successfully since 2004 when she booted out the Nationals.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Celebrating 40 years of Fig Tree Restaurant

It all started with a simple dream, to convert its original farmhouse in Ewingsdale into a restaurant in which its guests could gather to...

Crabbes Creek Woodfired

By V. Cosford There’s a contingent of Europeans who don’t mind travelling a considerable distance in order to stock up on Jon and Gina Hutton’s...

Stone & Wood’s Brewery Festival Returns

Stone & Wood are opening the gates to their Murwillumbah brewery with the return of their ‘Murbah Open Day’, on Saturday 6 August. Welcoming the...

Decades of volunteering earn prestigious NSW Sports Award

Brenda Zakaras and John Beasley from Lennox Head were two of 19 sports volunteers from a wide cross-section of sports who received a Distinguished...