13.2 C
Byron Shire
July 7, 2022

Opinion: Where’s the action on public housing?

Latest News

Value of the intangible and Suffolk Parks future

It’s hard to know what value to place on the environment – until it changes irrevocably.  A place is defined...

Other News

Trees Not Bombs gone but not forgotten

On Friday evening the space that was home for the Trees Not Bombs recovery café stood empty of its tent, pots and pans, makeshift kitchen sink and cups of tea and cake, but the most noticeable absence was the smiles and support of the volunteers.

Letters to the editor

The Echo loves your letters and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most...

Community members needed for health advisory groups

Northern NSW Local Health District (NNSWLHD) is seeking expressions of interest from community members to join health advisory groups.

The ‘Court of Public Opinion’

The corona investigative committee is moving forward. Time is needed to assimilate the proceedings of this very important investigation,...

Farmers: flood rebuild vital for regional survival

An increase in federal government funding to rebuild businesses in Lismore has been welcomed by the state’s peak farming body, but it remains concerned about vital job losses.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: To Hall and Back

There is something magical about a country hall. These small wooden buildings dot the landscape. They have a frugal modesty and an old fashioned generosity. If they had names they’d be called Thelma or Rose or Alan. They’re a pungent olfactory mix of last week’s wedding enmeshed with yesterday’s committee meeting. Curry and Jatz, tea and beer, tears and laughter.

During his victory speech, newly-crowned PM Anthony Albanese reflected on his journey from a childhood growing up in ‘public housing down the road in Camperdown’ to the top political leadership position in the country, saying he hopes it ‘inspires Australians to reach for the stars’.

However, in a social media post a few days later, Action for Public Housing (APH) displayed a photo of the premises that Albanese grew up in, outlining that when the prime minister was born, governments nationwide were building 10,000 public homes a year for a population of 11 million.

‘For all the new PM’s talk about growing up in public housing and the vital support it provided him and his mum, he has no plan to extend that same support to people who need it today,’ the housing advocacy group claimed.

Indeed, federal Labor’s policy platform notes that ‘there are more Australians renting, and renting for longer’ and ‘more people experiencing homelessness than ever before’, but when it comes down to it the new government’s priority is making homeownership more affordable.

As Sydney public housing defender Andrew Chuter points out, when Labor’s policy does touch on public housing, it’s under the umbrella term of social housing, which includes both public and community housing.

Since 2002, successive NSW governments have been shifting to a privatisation model, whereby old public housing estates are sold to redevelopers, who then build larger blocks that comprise of 70 percent private apartments and 30 percent community housing.

Community housing is managed and sometimes owned by private not-for-profits, which means the government saves on upkeep, while the housing is less secure being subject to private market forces, and the redevelopments often result in less bedrooms for low-income tenants.

Advocates argue that public housing estates could be maintained but purposefully aren’t, and then the focus could be on building more. This would also better the plight of public housing tenants, who are often displaced for years during the redevelopment process, without any clear idea of their fate.

Housing affordability was a prominent issue the recent election, but both majors focused on ownership, with Labor’s government subsidies and the Coalition’s proposal to raid superannuation.

So, the 148,000 households on the public housing waiting list nationwide have bascially been forgotten.

Action for Public Housing is one of a number of groups in NSW currently calling on both federal and state governments to return to the public housing model, which could easily see the 50,000 households on this state’s waiting list housed if the right to housing was prioritised in policy.

Sydney Criminal Lawyers spoke to Action for Public Housing spokesperson Andrew Chuter.

What is the Albanese government promising in terms of public housing?

‘A lot of us public housing campaigners found it refreshing to hear Anthony Albanese talk about his public housing background in his election victory speech. It’s unfortunate though that Labor policy on housing makes no mention of public housing, only “social and affordable housing”, which is either owned or operated by private providers, where the rents are higher and the protections for tenants are weaker’.

‘Labor’s Housing Australia Future Fund is a plan to provide social housing for just one in every eight applicants currently on the waiting list over the next five years. There are many more people than that in serious housing stress or have just given up and not bothered applying for public housing.

‘Albanese has already prioritised housing in a way that the Coalition didn’t during its decade in power. The PM has appointed a minister for housing in his new cabinet. And housing minister Julie Collins portfolio also takes in homelessness’.

What are your thoughts on these developments?

‘This reflects that the housing situation has gradually gotten worse over the last decade, and sharply worse over the last three years. It became a top issue so both major parties made prominent announcements about it just before the election in a hope to win voters, which basically failed.

All the analysis, even the mainstream outlets, were critical of their policies, saying it would push up house prices.

‘For a start, we mustn’t forget too that Albanese ditched previous policy to abolish negative gearing and capital gains tax exemptions, which, they correctly argued, push house prices upwards.

‘The Help to Buy scheme was just more fuel to the fire, pumping up the private market and predicated upon government recouping costs from rising prices.

‘If I went to the USA, I’d feel proud that we have Medicare, at least some form of universal health care, but if someone visited Sydney from Vienna, where 60 percent of people live in public housing funded by a one percent income tax, I’d be ashamed of the homelessness and state of disrepair of our public housing.

‘Early last year, a coalition of NSW housing groups, including Action for Public Housing, stepped up the campaign to not only expand public housing, but to ensure that pre-existing stock is kept public rather than redeveloped into something new.

‘This was in relation to plans to redevelop two public housing estates: one in Glebe and another in South Eveleigh.

‘Since 2016, the NSW Coalition government has been redeveloping public housing estates under the state Land and Housing Corporation’s Communities Plus program. But this doesn’t seem to have the best interests of pre-existing public housing tenants as its focus’.

The full article first appeared here courtesy of www.sydneycriminallawyers.com.au

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. That will be great !!! Can I get one of these houses if on the dole?
    Do they come with a cleaner? Can I paint mine any colour
    I voted Greens and Laber or is it Labour
    I would love to live at Byron , I hear your dole office is very busy though …I have my own backpack
    Will the govt pay my rent. I am a green / teal and hate work but love free stuff
    I have hundreds of friends to bring with me. Some are on the boat right now !
    Do you have free coffee in Byron Baye? Ive seen the show and dig the chicks.
    Thinking of starting up an internet business soon as I get my free laptop and learn how to use it
    See you all soon 🙂
    Meetcha at the kebab shop

    • Looks like you need NDIS assistance as well as cheap rent Tito.
      Why not apply for a private swimming pool, yoga lessons and horse-riding lessons at the same time ?
      Then you could be well on the way to a taxpayer-funded nirvana for life.
      Even getting your lawn cut every week for free (but $200 charged to NDIS by The Provider).
      Yeah! – free stuff is everywhere Mate !

  2. Where is Tamara Smith ? Public housing is a state responsibility and she is the state representative. Her ball, her court. Nothing to do with the Feds.

  3. I’ve just been a part of several hours discussing – dare I say it – “Public Housing’s” for
    The Rivers. It’s nowhere near good enough. State & Fed governments need to keep
    their word. Too slack – that’s putting it mildly. People are hurting. Move on this Alby!

  4. If the Guv’ment stops the rorts in existing public housing there would surely be more to go around for the really needy.

  5. Love Tito’s ‘satire’.
    Public housing can take different forms. Once, public servants who served in rural areas , and some near city locations could apply for a government owned rental property ( owned by NSW Govt Real Estate which no longer exists).
    In Brisbane a similar scheme still operates where police, nurses etc get preference in renting public housing. In other parts of Qld private school systems provide accommodation for their teachers when they can get it.
    This region is rapidly approaching the situation where workers on not insignificant wages as public servants (nurses, police, teachers et al) cannot afford to rent (let alone buy) a property. But it a bit nasty blaming the recently elected ALP government for not providing ‘public’ housing in the first month after the election. They do have plans… but need some encouragement.

  6. The housing price has been inflated into a bubble by monetary policy. People are sitting on empty houses as investment. Let the market crash and they will dump them all onto the market cheap.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Where is the love?

I have lived in Mullum and the surrounding hills for 35 years.  Yesterday I drove to Upper Main Arm, to Kohinur, to visit a friend,...

Flood help information from Chinderah, and Uki to South Golden Beach

The floods in February and March are still having direct impacts on the lives of many people and Serice NSW has a trailer coming to a location near you so you can easily access flood assistance.

Weaving through NAIDOC

DJ and Delta with some of the Weaving for Reconciliation exhibits. Photo Jeff Dawson.

Management of Byron’s fragile coastline impeded by NSW government: report

Insufficient funding and guidance from the State government is inhibiting Byron Council’s attempt to effectively manage its famous but fragile coastline, a Council report has revealed.