
The world’s annual climate talkfest, COP31, is halfway through. Week one ended stuck on fossil fuels, and Australia’s main job, writing the deal text, is now underway.
Under the deal struck at COP30, is hosting the World Leaders Summit in Antalya and holds the COP31 presidency, while Australia, in the not-exactly-inspiring form of Chris Bowen, is leading the formal talks. The USA isn’t there, and neither is Germany, France or Japan, although there are a record 92,900 registered delegates, including numerous lobbyists.
Anthony Albanese’s speech at the Leaders’ Summit on Wednesday was big on accelerating electrification and delivering ‘practical results’, while mysteriously failing to mention the fossil fuels at the heart of the climate catastrophe, namely coal, oil and gas.
At a press conference on Thursday, Greta Thunberg stood next to an Indigenous advocate from the Northern Territory, Rikki Dank, who is a Gundanji and Wakaya Traditional Owner of country currently threatened by fracking of the Beetaloo Basin. She urged the Australian government to stop approving new and extended fossil fuel projects.

Asked whether she agreed with Ms Dank about Australia’s dismal record as one of the world’s leading climate chaos exporters, Greta Thunberg said, ‘Even a snail would agree with that. It’s common sense. It doesn’t get more clear than that.’
Circuses dressed up as greenwashing
Thunberg has boycotted the UN’s COP events since 2021, when she described world leaders’ promises as ‘blah blah blah.’
She says host countries use the event to make themselves look good while doing nothing of substance. Euronews Türkiye reported that she also called the summits ‘yeşil aklamayla süslenmiş sirkler’, which translates as circuses dressed up with greenwashing.
Thunberg hasn’t written off the event entirely, though. With ‘everything and everyone we love’ at stake in the climate crisis, she said the situation is now so desperate that every opportunity has to be taken to save what can still be saved.
The People’s COP March on Saturday saw 10,000 members of environmental groups, trade unions and rights organisations out on the streets, but security was tight, with protesters confined to a barricaded route 20km from the summit venue, where their voices couldn’t be heard by those enjoying the hospitality of the Australian government’s famous and well-subsidised coffee cart.
One of the main reasons Australia used to justify its central role at COP31 was its vaunted Pacific Resilience Facility pledging event, in which developed countries were expected to ramp up their pledges to close the gap on a $500 million target to directly help Pacific nations on the frontline of the climate crisis, but none of the participating countries announced any new money.
The PRF’s largest donors are Australia, which allocated $67 million, about the price of a suburban intersection upgrade, or a small bridge, and Saudi Arabia, which donated $50 million. The only new money came from Twiggy Forrest’s Minderoo Foundation, which pledged a pathetic $5 million.
Rising Tide
Meanwhile, back in Australia, despite the best efforts of NSW premier Chris Minns, the largest ever Rising Tide protest went off without a hitch in the world’s largest coal exporting port, Newcastle.
While the local media largely ignored that, instead obsessing about cricket balls and hot mic comments from Bowen and Albanese in , the world is becoming increasingly aware of the Australian government’s rank hypocrisy on climate, which is a human rights issue as much as anything.
As Amnesty International’s Kyinzom Dhongdue and others have pointed out, Australia simply cannot legitimately claim climate leadership while approving new coal and gas projects (37 since they were elected in 2022).
Perhaps Chris Bowen can stop talking up gas long enough to pull COP31 out of the fire this week, and generate a deal that amounts to something other than hot air, but based on past form, you wouldn’t want to bet on it.

Originally from Canberra, David Lowe is an award-winning filmmaker, writer and photographer with particular interests in the environment and politics. He’s known for his campaigning work with Cloudcatcher Media.



For four decades The Echo has printed the stories some people loved, some people hated, and some pretended not to read. If you want us to keep telling the truth, the real truth, not the sugar-coated version. We’ll need your support to keep the presses rolling.