17.6 C
Byron Shire
March 29, 2024

Thus Spake Mungo: Missed chances

Latest News

Retired local professor launches book on grief

A leading international thinker and researcher in the development of innovative sport coaching and physical education teaching has returned home to Byron Bay and is launching his first non-academic book, 'Grief and Growth', on April 4 at The Book Room in Byron. 

Other News

Cinema: Wicked Little Letters

Based on a true scandal that stunned 1920s England, Wicked Little Letters centres on neighbours Edith Swan and Rose Gooding in the seaside town of Littlehampton.

Seize the Decade report outlines benefits of renewables

The Climate Council says many more Australian families can directly benefit from rooftop solar and batteries under a new plan that spells out how we can electrify the nation and cut climate pollution this decade.

The Picture House is turning 8

It feels like we were only just ringing in the new year days ago and here we are approaching Easter weekend at The Brunswick Picture House. It’s already been a whirlwind start to 2024 with their biggest and busiest program so far, bringing an eclectic mix of some of the hottest stand-up comedy, music gigs, film screenings and cabaret – and that was just last week!

Workshop in Creative Writing For Beginners

Have you always felt like you have a novel in you, but don’t know where to start? Or have...

How the coral crisis affects other marine wildlife

Marine heatwaves are killing coral and denuding reefs of their colourful beauty – but in a world where everything is food for something else, these heatwaves also pose a major threat to biodiversity.

Byron Council staff baulk at councillors’ promise of free parking for locals

Will Byron Council deliver on its pledge to make parking permits free for locals across the Shire when paid parking comes into force in Brunswick Heads?

Malcolm Turnbull should have called his election months ago.

It is easy to say it in hindsight, but passing up the chance to capitalise on the all but universal wave of relief that greeted his ascension was a seriously missed opportunity.

He had every reason, every excuse: all he had to do was to say that while the party room had passed its judgment, he need a popular mandate from the voters.

And he had his double dissolution triggers ready: the abolition of the Clean Energy Finance Corporation was not an obvious choice, but the establishment of Registered Organisations was a natural: in the absence of the Building and Construction Commission, it was a serious piece of union bashing that could be guaranteed to enrage the ACTU and the ALP.

There was plenty of ammunition; while Dyson Heydon had not yet concluded his findings, there was ample public evidence that could be used to target everyone involved, including Bill Shorten. The Employment Minister, Michaelia Cash, has since said it would do very nicely for a major campaign issue.

But in any case, in this heady atmosphere the issues would be utterly irrelevant. The event would be all about the endorsement – the celebration – of the new super star. Other players would feature as mere extras; Bill Shorten would be lucky to manage a cameo performance as a fall guy.

It would not be entirely flawless — a double dissolution would not necessarily clear out the crossbenchers entirely: that would have to wait until the amending legislation could be finalised and passed ready for next time. But it would certainly weed out some of the current lot of recalcitrants, and, given Turnbull’s then stratospheric popularity, there was even a chance that it could deliver control of the senate to the coalition.

And, best of all, there was a genuine hope that in the excitement of snap election, a dispirited and disconsolate Tony Abbott might be persuaded to retire – perhaps to the cushy jog of High Commissioner to Great Britain. He would still leave behind him a grumpy rump of conservatives, but in the absence of their flag-bearer they could be dismissed as fringe-dwellers.

A glorious fantasy, and what a contrast the muddle through which Turnbull and his disillusioned colleagues will now have to navigate. It is hard to believe that they have been so unprepared; surely someone within the organisation would have pointed out the relevant dates.

For immutable technical reasons the last day a double dissolution could be called was May 11, which was, as everybody knew (or thought they knew) the day after the budget. And it could not be held until the first Saturday in a July, unless the electoral schedule was overturned and yet another half-senate election was planned for 2017 – an occurrence unattractive to the parliament and the public alike.

But then it got worse: to make sure of securing supply the budget would almost certainly have to be brought forward a week, and if that happened, it would be the clearest possible signal of an election on July 2 – two very long months away. The long campaign would be nearly unendurable and close to unaffordable.

But there is now every indication that Turnbull is going to inflict it upon us – not yet, of course, but when he gets around to it. And even before it begins, there is much unhappiness within his own ranks, and indeed across the nation.

Turnbull is seeking to bestride the path of righteous inevitability: the constitution was specifically written to deal with the problem. If there is legislation rejected by the senate twice over a period of three months, the deadlock can be broken by a double dissolution election followed by a joint sitting of both houses of parliament to resolve the impasse.

This is true, but it hardly ever happens: there have been double dissolutions aplenty, but only once has the legislative stalemate been passed at a joint sitting, in 1974 by the government of Gough Whitlam. And Turnbull’s argument for a reprise appears particularly feeble: what he trumpets as the vital need to re-establish the Building and Construction Commission has been knocked back once, but has not yet appeared on the notice paper for a second try.

Apparently it was postponed by a deal with the Greens to reform the senate voting system, a far more urgent priority required to eradicate the crossbenchers in time for, you guessed it, a double dissolution. Presumably the ABCC bill will be re-introduced when the senate sits again, and since the only real opportunity for a vote will be if the parliament is brought back on May 3, the early budget, and the early election, becomes a fait accompli.

Turnbull assures us that this is not a matter of political tactics: it is a political and constitutional necessity, driven by the purest possible motives. But no-one, not even his closest allies, believes him. The cynicism is reinforced by his ministers, who keep parroting that they are all working to a budget on May 10, but all are leaving themselves loopholes and get out clauses: well, the budget will definitely be in May and the election will be in the second half of the year – and really, July isn’t all that much earlier than September, is it?

Turnbull has every reason to dash to the polls: things are not going well and could get worse. The budget and the election will at the very least supply a circuit breaker and perhaps even a fresh start to what has been a hugely disappointing resurrection. But in the process he has appeared indecisive, mean and tricky and whatever the campaign will be meant to be about – curbing the unions, saving the country from Shorten’s reckless agenda, selling what will have to be a pretty wishy-washy budget – the interminable campaign will include mistakes, setbacks and pitfalls.

It will certainly not be the triumphal march that it was meant to be. The government is likely to be returned – first governments almost always are, and although Labor has become competitive, the late resurgence is unlikely to be enough. Turnbull will be vindicated, after a fashion, but he will be even more chastened, and probably even more cautious, than before. How different, how much better, it could have been.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

2 COMMENTS

  1. Mungo, what makes you think that Turnbull will get his ducks in a row when the Senate returns on 10 and 11 May 2016? Labor, the Greens and the Cross-Benchers have no reason to jump through hoops so Malcolm can rush off to see the GG. That’s not their jobs. They will defer debate on any interim appropriation bill (for the period after 30 June) and the ABCC Bill until, say, 12 May 2016. They won’t block supply. They won’t even debate the supply bill.
    Then Malcolm will look like the prize mug he truly is – couldn’t even organise a double dissolution.
    I’ve got the popcorn ready

  2. While it is true that first time governments are usually returned, a convention, (if that’s it’s name) predicated upon a belief the ruling government should have time to put it’s agenda in place,and to prosecute it, voters in the approaching election may feel that this government has not clearly enunciated it’s agenda to the extent that they should be allowed to fullfill it’s aims, whatever they are.

    Voters elected this Abbott/Turnbull government to rid the nation of the execrable mess Rudd/Gillard/Rudd had led it into. Abbott swept in on a tide of anger with what was, not on a sense of optimism for what might be. He had no policy, no agenda,except stop the boats, stop the carbon tax- and indeed that sufficed.The Turnbull half needs more than that. Given the reception by the electorate to the 2014 budget,suspicious and leery voters will be expecting something less mean and tricky.

    Those voters will have no compunction of turfing this government out, if they suspect that the immensely unpopular agenda Abbott/ Hockey unveiled after they had gained the Treasury benches, is to be prosecuted by Turnbull/Morrison on behalf of the IPA and other vested Corporate interests. First term or no, they will be swept from office, on the same tide of resentment and anger that got them there in the first place. That’s the way it happens in the “dog eat dog “world they had a hand in creating.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Resilient Lismore’s ‘Repair to Return’ funding

On the eve of the second anniversary of the second devastating flood in 2022, Resilient Lismore has welcomed the finalisation of its funding deed with the NSW Reconstruction Authority, which will enable the continuation of its ‘Repair to Return’ program.

Editorial – Joyous propaganda! 

The NSW Labor government marked its one year in office this week with a jubilant statement of achievements issued from Macquarie Street HQ.

Man charged over domestic violence and pursuit offences – Tweed Heads

A man has been charged following a pursuit near Tweed Heads on Monday.

Where should affordable housing go in Tweed Shire?

Should affordable and social housing in the Tweed Shire be tucked away in a few discreet corners? Perhaps it should be on the block next to where you live?