19.9 C
Byron Shire
January 24, 2022

Claims that Adani will not cost taxpayers debunked by new report

Latest News


Mick woke up this morning to a great epiphany. So, we’ve decided to forget all our activism, we’re going...

Other News

Daintree buyback sees more forest retained

Over the last two-and-a-half years the Mullumbimby based Rainforest 4 Foundation has had a mission to buy back parts of the Daintree Lowland Rainforest that were subdivided for sale in the 1980s. 

SES issues Minor Flood warning for Lismore

Moderate rainfall across the Wilsons River catchment since Wednesday has caused significant river level rises along the Wilsons River and its tributaries, which has the potential to cause minor flooding along the Wilsons River at Lismore late Friday morning.


Dear Editor, good on you for your piece reminding us about the importance of public discourse. Like you, I find...

Israel and Palestine

As an apologist for Israel, Michael Burd (Letters, 12 January) conveniently ignores the harsh truth of Israel’s brutal oppression,...

First Byron Shire Council meeting postponed

Byron Shire Council’s first meeting of newly minted councillors was to take place today, 20 January, however, the storm of COVID-19 that is taking place across the country led to it being postponed.

Food for thought?

‘The fundamental cause of the trouble,’ he wrote, ‘is that in the modern world, the stupid are cocksure while...

Paul Bibby

Adani’s claim that it did not need ‘a cent of Australian taxpayer dollars’ to fund the Carmichael coal mine has been undermined by a new report showing that it will receive billions in public money.

The briefing note from the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) estimates that the multinational will receive $4.4 billion in tax exemptions, deferrals and capital subsidies over the next three decades.

The subsidies are required because Adani has been unable to secure capital for the project from anywhere in the world.

The author of the report, IEEFA’s Tim Buckley, said the money could instead have been used to assist the transition from coal to sustainable energy alternatives by helping workers in regional communities secure long-term employment.

‘The Federal and Queensland governments have repeatedly stated the Adani mine is commercially viable and able to stand on its own two feet – while at the same time providing Adani with billions of taxpayer dollar in subsidies,’ Mr Buckley said.

‘IEEFA has concluded the Adani coal mine would not open nor survive without billions of dollars in ongoing subsidies being provided by the Queensland and Australian governments over the coming three decades.

‘Our governments’ massive subsidies should instead be funnelled into projects that help prepare and transition Australia’s regional communities, and those which are likely to generate corporate taxes for Australia.’

The briefing note reviews a number of subsidies and exemptions being awarded to Adani, including a 900 million dollar, seven-year low interest royalty capital subsidy provided by the Queensland government.

The deal, which has been subject to repeated extensions, would ensure no royalty return from the Carmichael mine into the Queensland community for a decade.

According to Mr Buckley, ‘The review also included the fuel tax credit scheme, 22 billion litres of water annually, a 90km private road (Adani claims we are wrong on this one), final void rehabilitation exemptions, and corporate tax shields.’

‘That Australian taxpayers have to shoulder high and increasing personal taxes at a time when the predominantly foreign-owned coal industry is continuing to access a billion-dollar annual diesel fuel subsidy is simply wrong.

‘IEEFA would contend the coal industry should be weaned off this diesel rebate. Fifty years of subsidies should be long enough for this sector to get to viability absent taxpayer support’, Mr Buckley said.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. Debunked… why not. Why aren’t so many of us not
    surprised. The criminality of it all backed by smiling
    premiers, an untidy toad fed. government along
    with a useless opposition? I’m about to take up a
    new religion. Seriously… it’s Hell here on earth &
    getting warmer by the second: robber barons
    applauded. May the lot of them swallow diesel
    rebates & feast on the famine of their own making.
    Lest we forget.

  2. I may not see it but the greed that manipulates politicians into making the decisions that will have cruel outcomes for the innocent in the near future is bewildering to me.
    How is it possible that these people get elected?
    Easy when the truth rarely reaches us.

  3. Unfortunately greed is the only currency acceptable to our politicians. Greed for votes. The fact that 84% of Aussies disagree or are very doubtful about Adani yet it still goes ahead is just plainly immoral. And don’t get me started on the grand theft of our precious water resources by these coal mines.
    Historically humans have always adapted. Maybe the farriers of past times had to reeducate themselves and learn to change tyres. Miners may have to actually accept that they have a responsibility to retrain themselves, forgo their jet ski lifestyles and help us all survive.
    I read where the Galilee Basin coal extraction would in itself alone raise global temperatures 2 degrees if put on the world market. How do you feel about that citizens of Adani country ?
    We get the politicians we deserve, So they say, and the numbskulls of Adani country saw to that.
    Don’t holiday in Qeensland.

  4. Adani is one of those fantastic “Can Do” projects Australia is famous for. Providing Australian Jobs, State Royalties, Federal Taxes and Export Income.
    Dont forget this project will provide reliable and cheap energy to India, energy security that we in Australia have taken for granted for decades. Congratulation Adani. We all look forward to a long and mutuall beneficial relationship.

    • Ras, what part of environmental vandalism and the existential threat of climate change have you not caught up with. You need to go and inform yourself on The Great Barrier Marine Park Authority recent report on the long term health outlook for The Great Barrier Reef where 64,000 jobs and $6.4billions pa at risk from the worsening health of The Reef. How many jobs with Adani – the only official number is 1464 admitted by Adani in 2015 in QLD Land and Environment Court when Adani was a proposed the 60million tonnes pa output. But now Adani is scaled down to 10-12 million tonnes pa. How many jobs ????? Royalties and taxes – you didn’t read the article about the $4.4billions in subsidies for Adani. India is already drowning in air pollution causing respiratory disorders and premature deaths and you think it all good that they keep the coal burners firing away. “Congratulations Adani”, you must be joking.

  5. Ah… give me a tin drum & a stick. I bolted out of QLD
    over 3 years back. Born there 74 years ago & know
    it inside out. Adani’s got Qld state government $$$ &
    3 decades of tax support in the billions from the Fed
    government. Energy for India can easily be any of the
    alternatives. This is a money-game, Ras. You can go
    & buy it in any toy shop for children – that way you
    may just help save the planet. Monopoly… it’s unjust

  6. A P.S. So much for honesty & what’s good
    for Australia let alone its ‘first peoples’. The
    Qld Government has taken Title of the land
    of the Jangalingou & the Wangan Family
    Council. What will they do next. We can
    always give all Australian lands to Adani.
    The Opera House & Canberra for starters.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Boat people we are

We here in this country, now called Australia, need to be reminded that we started off as ‘boat people’. The First Fleet arrived (including my...

Israel and Palestine

As an apologist for Israel, Michael Burd (Letters, 12 January) conveniently ignores the harsh truth of Israel’s brutal oppression, while claiming there are two...

Greens Mandy Nolan to hold community forum in support of nurses and paramedics

Locally and across the state nurses, and paramedics are struggling in the face of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic as they are being asked to do double shifts and manage effectively in health system that is struggling to cope. This has led to an increasing number of nurses and paramedics resigning.

NSW COVID update on COVID deaths – vax stats and comorbidities

NSW Premier Dominic Perrottet again opened his COVID update with condolences to families who have lost loved ones, and thanks to the  ‘inspirational work of our health workers'.