8.2 C
Byron Shire
June 18, 2024

A secret meeting and that $78m funding application

Latest News

Why have NSW Labor failed to hold their promised drug summit?

On budget eve the banner ‘Premier, you promised. Drug Summit Now’ was dropped cross from NSW Parliament calling on NSW Labor to set a date for the long awaited NSW Drug Summit.

Other News

Murwillumbah’s Budd Park – what do you want to see there?

Tweed Council is seeking community feedback on a draft concept plan to upgrade Budd Park at Murwillumbah, a popular meeting point beside the Tweed River.

Wilsons Creek Public School scoops NSW Landcare award

Wilsons Creek Public School was honoured with the Woolworths Junior Landcare Award on June 3 at the NSW Landcare Awards.

Flood-prone land subdivision DA on exhibition

A proposal by developer Callum Sked to subdivide flood-prone land near the Mullumbimby Showground is now on public exhibition on Council’s website until June 25.

Mandy Nolan’s Soapbox: A Spoonful of Sugar Really Does Help The Medicine Go Down

Making people fat is big business. Just ask the sugar industry. Making people not fat is potentially even bigger.

AI’s invisible bystanders

In her Echo column last week, Mandy Nolan recommended literature for her daughter, including classics like Catcher in the Rye and To Kill a Mockingbird. 

Call for immediate ban on logging in the proposed Great Koala National Park 

There will be no more koalas in the wild in NSW by 2050 if we don’t take action to preserve their habitat, according to a NSW state parliamentary inquiry in 2020, but the Nature Conservation Council say NSW Labor still isn’t doing enough.

Council’s Director of Infrastructure Services, Phil Holloway.

Hans Lovejoy

Answers to questions raised by Cr Basil Cameron regarding a secret meeting and a $78m funding application by staff to a federal agency to upgrade the M1 highway interchange at Byron Bay have been answered by Council’s Director Infrastructure Services, Phil Holloway.

Yet, as to be expected, his answer raises more questions than were answered.

Mr Holloway’s lengthy reply is included in the minutes of Council’s October 15 planning meeting, which are available online.

As recently reported, Cr Basil Cameron told The Echo that an application to Infrastructure Australia (IA) was made by executive staff without the knowledge of Council’s Transport and Infrastructure Advisory Committee. The implications – and its cost to taxpayers – are enormous, as it seeks to lock funding into a traffic solution without seeking all transport outcomes.

Cr Cameron says it comes at a cost that is similar to Council’s annual budget.

‘$78 million is a lot to spend on a proposal so poorly supported by data… We need to transition to sustainable transport systems that meet the needs of our community’.

Pacific Highway southbound near the Ewingsdale interchange on Tuesday, April 3, following Bluesfest. Photo David Pettifer

Transport Strategy yet to be adopted

Mr Holloway’s reply admits, ‘There is no single specific resolution’ relating to staff secretly pursuing the road upgrade funding; however, he justifies not informing the public of the application owing to ‘multiple reports, resolutions, strategic planning workshops, and email responses to questions from Councillors that address this issue’.

There also appears to be a planning inconsistency surrounding the decision, with it being made without adopted polices in place.

For example, the Draft Byron Shire Transport Strategy is currently with Transport for NSW, and is ‘not inconsistent with the expression of interest to Infrastructure Australia’.

Yet Mr Holloway also admits in the same sentence: ‘there is no presently adopted Transport Strategy’.

Council’s General Manager (GM), Mark Arnold. Photo supplied

August meeting

According to Mr Holloway’s reply, general manager Mark Arnold met with Ben Franklin MLC (Nationals) in August with to discuss traffic congestion at the M1 and MR545 interchange.

Ben Franklin MLC (Nationals) lost the Ballina seat in 2019 to incument Tamara Smith MP.

Mr Franklin, who is not the elected local MP, confirmed with The Echo, ‘Council raised the traffic congestion issue with me and advised that they were making the submission’.

It is still unclear why Council staff did not invite the elected local member, Greens MP Tamara Smith, to the meeting. Ms Smith is on the Transport and Infrastructure Advisory Committee.

Subsequently, Mr Franklin told The Echo he, ‘offered to write a letter of support, which I am always happy to do for any Council in the region to support projects that they believe are important for the local community’.

Mr Franklin did not answer the questions: ‘Are you concerned that Council staff are ignoring elected community representatives, have engaged in background political lobbying, and ignored transparent processes with regards to major infrastructure funding?’

And, ‘Were you aware this meeting was to the exclusion of elected community representatives?’

Meanwhile, Cr Cameron asked, in one of his questions to Mr Holloway, ‘Why has Byron Shire Council endorsed a proposal largely driven by a TfNSW study, with a limited study area and no analysis of what this will mean for Byron Bay and the Ewingsdale corridor beyond the study area? Why was no independent assessment undertaken?’

Mr Holloway replied, ‘As part of the stage one submission to Infrastructure Australia, Council was required to quantify the problem to demonstrate that it is nationally significant (the current definition of a problem of national significance is a threshold value of $30 million per annum). The study provided by TfNSW contained the latest data available to Council, and as a result, its data was used for the Business Cost Analysis’.

Councillor Basil Cameron. Photo David-Hancock

GM delegation

Asked by Cr Cameron what resolution of Council authorises the preparation and submission of the application to IA, Mr Holloway replied, ‘The General Manager of Byron Shire Council possesses the delegation to authorise a stage one submission’.

Echo question of apology rejected

The Echo put it to the general manager that the reply from Director Infrastructure Services, Phil Holloway, ‘indicates that the general manager has a free rein, through delegation, to engage in secret political lobbying and ignore transparent processes, the community that employs him and the elected body that is tasked with making decisions regarding the future direction of the community’.

The Echo asked, ‘Given the general manager Mark Arnold and Mr Holloway have clearly breached the trust of the community that employs them, what will the GM do to ensure that this doesn’t happen again?’

‘Will the GM apologise to the community for this? This follows on from other bungling of major infrastructure projects, including the Byron Bay Bypass’.

A reply from Council’s media spokesperson reads, ‘All staff, including the General Manager, are required to adhere to the Code of Conduct. Your assertions concerning the conduct of the General Manager and the Director Infrastructure Services are rejected in their entirety’.

According to the Code of Conduct Staff Policy 2019 (General Conduct Obligations), ‘You must not conduct yourself in a manner that: a) is likely to bring the council or other council officials into disrepute, b) is contrary to statutory requirements or the council’s administrative requirements or policies, c) is improper or unethical.

Staff are also required to ‘act lawfully and honestly, and exercise a reasonable degree of care and diligence in carrying out your functions under the LGA or any other Act. (section 439)’.

Cr Cameron: staff reply lacks clarity

Independent councillor Basil Cameron told The Echo of Mr Holloway’s reply, ‘Lengthy answers were provided on discussions within Council about Ewingsdale Road, going back to 2012; however, answers regarding the recent application focussed on the Pacific Highway interchange lacked clarity.’

‘It is a concern that Mr Franklin’s letter was addressed to the Deputy Prime Minister for an application to Infrastructure Australia, a body that is supposed to be independent.

‘Given the price tag on the application, one thing is clear: park and ride and multi-use of the rail corridor must be part of a financially and environmentally sustainable solution. It is time for all local and state representatives to acknowledge community aspirations, and get involved in making this vision a reality’.

Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.


  1. it could be a warning to Byron Council.
    There are four Councils all in financial strife, the most infamous of the four is the Central Coast Council centred on Gosford. That Council has been bailed out by the NSW government so the Council can pay staff its wages and salaries. They have overspent their quota. The trouble is the huge and increasing cost of infrastructure. A block of concrete is not cheap any more. The Council is under Review of whether it should be sacked. That decision whether the councillors will survive will be known next week and an administrator put in charge.
    On all councils there is enormous pressure by ratepayers and developers that Councils spend money and advance development in going forward. Developers push and push and put in buildings, and shopping centres and Council has to build and pay for the infrastrure. On the Central Coast the money went out and was spent by Council, and they found that did not have enough for wages and saleries.
    Good financial management is to resist the pressure to develop. Resist, and stop spending especially at a time when tourism is nearly non-existent. The tourisn dollar is not coming in like it once did.

  2. ‘Congestion… at the M1 & MR545 [Ewingsdale Rd] interchange’? What universe do these people live in? There is no congestion at the interchange. The traffic jams for town-bound traffic start from the Short Stop or sometimes the Industrial Estate. Duplication of Ewingsdale Road will do nothing to alleviate these. This whole issue raises serious questions about governance & process. Stay on the case Basil.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Questions remain unanswered over Mullum’s water strategy

Questions unanswered over Mullum’s water strategy Council’s Water and Sewer Advisory Committee (WSAC) members Ben Fawcett and Elia Hauge say their concerns around Mullum’s future...

Greens Councillor Dr Nola Firth is running for council again

Dr Nola Firth has announced that she is again running for Tweed Shire Council in the upcoming 14 September elections.  During her last term Cr...

16-year-old Mullum boy summits Imja Tse

Back in 2017, nine-year-old local boy, Finn Marshall-Rosato, became the youngest Australian to trek to Everest Base Camp, unaided and carrying all his own gear. 

Labor announces its councillor ticket

Labor councillor, Asren Pugh, and South Golden Beach local, Janet Swain will head the Byron Shire Labor team to contest the Byron Shire Council elections on September 14.