10.4 C
Byron Shire
May 20, 2024

Child sponsorship and the decolonising aid debate

Latest News

Appeal to locate man missing from Mullumbimby

Police are appealing for public assistance to locate a man missing from Mullumbimby.

Other News

North coast fire fighter honoured

It was a hot, smoky morning when Senior Deputy RFS Captain John Holmes and his comrades arrived at the Bean Creek fire, near Bonalbo.

Crime ‘cluster’ spikes spread across region

Local police are calling on residents to keep their doors and windows locked, including when they’re at home, in a bid to address the spike in car break-ins and thefts taking place in and around local shires.

Cartoon of the week – 15 May, 2024

The Echo loves your letters and is proud to provide a community forum on the issues that matter most to our readers and the people of the NSW north coast. So don’t be a passive reader, send us your epistles.

The Toad, the Whale and the Sun

Filmmaker and environmental activist Dean Jefferys will be hosting the world premiere of his epic feature documentary The Toad, the Whale and the Sun, at the Byron Community Centre on Friday, 31 May at 5pm and again at 8pm, with a panel discussion and Q+A after both screenings.

Back, bigger and better than ever

Stone & Wood’s annual Festival of the Stone is back, bigger and better than ever on Saturday, 1 June. This year is shaping up to be a huge celebration of community, music and delicious food – all for a good cause.

Can artificial intelligence be used for beach safety?

Is it time for a new approach to beach safety that utilises AI technology to tell locals and visitors where it’s safe to swim?

Carol Sherman

Having worked in the international aid and development sector for thirty years, it is good to see CEOs and their senior staff are finally engaging in discussions to end racist and paternalistic practices. It’s not a new discourse, but the murder of George Floyd shone a global spotlight on racism, and the pandemic has shifted how international non-government organisations (INGOs) work.

Those in the Global South continue to demand to be at the table when decisions are made that affect their communities, and when business models of aid that smack of colonialism are being scrutinised. 

Such connections, which put aid in the same sentence as racism, and debates on how to decolonise aid can be confronting for the well-intentioned giving public. Many who support government overseas aid and further, make individual contributions through INGOs, for instance to child sponsorship, have not grasped the extent of racism, often unconscious, and unequal power relations that occur in the very agencies they donate to.

Photo Supplied

Who sets agendas?

The non-government sector has largely avoided mainstream critique given it is often held up as an altruistic project, sometimes affiliated to faith-based agencies and staffed by selfless aid workers.

Today there are those that point to international development being a system where majority white societies with ample resources determine what ‘poor black and brown people need, how much they need, set up the parameters for delivery of what they need’ and create elaborate mechanisms for monitoring the donated funds. With blackness positioned to embody poverty and ignorance and whiteness signaling wealth, knowledge, and assistance, Eurocentric northern whiteness becomes the norm and serves as a measurement of progress.

Change needed

Systemic change on a global scale is not easy. Much is up to the political will of national governments and multilateral agencies to spearhead new ways of doing business. Major international donors, along with INGO partners, attempted to tackle imbalances in humanitarian funding in a 2016 Summit Too important to fail – addressing the humanitarian financing gap.

Five years on, little progress has occurred. Greater localisation of aid and direct funding to national and local groups is still to be achieved. However, INGOs, not only big government donors, need to reform to end their northern dominance when responding to crisis as well as longer term development. 

Photo Supplied

Diversity needed

Justice, equity, empowerment, participation, and partnerships are often at the core of INGO work. Several agencies have advertised for new staff to ensure they address racism, whether occurring through human resource pay disparities, the lack of diversity of senior management and boards, to the preferencing of westerners where national actors would be equally – or more – suitable to perform various roles.

The entire business model whereby the white way is the right way, coupled with stereotypical marketing strategies needs to be interrogated. The British charity Comic Relief was forced to stop sending celebrities to Africa for marketing purposes after people complained that stars like Ed Sheeran acted like ‘white saviors’. And although some now depict smiling, well-dressed children alongside their story of poverty, white saviour mentalities are still reinforced.

Swipe right

The popular INGO child sponsorship program is one example. Like a shopping or dating app, the INGO Compassion’s extensive web-based portfolio of children with ‘Choose Me’ emblazoned across their chest is one such site to select a child of your choice.

On a different site you will need to punch in your credit card number to get more information on the child that has appealed to you.

Programs are remarkably alike. They typically involve exchange of letters, photos, and a long-term connection allowing the sponsor an intimate view into a child’s life as their parents struggle to provide for them.

Organisations vow that the dignity of each child is assured, yet the program continues to promote an age-old stereotyped North-South divide, where contributions from the North help to save the day, and where the donor is massaged by the feel-good connection sold to them for a monthly fee.   

Options needed

Many argue that doing something is better than doing nothing. And it is. However, how we contribute needs to be interrogated.

I can vouch for many excellent programs that have been funded through child sponsorship. Yet until the root causes of poverty and global injustices are tackled in earnestness, picking children from a catalogue advertising their poverty perpetuates white saviour and colonialist attitudes in an antiquated approach to charity.

Too often the parents of a child are forced to receive these type of funds as they have no other options. Too often the focus on one child having a special relationship with the ‘wealthy’ white donor can cause angst for those who are not selected, and while the move to fund community projects has occurred in some agencies, many donors still refer to ‘their’ child and feel validated by the carefully crafted thanks and ‘good news’ stories they receive.

New initiatives

It is within the power of INGOs who run such programs to vigorously explore new fund-raising initiatives to support wide-ranging and locally designed and led programs developed in the Global South.

INGOs can step up by helping national and local organisations to have the capacity to manage larger funds for projects if greater capacity is required. They can advocate for donors to make aid administration less complicated. They can pay local groups reasonable overhead costs to ensure their sustainability. They can develop actions to hold the international development system accountable so that more equitable power relations are achieved.

Regular giving is important. However, INGOs will have to adjust their business models to ensure their role remains relevant. Power needs to shift to ensure actors in the Global South are in the driver’s seat in terms of responding to crisis and planning development – not the other way round.

Carol Sherman. Photo Supplied

Author Bio

Carol Sherman has called Byron Bay home for thirty-five years. Having worked for major INGOs across the Balkans, Asia, Africa, and the Middle East as a Country Director, she is now an independent consultant.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

1 COMMENT

  1. My experience with an IMGO in Cambodia demonstrated that their are other problems with this kind of aid also. Although all staff were ‘locals’, they were all required to renounce their religious beliefs to become converts to the NGO’s belief system. They were then treated to luxury vehicles, aircon, silk shirts, long restaurant lunches and a very good salary, whilst their target villages were dirt poor and alienated from the 2 speed economy that this creates.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Brunswick 30 has been delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour

Following successful sea trials at Yamba the Brunswick 30 was delivered to Brunswick Heads Boat Harbour on Wednesday, May 15. 

Editorial – Just another unjust moment in history

Justice has been served and it’s a shit sandwich: whistleblower David McBride is now the first person to be sentenced to jail in Australia for reporting war crimes.

What do young people want and what do they think needs to change?

The ‘Your Voice, Our Future’ survey has been launched and is asking young people to put forward their views on what is important to them. 

Conciliation meeting over Broadwater floodplain development terminated

Richmond Valley Council refused a development application for a 60-lot residential development on flood-prone land on Rileys Hill Road, Broadwater, close to the Richmond River in October 2023.