22.1 C
Byron Shire
March 28, 2024

Buyers beware of developments on a ‘1 in 100 year’ flood site

Latest News

Man charged over domestic violence and pursuit offences – Tweed Heads

A man has been charged following a pursuit near Tweed Heads on Monday.

Other News

NORPA’s wild ride at Lismore Showgrounds

NORPA is taking audiences on an adventure outside the theatre once again, announcing it will stage its original work Wildskin in a warehouse space at the Lismore Showgrounds. A sensory, destination theatre experience, Wildskin inhabits an outrageous and unpredictable world that’s part bush-thriller, part road-trip and a whole lot of NORPA’s signature theatrical style.

What the duck!

Most days I ask myself ‘what the duck’ is happening here? How could Trump be president again if he...

Saddle Road group home DA decision this week

Plans to build Byron Shire’s first permanent group home for women and children in housing stress are moving ahead, with the development application for the project coming before Council this week.

Democracy on the ropes?

The ancient idea of democracy is under threat around the world. Today, there are only 63 democracies compared to 74 autocracies, and many of these democracies are highly problematic.

Govt cost-shifting ‘erodes financially sustainable local government’

Byron Shire Council looks set to add its voice to the growing chorus calling on the state government to stop shifting responsibilities and costs onto local government.

Bay FM community radio celebrates digital upgrade

Volunteers from Byron and across the Northern Rivers celebrated nearly $100,000 worth of new studio equipment at Bay FM Community Radio station on the weekend.

Towns across the Northern Rivers, like Ballina, flooded in areas they had never flooded before during the 2022 floods. Photo David Lowe.

Flooding and damage to homes and businesses in New South Wales are as big an issue as they are in Queensland where I now live.

The recent local floods are the fault of the ongoing development practice by which buildings are permitted to be built on floodplains. The oft-cited measuring stick is the phrase: ‘1 in 100-year flood’ level clearance. This sounds exactly like the situation back where I used to live, in nearby Byron Shire.

Currently government in Australia uses the 1/100 AEP (Annual Exceedance Probability – AEP) event, or ‘1 in 100-year flood’, with an appropriate additional height for buildings this is designated as having an ‘acceptable’ risk for planning purposes, regardless of the potential consequences of a flood. Obviously, this is unsatisfactory as climate change marches ahead.

What do senior scientists think?

The Office of Queensland Chief Scientist’s website says (www.chiefscientist.qld.gov.au/publications/understanding-floods/chances-of-a-flood): ‘Currently, the one per cent AEP event is designated as having an ‘acceptable’ risk for planning purposes nearly everywhere in Australia. However, good planning needs to consider more than just the one per cent AEP flood.’

The report added ‘one per cent annual exceedance probability (or one per cent AEP), are preferred because they avoid the common misconception that a “1 in 100-year flood” for example, can only occur once every 100 years; or that you are “safe” for another 100 years after you experience such an event. For example, in Kempsey, NSW, major floods approaching the one per cent AEP level occurred in 1949 and then again a year later in 1950.’

A recent example is the sorry experience of someone who in July last year, bought and upgraded a small regional store near Gympie. Only six months later they were devastated when the flooding rose up to halfway up the two-storey building. And it happened again in the recent floods! The owner had been assured that the site was robust as per ‘1/100 AEP’.

The same flooding happened on a nearby greenfield land, which has a DA already approved by Gympie Council. When asked, the developer quickly said, ‘Development Application had met the “1/100 years” rule. So the development can go ahead.’

Mathematically calculated by hydrological engineers

On checking on this flooding issue with Gympie’s Regional Council, their Director of Community Sustainability, Adrian Burns, explained, ‘A 1/100 flood event is an event that is mathematically calculated by hydrological engineers… [The] development must meet the requirements that were assigned at the time of the assessment [in this case, back in 2013 when the DA was originally approved].  Please note that the buying and selling of land has no council involvement. Additional requirements cannot be placed on an already approved development applications in the future, should certain benchmarks, such as flooding, change.’

In other words, for existing developers with an approved DA, ‘no worries’. But buyers, beware! The recent approval of mega-development of the ‘locals’ West Byron DA is based on the same gob-smacking legal logic.


Support The Echo

Keeping the community together and the community voice loud and clear is what The Echo is about. More than ever we need your help to keep this voice alive and thriving in the community.

Like all businesses we are struggling to keep food on the table of all our local and hard working journalists, artists, sales, delivery and drudges who keep the news coming out to you both in the newspaper and online. If you can spare a few dollars a week – or maybe more – we would appreciate all the support you are able to give to keep the voice of independent, local journalism alive.

6 COMMENTS

  1. Maybe intending buyers of houses here should be aware on whether the property can be insured or not. According to an on line form, my house is now not insurable.

    • John, spot on comment.
      The Insurance Industry is well ahead of the game with ‘insurance risk’.
      If someone has a property and can’t get insurance or if you can get insurance that is prohibitively expensive, then that is a tell tale sign that the ‘risk’ to property is very very real.

  2. We have been representing litigation for nearly 5 years to stop a major development on the Dunoon Road
    floodplain. This development is Stage 1 for the North Lismore Plateau proposal.

    This development if allowed to proceed is a scam, uninsurable , inundated and was isolated in 2017 and 2022.

    Lismore Council approved it last year fully knowing this is the case and now are supporting the developer to try and strike out the proceedings before a hearing of the evidence.

    Add in the 30 million plus of borrowed money for supporting infrastructure for the development the problem is deep rooted and those unfortunates who are sold this lolly will suffer,

  3. Tweed shire has online 1:50 and 1:100 flood mapping overlays that can be accessed for free on their website for public information.
    Whilst flood and weather prediction is not, and never will be, an exact science it is relatively simple to check flooding potential prior to purchase.
    Perhaps Byron Shire and others could also offer this service? It’s not a guarantee, but it’s certainly ruled out a number of properties for us.
    Having the sense to look at property without rose tinted glasses, and figure out that if the land is flat, and/or there’s a waterway, watercourse, etc., nearby into likely to flood would also be helpful.
    Also, get a geotech engineer to do you a report before buying on hills, sometimes they’re not going to stay put.
    So much property around here is ridiculously overpriced for the hazards that will be faced.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Where should affordable housing go in Tweed Shire?

Should affordable and social housing in the Tweed Shire be tucked away in a few discreet corners? Perhaps it should be on the block next to where you live?

Making Lismore Showground accessible to everyone

The Lismore Showground isn’t just a critical local community asset that plays host to a number of major events each year, but has also been used as an evacuation centre during past natural disasters in the region. 

Iconic Lennox beach shed upgraded –  not demolished

Lennox Park and the shelter shed has now been upgraded and reopened.

Govt cost-shifting ‘erodes financially sustainable local government’

Byron Shire Council looks set to add its voice to the growing chorus calling on the state government to stop shifting responsibilities and costs onto local government.